News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:No, 15-Minute Cities Aren’t a Threat to Civil Liberties by leereeves on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @02:46AM (#34966733)
Nobody is objecting to the idea of a walkable city. People object to the part where they won't be allowed to travel without a permit.

I quoted this in another comment but I think it's worth repeating:

"When [the traffic filters] are operating, private cars will not be allowed through the filters without a permit."[1]

"Residents [of the area affected by the traffic filters] will be able to apply for a permit to drive through the traffic filters for up to 100 days per year"[1]

1: https://www.oxfordshire.gov.uk/sites/default/files/file/road...

Re:No, 15-Minute Cities Aren’t a Threat to Civil Liberties by renewiltord on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @03:40AM (#34967076)
Seems a little fairer than the San Francisco strategy which excludes certain rich neighborhoods from outside car traffic (they can still drive there) but they can drive to anywhere they want. They call it Slow Streets.
Re:No, 15-Minute Cities Aren’t a Threat to Civil Liberties by defrost on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @03:00AM (#34966819)
That's about restricting private car access to high traffic shopping streets | parish centres, etc.

People are still allowed to travel, to travel in private cars around those zones, and to travel in those zones on foot, by bus, or in a commercial vehicle delivering goods, etc.

Claiming this equates to people "won't be allowed to travel without a permit" is delibrately misleading.

Re:No, 15-Minute Cities Aren’t a Threat to Civil Liberties by leereeves on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @03:06AM (#34966860)
> That's about restricting private car access to high traffic shopping streets | parish centres, etc.

According to the linked report, it's about:

"Encouraging a change in behaviour to tackle private car use"

The headline targets include replacing or removing 50% of car trips and delivering a net-zero transport network by 2040.

Re:No, 15-Minute Cities Aren’t a Threat to Civil Liberties by thecopy on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @03:53AM (#34967148)
That is great. Private car use is insanely inefficient, and has numerous negative externalities like toxic gas exhaust, increasing the risk of injury to people not in a car, and rubber particulates.
Re:No, 15-Minute Cities Aren’t a Threat to Civil Liberties by aww_dang on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @03:05AM (#34966853)
>"Residents [of the area enclosed by the traffic filters] will be able to apply for a permit to drive through the traffic filters for up to 100 days per year"[1]
Re:No, 15-Minute Cities Aren’t a Threat to Civil Liberties by morelisp on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @02:50AM (#34966754)
> People object to the part where they won't be allowed to travel without a permit.

If you stop and reflect for a few seconds you likely are already aware of this, but you already cannot drive a car anywhere in the city without a permit.

Re:No, 15-Minute Cities Aren’t a Threat to Civil Liberties by leereeves on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @02:56AM (#34966798)
Accepting that restriction doesn't mean we have to accept any and all restrictions.

That said, I'm not familiar with UK driver's licenses - do they normally restrict where and when you can travel?

Re:No, 15-Minute Cities Aren’t a Threat to Civil Liberties by arethuza on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @03:14AM (#34966918)
UK driving licenses are extremely restrictive - the areas where you are allowed to drive are actually quite narrow, though they are quite long and occasionally do connect together.
Re:No, 15-Minute Cities Aren’t a Threat to Civil Liberties by rexpress on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @03:49AM (#34967125)
But they will be able to travel without a permit, it's just that those journeys may need to be rerouted to take a less direct route to avoid the traffic filters.

Traffic filters are not new to the UK, and plenty have existed for decades in cities like London without controversy or conspiracy. They do not form an impermeable cordon around an area.

They restrict through traffic on certain streets, in order to provide faster and safer routes for either bikes or buses. As far as I can tell the Oxford proposal is less restrictive than traditional filters as permits allow car driver to bypass the restrictions a certain number of times a month.

Re:No, 15-Minute Cities Aren’t a Threat to Civil Liberties by leereeves on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @05:39AM (#34967841)
> those journeys may need to be rerouted to take a less direct route to avoid the traffic filters.

I don't know enough about Oxfordshire to be sure, but it seems unlikely that the goal here is simply to move the traffic to different streets - especially after they said the goal is to eliminate 50% of car traffic.

Re:No, 15-Minute Cities Aren’t a Threat to Civil Liberties by TheCoelacanth on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @09:52AM (#34969900)
By making other modes of travel more convenient. They aren't outlawing those trips.
Re:No, 15-Minute Cities Aren’t a Threat to Civil Liberties by cmh89 on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @07:15PM (#34976901)
Wow! You must be against drivers licenses as well I assume, as they permit you to operate a motor vehicle.
Re:No, 15-Minute Cities Aren’t a Threat to Civil Liberties by leereeves on Wednesday March 01, 2023 @01:59AM (#34979527)
If driver's licenses were limited to driving 100 days per year, and used as a tool to eliminate 50% of car trips, I certainly would be against them.
Re:No, 15-Minute Cities Aren’t a Threat to Civil Liberties by cmh89 on Wednesday March 01, 2023 @11:30AM (#34984223)
That's fine, you have the right to advocate for a dead city all you want.

Your characterization of this as not being "allowed to travel without a permit" is utter nonsense made to make something rather routine and benign sound like Nazi Germany.

We restrict where, by whom, and how motor vehicles and literally every other form of transportation is used all the time.