News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by paxys on Thursday March 02, 2023 @01:47PM (#34999980)
The surest sign of a failed system is people in power justifying it as "this is our culture". You could send a letter with a formal address in San Jose 30 years ago and it would get delivered. Today it likely will not. This has nothing to do with culture or nostalgia, but rather a breakdown in urban planning and failing to deal with population growth.
Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by hadlock on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:01PM (#35000169)
My uncle used to live on an old ranch road in west Texas. It didn't really go anywhere just connected to larger roads together, probably 20 miles long and kind of wound through a couple of minor valleys. Eventually all the road frontage on that road slowly got sliced up in to parcels for mini-ranches of 30-90 acres, the county sort of numbering them as they went along. Eventually the numbering system on that road got so messed up, someone called for an ambulance and died because the ambulance couldn't find the house.

A month later the county formally renumbered the whole road and each mailbox has a bright new blue 6x12" "house number" reflective sign. This meant they had to go through the property records and redraw all the plats with the new labels.

I don't have any idea how a city or country can do any kind of property taxation without formal addresses. Or a census. Or transfer of Real Property. There must not exist any kind of title insurance because without property and tax records you can't keep track of who owns what. I'm curious if the author consulted the tax office because street names are critical to the relation of ownership of property to physical location. Occasionally property records will reference "iron spike at corner of property" but those aren't definitive and move/get lost. Streets rarely change location or get lost.

Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by leesalminen on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:22PM (#35000493)
I own property in Costa Rica.

From what I understand, property records, taxes & ownership were a huge problem up until ~10 years ago when all the disparate property record systems were merged into a nationalized, computerized, property record system.

To pay my property taxes, I just log into my county's website and pay with a Visa card. It's very easy.

Our property record uses GPS coordinates and relative distances from those points to determine the boundaries of the property. It's common to have the surveyors with their fancy laser & GPS machines come out during due diligence in a real estate transaction.

It feels pretty similar to the rest of the world now, though it hasn't always been this way.

Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by hadlock on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:25PM (#35000543)
Thanks for your ground-truth insight. Does your county offer a "plat" where you can view your property plat number, and adjoining parcels? Surely it includes a road if your property has road frontage? I'm not sure how other countries handle it but in the US at least, seems to be fairly standardized from state to state with all of this information written on it.
Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by leesalminen on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:29PM (#35000622)
Yes, it does. They call them a "plano". You can examine this all online in the national property registry.

Entering a property ID number will let you see the drawing of property lines, road frontages, concessions, etc. Can also see the ownership & transfer history, any liens, unpaid taxes, etc.

The website also gives you links to the neighboring properties and you can view those as well.

The website is only in Spanish and was built circa-2010 with circa-2005 UX, but it works, mostly.

Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by blevin on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:37PM (#35000730)
Respectfully, and acknowledging this is a nitpicking tangent: “died because the ambulance couldn’t find them” reads like an unintended direct attribution. Presumably they died because of something else, but might have been saved had the ambulance been able to find them, as part of a subsequent chain of actions to provide lifesaving intervention.
Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by verelo on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:40PM (#35000793)
You’re totally correct in saying this but here’s some unrequited advice: never speak this way to your significant other!
Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by sokoloff on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:57PM (#35001077)
> This meant they had to go through the property records and redraw all the plats with the new labels...I don't have any idea how a city or country can do any kind of property taxation without formal addresses.

The legal record for one of my past houses was by Map and Plat number, not by street address. There is a mapping table between street address and tax lot, but it's not the legal record of the land. (That particular parcel was last changed in the early 1800s, but it seems like all of them are by what amounts to a locally unique identifier and then has an address mapped to it.)

Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by Taniwha on Thursday March 02, 2023 @04:13PM (#35002164)
I grew up on a street in a suburb that had originally been laid out by 'surveyors' in the colonising country on the other side of the world - it cut through a bunch of hillocks and a ravine and was chopped into 3 pieces ... we lived on the small middle piece ..... one day the local volunteer fire brigade got lost, we solved the problem by renaming our bit to be the same as another road that connected with it - the numbers didn't overlap so we kept them
Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by Kon-Peki on Thursday March 02, 2023 @04:20PM (#35002238)
> I don't have any idea how a city or country can do any kind of property taxation without formal addresses

In most of the US, property identification is entirely independent from a mailing address: your property identification is a completely unique description deriving from a series of land subdivision based on the Land Ordinance of 1785

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Public_Land_Survey_System

Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by tonyarkles on Thursday March 02, 2023 @07:51PM (#35004308)
Western Canada has something similar to that too. Southern Saskatchewan (where most people live) is divided into a 1-mile grid. One of the things that still amazes me is that this mapping was started in 1871 using chains, compasses, and a couple other instruments... and as it turns out it was exceptionally accurate!
Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by Kon-Peki on Thursday March 02, 2023 @09:36PM (#35005130)
> Southern Saskatchewan (where most people live) is divided into a 1-mile grid.

1 square mile is 640 acres. That’s exactly the same size as a “section” in the US survey system. If I remember correctly, the smallest unit you could buy directly from the government was 1/8th of a section - a 40 acre square.

Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by tonyarkles on Sunday March 05, 2023 @08:01PM (#35036214)
Oh nice, yeah we call them sections as well. I think quarters were the smallest you could get around here.
Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by readthenotes1 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @04:29PM (#35002347)
And I last lived in texas, the official location of my property had nothing to do with the postal address. Since the postal address is a federal invention, I'm pretty sure more local governments don't use them for property tax or other identification.
Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by cafard on Thursday March 02, 2023 @06:33PM (#35003597)
The Department of Homeland Security paid out a lot of money for the standardization of addresses. Plenty of people who used to have RR (Rural Route) 4 for an address now have a five or six-digit house number, calculated from the center of the nearest town that somebody thought should be counted.
Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by SN76477 on Thursday March 02, 2023 @02:14PM (#35000374)
Is the word culture being used to replace "we don't want to change, don't think about change and are stubborn"?
Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by tablespoon on Thursday March 02, 2023 @03:48PM (#35001825)
> The surest sign of a failed system is people in power justifying it as "this is our culture".

Maybe sometimes, but it's a different kind of failure when culture is demanded to accept any change imposed on it by some "system."

I can see some value systems where Costa Rica's address system is stupid and unjustifiable (and those value systems are very common among software engineers [1]), but I can also see value systems were it isn't (e.g. ones that value many things that "modernity" discarded in favor of technocracy).

[1] e.g. the value system of a former colleague of mine, who seriously believed that time zones should be abolished in favor of people using UTC for their daily life, mainly so it would be easier to handle time in software systems.

Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by ChainOfFools on Thursday March 02, 2023 @08:09PM (#35004482)
your colleague is in sorta-ish good company, considering that nearly every famous mathematician alive during the French Revolution was advocating for some form of time comparable to the metric standard [0], using base 10 instead of 12 or 60. They were making the 18th century equivalent to the utc standardization argument today. And arguably on similarly sensible grounds that it made basic clock math slightly less exposed to simple error.

0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decimal_time?wprov=sfla1

Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by tablespoon on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:04AM (#35011356)
> your colleague is in sorta-ish good company

Not really. He was making a pretty serious error of not really understanding the "users," prioritizing his esoteric concerns over arguably more important ones, essentially forcing his users to serve his system instead of building the system for them.

Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by ChainOfFools on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:12AM (#35011441)
"if i asked my customers what they wanted, they would have said faster horses." - Henry Ford
Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by tablespoon on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:22AM (#35011602)
> "if i asked my customers what they wanted, they would have said faster horses." - Henry Ford

I think a more apropos Ford quote would be the "you can have any color you want, as long as it's black," but that still doesn't capture it.

It's one thing to present something that meets the needs of your customers that they didn't anticipate, it's quite another to ignore those needs and just force the thing you want on them at great cost. He was only concerned with software engineers writing less time conversion logic, and cherry-picking to try to justify that idea. If you think about it, the whole thing is crazy and backwards, given how people use time 99% of the time and who is better at arithmetic.

Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by garbagecoder on Thursday March 02, 2023 @04:19PM (#35002235)
I'd rather have roads fixed than labeled. CR has the worst roads in the OECD but the roads in the GAM are much much better than where I live. Last time I was in Atenas, I noticed they have street signs. Gee, I wonder why.

For the Americans out there, I have to look at a Facebook page to see if a road near me is open or flooded too much to pass. Otherwise, I have to go an hour around.

People use Waze and other stuff to find places and there isn't a lot of letter sending these days, so while I agree with you that brushing this off as culture is an excuse for the corruption, I don't really see this as one of our top challenges either.

not much point in knowing where you're going if you can't get there

Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by smallerfish on Thursday March 02, 2023 @04:27PM (#35002328)
> I have to look at a Facebook page to see if a road near me is open or flooded too much to pass

We also had 300" of rain last year, which is ...pretty extreme. I thought the infrastructure held up remarkably well given the rainfall.

Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by throwawaylinux on Thursday March 02, 2023 @08:20PM (#35004566)
A lot of places in tropical / monsoonal climates get seasonal flooding and roads regularly becoming impassible with flooding and slips and washouts etc, even in "developed" countries. I imagine places that get a lot of snow have similar issues. That doesn't make precise and unambiguous addresses less important than in other parts of the world!
Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by garbagecoder on Friday March 03, 2023 @11:27AM (#35011662)
Not saying it does, but we can't afford to do everything. The OECD has said the roads are a huge drag on our growth. The biggest problem was a massive corruption scandal surrounding the improvement of the main highway for the whole country. It's getting done, but years late.
Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by throwawaylinux on Monday March 06, 2023 @03:16AM (#35038646)
Presumably the choice is not roads or sane addresses though. Costa Rica is an upper-middle income country with the GDP per capita of China, for crying out loud. And poor addressing systems are also considered to have a huge economic drag.
Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by smallerfish on Thursday March 02, 2023 @04:20PM (#35002240)
I live in CR, well outside of the GAM. There's simply no mail service out here, so there's no need for mailing addresses. Amazon will ship to the tourist info center in town, and you can pick up packages there. Otherwise...I really don't miss mail.
Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by leesalminen on Friday March 03, 2023 @02:28PM (#35013922)
Are you in Uvita? Just how you say the tourist info center in town...sounds like me ;). Hit me up! Contact in bio
Re:Why doesn't Costa Rica use real addresses? by TMWNN on Friday March 03, 2023 @02:41AM (#35006883)
Agreed. Even worse is that, as the article says, there used to be a formal address system:

>The explanation came from Geovanny Campos of Correos de Costa Rica, the company that manages the country's postal service. As he told Luis Fernando, San José’s growth was characterized by disorder. As the city expanded without following a pattern of rectangular city blocks, the established street numbers stopped making sense.

>Eventually, nobody used them.

Good grief. That's a failed system; like South Africa's electrical system, something that worked 10-20-30 years in the past but no longer does, because people (speaking in the aggregate) don't care enough to/are no longer able to keep it running.

I also found hadlock's and others' anecdotes enlightening. I'd vaguely had the idea that it was one of the small success stories of Latin America; all those Reddit TILs about how "Costa Rica abolished its army in the 1940s" and "Costa Rica last year ran 100% on renewable power for months". I am aware that Intel has a plant there. I know that Costa Rica supplies relatively few of the illegal aliens streaming across the US's southern border. Etc., etc. Welp.

(Of course, that last fact implies that CR, despite its woes, is still better off than much of the rest of Latin America, which itself says something.)