Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by zacharypinter on Friday October 31, 2008 @01:39PM
(#350137)
This could serve as a great example of illustrating the difference between theft and copyright infringement.
Theft would be stealing somebody's Lamborghini. Copyright infringement is building your own.
The standard argument against copyright infringement is that Lamborghini lost a sale by him building his own. However, how likely is it that he would have bought a Lamborghini if he could not build one?
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by antiismist on Friday October 31, 2008 @02:47PM
(#350223)
I'm not sure that this is a great example, because it muddies the difference between trademarks, copyrights, and patents (i.e. there may be issues with all three here, and maybe the biggest issue is on the trademark side).
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by electromagnetic on Friday October 31, 2008 @04:08PM
(#350313)
Actually it doesn't have a single thing to do with copyright as it isn't a creative work, it's solely under a patent. As long as he doesn't go around calling it a "Lamborghini Countach" he isn't breaking any trademark laws.
Finally a patent only extends to cover something that is in itself patentable. Nintendo is taking forever to get patents on it's DS game cartridges because they're based off of an SD card. If its not found to be useful or inventive then it's not patentable.
Inherently most vehicles are non-patentable as they all serve an identical purpose and relatively few are at all inventive.
Quite simply a patent can be invalidated by someone simply inventing it themselves, which turns something from 'original' to 'obvious' and thus non-patentable.
Vehicle patents are very complicated to enforce, namely because if anyone ever tries to enforce one they can actually end up getting it invalidated (which in patent law, abolition happens more than enforcement). Lamborghini might not be able to enforce a single patent because a court might find it an obvious improvement over Henry Ford's original patent or is outright patent infringement of Fords. It's a serious lose-lose business.
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by ken on Friday October 31, 2008 @05:21PM
(#350361)
> Inherently most vehicles are non-patentable as they all serve an identical purpose and relatively few are at all inventive.
I would guess Lamborghini is one of the few that does. Look up "design patent" in wikipedia: "a patent granted on the ornamental design of a functional item". If the shape and components of a top sports car don't meet this description, it's hard to imagine what would.
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by hugh on Friday October 31, 2008 @08:59PM
(#350490)
Well, that's interesting. Looking further into it, the Countach had been built since 1974, but they never applied for this US design patent until Lamborghini was bought by Chrysler in 1989. By 1992, when it was actually granted, the Countach had already been discontinued.
Wait... looking at the pictures again, I'm pretty sure that's actually the Lamborghini Diablo -- that would make more sense with respect to the timing, since it was made from 1990 to 2001.
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by electromagnetic on Saturday November 01, 2008 @02:18PM
(#350825)
Well I suppose most sports car designs do fall into unique looks, so I understand how they'd be able to patent the exterior design, but the machine inside would likely never hold up in court.
If the guy had built an old sedan he wouldn't have a worry in the world about the exterior design as the amount of chassis sharing between companies they're all inherently the same. I do believe you're right though, the patents on the 'ornamental design' seem valid, but as you stated virtually any vehicle design patent seems invalid if it was made before 1994.
I'm wondering if vehicle manufacturers allow these patents to die off after 14 years to allow people to rebuild classics. I mean what would the public reaction be like if Ford sued someone for patent infringement because they fixed up a classic Mustang and couldn't get all the Ford manufactured parts.
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by dpatru on Friday October 31, 2008 @06:30PM
(#350423)
> Quite simply a patent can be invalidated by someone simply inventing it themselves, which turns something from 'original' to 'obvious' and thus non-patentable.
Just because an invention is re-invented, or invented independently more or less at the same time, does not mean it is unpatentable, obvious, or that an already granted patent is invalid. At most it is evidence of obviousness.
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by antiismist on Friday October 31, 2008 @06:14PM
(#350407)
There are lots of patents on car parts, for example intermittent wipers or a way of connecting the door to the frame of the car. I'm pretty sure Lamborghini has a few patents like that around.
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by hugh on Friday October 31, 2008 @09:02PM
(#350491)
A car is not an original work of authorship. A picture of the car is...
Why not? A car is a sculpture which just happens to be banged out of sheet metal instead of carved out of marble.
Admittedly it's hard to think of a Toyota as a sculpture, but a Lamborghini is definitely one. And a damn lot better looking than most of the sculptures you'll see in galleries.
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by hugh on Friday October 31, 2008 @08:47PM
(#350486)
Exactly. If instead of just copying a DVD, you hired actors, cameras, lighting and props and made a short-by-shot remake of your favourite movie, and then promised not to make any further copies of it, you'd be analogous to this guy.
Or, I'm reminded of that guy in that Borges story who spends his whole life trying to rewrite Don Quixote from scratch.
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by bena on Friday October 31, 2008 @03:57PM
(#350296)
Not really. He still had to go through the process of creating something. He still needed to buy and assemble materials. He didn't just borrow someone's Lambo and throw it in a matter replicator.
In copyright infringement cases, people are making exact duplicates without having to work to produce those duplicates. When someone makes a copy of a picture/song/program, they get all of the benefit without having to reward or acknowledge the effort that went into producing the original.
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by LogicHoleFlaw on Friday October 31, 2008 @05:57PM
(#350397)
Just a quick note: The amount of work or effort which went into producing a work is not legally relevant to its status under copyright. This, for instance, is why mere lists of facts are not copyrightable. In Feist Publications v. Rural Telephone Service ( http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Feist_Publications_v._Rural_Tel... ) the "sweat of the brow" doctrine was soundly dismissed.
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by Retric on Friday October 31, 2008 @05:34PM
(#350375)
In most cases you still need to pay money to the songs author to legally be a cover band. The way things are setup he probably broke the law in such a way that he can get away with it. (AKA, they are not going to sue because it's good press and they might sell logos / parts to other people doing this.)
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by viae on Friday October 31, 2008 @12:44PM
(#350079)
It's actually possible to do this with 1st generation Camaros (1967-69). Someone thought ahead and saved the original tool and die casts before GM destroyed them. Some googling will find you sources for parts: from frame and body to seats adn trim. From what I've read, it costs somewhere in the realm of 12-20k. Not bad for a clone of what is the most fantastic American muscle car to ever be made with modern reliability.
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by sown on Friday October 31, 2008 @03:07PM
(#350246)
There's a company (http://www.ultimasports.co.uk/canam/index.html) that sells kit super-cars. According to them it takes 40 - 80 hours to put together what is essentially a car that is 95% as good as some Italian machine but at 10% of the cost. Not bad considering what you are getting.
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by jcromartie on Friday October 31, 2008 @02:03PM
(#350171)
Assembling a batch of nice fresh parts is a lot easier than you think. Unless you have to assemble/rebuild the whole engine by hand, you will probably spend more time waiting for the paint to dry than you will putting it all together.
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by tapostrophemo on Saturday November 01, 2008 @02:00AM
(#350601)
Not necessarily; ever put together one of those Saga electric guitar kits? I've spent maybe 5-10% (out of maybe 15-20 total build time) tweaking and adjusting, finding they didn't drill all the holes in the right places, etc.
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by noonespecial on Friday October 31, 2008 @02:09PM
(#350179)
To me the coolest part would be the ramp and the new door in the basement. Ordinary Ken slips down to the basement of his ordinary suburban house and, like the bat cave, a Lambo comes roaring up out of the secret lair! Sweet.
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by rrhyne on Friday October 31, 2008 @02:36PM
(#350207)
I think this is kind of a shame. The guy has insane amounts of motivation, insane skills, and even funding for his project, yet he makes a copy of something else.
Seems all he was lacking was a great original idea.
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by vaksel on Friday October 31, 2008 @01:53PM
(#350154)
if I was hand building a car from scratch I'd try for something a little bit more exotic. Fiero kit car Coutnachs are all over the place(not really, but its a pretty common kit).
Personally I'd go for something like an F50, because the kit cars for those usually look like ass because the dimensions are way off since the donor cars are shorter.
But still huge props from the guy, it probably took him 5-6 years to finish this(unless he was doing it full time)
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by vaksel on Friday October 31, 2008 @02:51PM
(#350227)
ah..makes sense that its not an F50 then...they were around from 95-97, so they weren't around when he started. F40s were around since 87, but I bet the behind the scenes prep work for the Countach took him a couple of years too so they were probably not around as well.
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by tlrobinson on Saturday November 01, 2008 @04:49AM
(#350638)
"Once he finished the car there was one itsy-bitsy problem; the fact that the faux Lambo was built in the basement meant that there was no conventional way to take it outside of the house..."
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by tapostrophemo on Saturday November 01, 2008 @02:03AM
(#350602)
Cool...still, I couldn't help but think that having to cut a large hole in the foundation to get it out showed something of a lack of planning and foresight. :-(
Re:Man hand-builds Lamborghini Countach, from scratch, in hi...
by nuclear_eclipse on Friday October 31, 2008 @01:21PM
(#350122)
The wood is only there while fashioning the sheet metal for the body. The wood was then removed and replaced with the frame and suspension from a Corvette.
Theft would be stealing somebody's Lamborghini. Copyright infringement is building your own.
The standard argument against copyright infringement is that Lamborghini lost a sale by him building his own. However, how likely is it that he would have bought a Lamborghini if he could not build one?
Finally a patent only extends to cover something that is in itself patentable. Nintendo is taking forever to get patents on it's DS game cartridges because they're based off of an SD card. If its not found to be useful or inventive then it's not patentable.
Inherently most vehicles are non-patentable as they all serve an identical purpose and relatively few are at all inventive.
Quite simply a patent can be invalidated by someone simply inventing it themselves, which turns something from 'original' to 'obvious' and thus non-patentable.
Vehicle patents are very complicated to enforce, namely because if anyone ever tries to enforce one they can actually end up getting it invalidated (which in patent law, abolition happens more than enforcement). Lamborghini might not be able to enforce a single patent because a court might find it an obvious improvement over Henry Ford's original patent or is outright patent infringement of Fords. It's a serious lose-lose business.
I would guess Lamborghini is one of the few that does. Look up "design patent" in wikipedia: "a patent granted on the ornamental design of a functional item". If the shape and components of a top sports car don't meet this description, it's hard to imagine what would.
In fact, it's not too hard to find automobile patents, e.g., http://www.google.com/patents?id=XR87AAAAEBAJ (DeLorean) or http://www.google.com/patents?id=TvZ7AAAAEBAJ (Lotus?) -- but these patents seem to have a 14-year term, so even if Lamborghini did patent this shape, the patent (at least in the USA) has probably expired by now.
Wait... looking at the pictures again, I'm pretty sure that's actually the Lamborghini Diablo -- that would make more sense with respect to the timing, since it was made from 1990 to 2001.
If the guy had built an old sedan he wouldn't have a worry in the world about the exterior design as the amount of chassis sharing between companies they're all inherently the same. I do believe you're right though, the patents on the 'ornamental design' seem valid, but as you stated virtually any vehicle design patent seems invalid if it was made before 1994.
I'm wondering if vehicle manufacturers allow these patents to die off after 14 years to allow people to rebuild classics. I mean what would the public reaction be like if Ford sued someone for patent infringement because they fixed up a classic Mustang and couldn't get all the Ford manufactured parts.
Just because an invention is re-invented, or invented independently more or less at the same time, does not mean it is unpatentable, obvious, or that an already granted patent is invalid. At most it is evidence of obviousness.
And I agree about trademark being the biggest issue, perhaps coupled with infringement on design patents held by Lamborghini.
No matter what this guy has an extremely strong personal use defense. He has zero effect on the market and is not distributing.
Why not? A car is a sculpture which just happens to be banged out of sheet metal instead of carved out of marble.
Admittedly it's hard to think of a Toyota as a sculpture, but a Lamborghini is definitely one. And a damn lot better looking than most of the sculptures you'll see in galleries.
I stand corrected. Lamborghini and Toyota would have valid copyrights in their design, even if the Toyota is relatively boring.
Personal use defenses still stand however...
Or, I'm reminded of that guy in that Borges story who spends his whole life trying to rewrite Don Quixote from scratch.
In copyright infringement cases, people are making exact duplicates without having to work to produce those duplicates. When someone makes a copy of a picture/song/program, they get all of the benefit without having to reward or acknowledge the effort that went into producing the original.
This guy is more like a cover band than Napster.
Seems all he was lacking was a great original idea.
I dunno. Maybe he wasn't lacking it? Maybe he had one and it wasn't what he wanted? Maybe what he wanted was a Lamborghini?
Personally I'd go for something like an F50, because the kit cars for those usually look like ass because the dimensions are way off since the donor cars are shorter.
But still huge props from the guy, it probably took him 5-6 years to finish this(unless he was doing it full time)
That's some extreme lack of foresight...
This is his site and has bigger pics. You'll see how he used the wooden frame.