News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:France's Baby Bust by swarnie on Sunday February 26, 2023 @06:43AM (#34944803)
I understand this is an America-centric forum but does religion play a major role in politics in the rest of the western world?

I'm counting back though prime ministers and i can't recall one who made religion a major part of their platform in my lifetime.

Re:France's Baby Bust by AlchemistCamp on Sunday February 26, 2023 @07:33AM (#34945036)
> does religion play a major rile in politics in the rest of the western world?

Hasn’t the growth of Islam in Europe been a large and growing political issue for the past decade?

France in particular has had lot of debates about religious clothing at schools, what kind of criticism of religious ideas is and isn’t acceptable, etc.

From my POV, it looks like religion is a bigger deal in European than American politics. In America, politics are the religion for many and marrying across political lines now carries more opposition than across religious ones, for the majority of people. Things have changed quite a bit since the 80s.

Re:France's Baby Bust by mtts on Sunday February 26, 2023 @08:02AM (#34945192)
> Hasn’t the growth of Islam in Europe been a large and growing political issue for the past decade?

Probably more like two decades by now :-) The political parties in Europe that pride themselves on anti-Islamism are themselves not religious all. And no one (of any significance) in Western Europe is arguing for a return to Christianity. Some parties advocate “Judeo-Christian values” but the various incarnations of this concept are nebulous at best and mostly completely unrecognizable to Jews and Christians.

At the same time, many Western European countries are now majority atheist or at least majority unaffiliated with organized religion, so, no, religion is not at all a bigger deal in European politics at all.

Re:France's Baby Bust by rayiner on Sunday February 26, 2023 @08:29AM (#34945363)
Those political parties in France talk about “western culture” instead of “Christianity,” but western culture is fundamentally an outgrowth of Christianity. Even if you strip out the supernatural parts, a religion provides all sorts of notions about fairness, justice, forgiveness, family life, the rules and order, etc. People in Europe are still socialized into all that, even if they stop going to church.

This is apparent if you come from a different religious background. I know people who are nominally atheist but you can tell their family is German Protestant a mile away.

Re:France's Baby Bust by mtts on Sunday February 26, 2023 @08:55AM (#34945554)
> Even if you strip out the supernatural parts, a religion provides all sorts of notions about fairness, justice, forgiveness, family life, the rules and order, etc.

Most people would call that a culture.

One were most people do not go to church on Sunday and politicians, even if they’re from a religious background, like Angela Merkel, don’t ever talk about God.

And one that is very different from the one across the Atlantic where “in God we trust” is the national motto and politicians make sure to fluff up their religious credentials.

Re:France's Baby Bust by rayiner on Sunday February 26, 2023 @09:14AM (#34945685)
> Most people would call that a culture.

Sure. But in Europe that culture co-evolved with more than a 1,000 years of Christianity being central to society. The cultural inheritance of Christianity survives whether people go to church or not. The same is true for those Muslim immigrants. They are culturally Muslim. It’s those differences in culture, rooted in religion, that are the source of the conflict, not theology in the abstract.

> One were most people do not go to church on Sunday and politicians, even if they’re from a religious background, like Angela Merkel, don’t ever talk about God.

The German system of offering education in Christianity in public schools would be illegal in America. In Germany abortion is still technically illegal, and is restricted after 12 weeks, whereas in most of America it’s available up to 24 weeks. In Bavaria the government can require Christian crosses to be displayed in all public buildings. In America that would be illegal.

So why doesn’t Merkel talk about Christianity? Is it because Christianity has less influence on government and society in Germany? Or is it because Germany secularism carved out a sphere for Christianity in society, and, unlike in America, nobody is trying to eliminate that sphere?

Re:France's Baby Bust by AlchemistCamp on Sunday February 26, 2023 @10:26AM (#34946232)
This sounds like a very outdated or caricatured view of the US (where I lived for half of 2022 and also 2012-2015). In those four years I didn't hear the phrase "in God we trust" even one time and the vast majority people I met were either athiest, agnostic or identified as Christian but hadn't been to church in years didn't seem to hold many religious beliefs but had some family background or cultural connection.

If you look, you can definitely religious people but it's not most people or even close. The one large exception to this is the large number of immigrants who were much more likely to be religious and church-going.

Re:France's Baby Bust by rayiner on Sunday February 26, 2023 @11:36AM (#34946816)
It’s not inaccurate. Soon as you step outside a major city, the majority of Americans go to church weekly. The percentage of Americans who pray daily is comparable to Iran: https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2019/05/01/with-high-l...
Re:France's Baby Bust by slaw on Sunday February 26, 2023 @01:23PM (#34947897)
Study from 8 years ago. No longer true.
Re:France's Baby Bust by rayiner on Sunday February 26, 2023 @02:18PM (#34948431)
You think a seismic shift in those numbers happened in the last year? 81% of Americans still say they believe in god: https://news.gallup.com/poll/393737/belief-god-dips-new-low..... It’s down only 6 percentage points since 2013.
Re:France's Baby Bust by slaw on Sunday February 26, 2023 @07:41PM (#34951541)
They may still believe in god, but not pray daily.
Re:France's Baby Bust by onetimeusename on Sunday February 26, 2023 @01:30PM (#34947978)
> And one that is very different from the one across the Atlantic where “in God we trust” is the national motto

What is your point about this? The motto has a long tradition almost as old as the country and it's really not uncommon for European countries to reference God in their national or even unofficial national motto.

> politicians make sure to fluff up their religious credentials.

Like who and how? Most politicians don't do this. Politicians in the US are generally not very religious in my opinion. Ironically, the ones I can think of that are most outspoken about their religion are two Catholics who are at odds with their church leadership over abortion and gay marriage, and Muslims who I somewhat doubt practice Islam. I am struggling to even think of more overtly religious politicians. I just think media reports skew how irreligious politics in the US actually is. I am sure you can find some story about a speech somewhere reference religion or a cross being put up on a state courthouse or something somewhere but I don't think exceptions make the rule and this forgets that even just taking the federal government alone, there are hundreds of politicians who never bring up religion and things are actually much more mundane.

Re:France's Baby Bust by WastingMyTime89 on Sunday February 26, 2023 @09:04AM (#34945616)
No one in France talks about western culture. The main parties which have made Islam a theme are staunchly anti-American.

France has had a strong separation between the state and religion for a century. It’s one of the less religious country in the world and a significant part of the population is still strongly against any kind of religion especially the Catholic Church.

Re:France's Baby Bust by rayiner on Sunday February 26, 2023 @09:18AM (#34945709)
Remind me which country is the one with the hijab ban in schools? Is it america or is it France? And you want to tell me you’re not having a religious conflict over there?
Re:France's Baby Bust by WastingMyTime89 on Sunday February 26, 2023 @09:46AM (#34945916)
I have issue making sense of your reply to my comment. I don’t see how it’s against anything I said.

As I wrote: "a significant part of the population is still strongly against any kind of religion".

All religious signs are banned in schools not only the hijab. France views religion as strictly a private matter which has no place at all in the public sphere. That’s not a religious conflict just widely incompatible with the American view on the subjects.

Re:France's Baby Bust by rayiner on Sunday February 26, 2023 @02:13PM (#34948395)
You don’t think the French ban on hijab has anything to do with religion? You think it’s just a coincidence and has nothing to do with the fact that Christianity happens not to generally require outwardly visible symbols of membership in a religious community, unlike Islam, Shikhism, Orthodox Judaism, etc.?
Re:France's Baby Bust by WastingMyTime89 on Sunday February 26, 2023 @05:48PM (#34950510)
Remind me which faith in France add to shoot at civil servants to try to prevent them taking an inventory of the content of their cult places so it could be ceased by the state. I guess you don’t know or you wouldn’t write such idiocies.

But even then, as a French, I would applaud anything going against religions. The faster we get ride of obscurantism the better the world.

Re:France's Baby Bust by __bjoernd on Sunday February 26, 2023 @11:34AM (#34946807)
Re:France's Baby Bust by LawTalkingGuy on Sunday February 26, 2023 @12:40PM (#34947443)
Do you truly believe that hijabs and only hijabs (or maybe other Islamic symbols) are banned? Because if so I've got some good news for you - all overt religious symbols are treated equally.
Re:France's Baby Bust by rayiner on Sunday February 26, 2023 @02:15PM (#34948410)
And it’s so convenient that it so happens that Christianity emphasizes one’s personal relationship with god and generally doesn’t require or encourage wearing overt religious symbols.
Re:France's Baby Bust by LawTalkingGuy on Sunday February 26, 2023 @02:54PM (#34948741)
Only the ones that integrate well with modern society. There are tv shows that point out the antiquated ways of the Amish such as how they teach their kids and dress their women and their older children's struggles to adjust in broader society, for example.
Re:France's Baby Bust by tptacek on Sunday February 26, 2023 @03:27PM (#34949018)
"Christianity" doesn't emphasize a personal relationship with God; many forms of Protestantism do, but Catholicism does almost the opposite, and French Christians are overwhelmingly Catholic.
Re:France's Baby Bust by lalopalota on Sunday February 26, 2023 @08:33AM (#34945403)
> marrying across political lines now carries more opposition than across religious ones, for the majority of people

Where can I learn more about this? I find it difficult to believe this is true for "the majority of people".

Re:France's Baby Bust by AlchemistCamp on Sunday February 26, 2023 @09:02AM (#34945606)
Re:France's Baby Bust by nwatson on Sunday February 26, 2023 @09:03AM (#34945608)
Religion is increasingly a political signifier in the USA now. Many MAGA Trump supporters who claim to be Evangelical don't even go to church on any regular basis. "Secular Evangelicalism" is huge in the USA South.

This trend started with William Branham (progenitor of Latter Rain cult, The Message cult, prosperity gospel, healing-campaign revivalism ... leading to the current New Apostolic Reformation) and his mentor Roy E. Davis (Klan leader) in the 1930s. They started a political white supremacist cult with a religious bent. These two spawned a plethora of "heretical" movements still going strong today, a fusion of supremacist, new age ideas from the late 1800s, anti-communist, and evangelical/pentecostal ideas.

(Refer to the "Leaving The Message" YouTube channel. These guys, Branham and Davis, spawned the hydra.)

Edit: clarity, additional points

Re:France's Baby Bust by DFHippie on Sunday February 26, 2023 @06:10PM (#34950702)
Eh, as an American I would say it checks out. We really hate each other.

Much of the get-out-the-vote effort on the right consists of reminding their voters why they hate the other side. This naturally pisses off the left. This leads to much angry rhetoric on the left. This rhetoric is nut-picked and put on blast by the media on the right. Etc. The situation isn't symmetric because the left has a lot of issues they're happy to run on: climate change, electoral reforms, education, health care. The right is mostly focused on their hatred of the left -- anti-wokeism, anti-CRT, anti-gender-whatever. The net effect is a lot of hatred.

Re:France's Baby Bust by b800h on Sunday February 26, 2023 @07:08AM (#34944909)
If you mean British Prime Ministers, then we have for a long time been allergic to the discussion of religion in British politics; but that goes hand in hand with British reserve. Not a uniformly wonderful thing, to be honest. If the Bishops in the House of Lords were less timid we might get some better debates on moral matters.
Re:France's Baby Bust by whatusername on Sunday February 26, 2023 @07:01AM (#34944883)
Scott Morrison (as a Pentecostal) had religion as a minor part of his platform at least. (I know you probably weren't looking at Australian PM's - but he stands out more so than any of the UK/CA/NZ examples that come to mind. I might be biased though)
Re:France's Baby Bust by dmurray on Sunday February 26, 2023 @07:04AM (#34944893)
I don't see American presidents making religion "a major part of their platform" either. They get some photo ops in church just like British leaders, and they side with their voters on things like abortion, which breaks down roughly along religious lines without being explicitly so.

But a major policy decision directly targeting religion? The closest I can think of in the US is Trump banning immigration from majority-Muslim countries under the pretext of links to terror.

As for the rest of the Western world, you might think of Angela Merkel and Ursula von der Leyen, who explicitly represent the Christian Democratic Union.

Re:France's Baby Bust by b800h on Sunday February 26, 2023 @07:10AM (#34944922)
US political debates are being driven by religion all the time - abortion for example. That's a much bigger deal in the US.

That said I'd argue the culture war is quasi-religious, and it's being fought equally across the Anglosphere and beyond.

Re:France's Baby Bust by rayiner on Sunday February 26, 2023 @11:30AM (#34946769)
And what, if not religion, is driving abortion law in Germany, which has a 12-week limit and restrictions such as waiting periods which were illegal in the US under Roe?

It seems to me like the reason Germany doesn’t have a religiously charged debate on abortion is that no major party is pushing for abortion to 24 weeks or even later like in America.

Re:France's Baby Bust by LawTalkingGuy on Sunday February 26, 2023 @01:08PM (#34947702)
I'm an atheist and I think that murder is bad despite not believing in the religious sanctity of life. I'd have trouble with full-term abortions of healthy, viable babies.

It doesn't seem unreasonable that other people would have a lower comfort limit, again even without religion.

Re:France's Baby Bust by rayiner on Sunday February 26, 2023 @02:21PM (#34948466)
You don’t think that “comfort limit” has anything to do with Christianity?

If you want to see what atheists do when they’re not bound by the cultural hangover of an abrahamic religion, look at population control efforts in Asia. The Chinese correctly observed that, from a purely utilitarian standpoint, there’s no compelling reason to draw the line at birth.

Re:France's Baby Bust by LawTalkingGuy on Sunday February 26, 2023 @03:01PM (#34948802)
> from a purely utilitarian standpoint, there’s no compelling reason to draw the line at birth.

Except there is. You want the same protections applied to you, even if you're unconscious or otherwise unable to protest. Pretty much the only broadly supportable position is that killing a viable person is murder and no more or less supportable than them killing you.

Re:France's Baby Bust by rayiner on Sunday February 26, 2023 @03:56PM (#34949347)
How does that factor into the utilitarian calculus? Who cares about you? If a stroke reduces you to the same level of mental functioning as a newborn, why shouldn’t society be able to eliminate you as a burden on them?
Re:France's Baby Bust by skissane on Sunday February 26, 2023 @04:24PM (#34949617)
The Australian philosopher Peter Singer is a preference utilitarian, and has argued that infanticide should be legal, on preference utilitarian grounds. He argues we have to treat the preferences of all beings equally, but newborns have no concept of what it means to continue to live, so can’t possibly have a preference/wish/desire to go on living. Hence, the only moral obstacle to killing them is the wishes of their parents, therefore (painless) infanticide should be legal with parental consent.

Personally I find his view to be utterly morally abhorrent, but I have to credit him with the courage and consistency of taking utilitarianism to its logical conclusion.

Re:France's Baby Bust by LawTalkingGuy on Sunday February 26, 2023 @05:30PM (#34950313)
> Who cares about you?

Me. That's why I want to find a simple set of rules that we can both agree to, where you care about me in trade for similar concern and protection.

> If a stroke reduces you to the same level of mental functioning as a newborn

Right, I don't consider that viable without some sort of prognosis of recovery but if we go too far down the line of 'burden to society' it starts to include people who drive too slowly in the passing lane and gets more subjective.

Re:France's Baby Bust by swarnie on Sunday February 26, 2023 @07:29AM (#34945024)
Maybe its harder to see from the inside... As an example I've pulled up the last state of the union address which appears to be a regular and semi-important thing across the pond. God is mentioned 11 times by my count.

That would be considered OOT for a priest over here.

Re:France's Baby Bust by barry-cotter on Sunday February 26, 2023 @08:08AM (#34945231)
> That would be considered OOT for a priest over here.

Only in the Churches where the religion part is seen with faint embarrassment. Established Churches are the best way to drive religiosity down yet discovered besides banning.

Re:France's Baby Bust by watwut on Sunday February 26, 2023 @08:06AM (#34945223)
Abortion and homeschooling are religion driven. Also, the evangelical fundamentalists are quite influential in USA.
Re:France's Baby Bust by vitus on Sunday February 26, 2023 @09:17AM (#34945696)
> The closest I can think of in the US is Trump banning immigration from majority-Muslim countries under the pretext of links to terror.

The Trump travel ban is weird in its various iterations. On one hand Trump was on the record during his campaign as wanting to ban Muslims from entering the country entirely, but on the other hand the ban completely omitted the largest predominantly-Muslim countries (Indonesia, Pakistan, Bangladesh). For a sense of scale, those three countries make up about a third of the world's Muslim population. (Add on India and Nigeria and you're looking at half of the global Muslim population.) There was also criticism for omitting places like Saudi Arabia, UAE, and Lebanon (and Egypt, in earlier iterations) which actually had demonstrable ties to 9/11.

But, the original list was mostly consistent with restrictions on the visa waiver program, which is to say the administration probably wanted to start small with the most legally defensible subset before expanding it more broadly. In practice, said restrictions were uniformly blocked by the judicial system.

Ostensibly the first amendment's establishment cause prevents Congress from passing laws that are overly religious, although that doesn't entirely stop them from, say, passing the Defense of Marriage Act or attempting to explicitly opt out churches from COVID restrictions.

These days it's mostly about putting ideologically-aligned judges on the courts and letting them choose which laws to block or precedent to overturn.

Re:France's Baby Bust by TMWNN on Sunday February 26, 2023 @01:13PM (#34947765)
>Ostensibly the first amendment's establishment cause prevents Congress from passing laws that are overly religious, although that doesn't entirely stop them from, say, passing the Defense of Marriage Act

No, it does not. The first amendment establishes freedom of religion, and prohibits state-sponsored religion. (The phrase "separation of church and state" is found nowhere in the Constitution.) As the Constitution was originally interpreted, it only applied to the federal government; individual US states had state-sponsored churches into the 19th century.

>or attempting to explicitly opt out churches from COVID restrictions.

This is based on the first amendment's guarantee of freedom of religion. This is why churches, for example, don't pay taxes.

In any case, this is immaterial to the Trump immigration bans. The US president has enormous latitude over who is admitted into the country. <https://np.reddit.com/r/bestof/comments/4vv1rc/utmwnn_explai...>

Re:France's Baby Bust by rayiner on Sunday February 26, 2023 @08:17AM (#34945284)
Religion can play a major role without becoming a point of conflict if everyone agrees. For example, many European countries still have established Christian churches and (possibly opt-out) religious education in schools. If Muslims in Sweden were filing lawsuits to prevent public money from being used to support religious education, or to force Denmark to disestablish the Lutheran Church, I suspect you would see religion becoming a point of contention.

In France, Muslim immigration has made religion a major campaign issue. The French frame it as a matter of secularism versus Islam, but French secularism is better described as a form of Enlightenment-flavored post-Catholicism: https://www.europenowjournal.org/2019/10/02/the-catholic-nes...

Re:France's Baby Bust by mkoubaa on Sunday February 26, 2023 @11:35AM (#34946812)
I think the self branding of this particular movement as a secular one is a triumph of marketing.