News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Missing Semester of Your CS Education by MacroChip on Saturday February 25, 2023 @02:05PM (#34939416)
My university had Dijkstra's quote "Computer science is no more about computers than astronomy is about telescopes". They made us aware of tools and we were free to use them as little or as much as possible to do the science. I always assumed that software engineering degrees focused on tools more than computer science degrees (among other differences).
Re:The Missing Semester of Your CS Education by _dain_ on Saturday February 25, 2023 @03:30PM (#34940148)
The following isn't aimed at you in particular, but in HN threads about the missing semester someone will always earnestly pull out this stinking turd of a Dijkstra quote, so I'll put my rant here:

Dijkstra was full of it. He wanted to think CS was just a branch of abstract mathematics but that's never been the case. The quote is just math envy.

And as for astronomy: knowing how telescopes are constructed, how they work, their optical characteristics, limitations, failure modes, all of that is essential to observational astronomy. And if you study astronomy, you sure as fuck are taught how to use a telescope!!!

Astronomy as we know it didn't exist until we had good telescopes. Cosmological theories have risen and fallen on the advances in optical theory and engineering. The same is true for computer science.

What other field is so ashamed of its own tools? Like, art isn't about pencils, but art students are taught how to hold a pencil! Stop repeating this thought-terminating cliche.

Re:The Missing Semester of Your CS Education by bazoom42 on Sunday February 26, 2023 @05:53AM (#34944605)
Thanks for calling this out. I belive Knuth remarked that Dijkstra himself didnt’ program the way he thougth CS students should.
Re:The Missing Semester of Your CS Education by MacroChip on Friday March 03, 2023 @03:09PM (#35014393)
Fwiw, your rant did not convince me.

I estimate that astronomers need to know about tradeoffs on a telescopes' settings for the data they are looking at. But I'm unconvinced that they necessarily need to know how to operate it (would depend on the workplace) and I certainly disagree that how they are constructed is absolutely necessary for all astronomers.

More knowledge is always good, so of course learn what you want. But it's not being "ashamed of tools" to say that a CS degree should "do one thing and do it well".

Additionally, we can simultaneously say that a university should encourage tool mastery while also saying that they don't need to teach entire courses on it.

Re:The Missing Semester of Your CS Education by throwaway675309 on Saturday February 25, 2023 @03:44PM (#34940275)
Completely agree. Things like shell scripting, debugging tools, IDE usage can all be naturally picked up on the job given whatever tools that they recommend you use at their company.

You know what you're not going to be able to pick up at your first software engineering position? Discrete mathematics or linear algebra.

Re:The Missing Semester of Your CS Education by jrpelkonen on Saturday February 25, 2023 @05:05PM (#34940919)
Not trying to dismiss the importance of knowing discrete math etc. in general, but I would posit that vast majority of entry level swe positions require no knowledge of it.

However, knowing the tools of the trade is something that is invaluable. And yes, it can be picked up on the job, but deliberate learning and practice is more effective and less stressful.

Re:The Missing Semester of Your CS Education by matwood on Saturday February 25, 2023 @05:41PM (#34941192)
> Not trying to dismiss the importance of knowing discrete math etc. in general, but I would posit that vast majority of entry level swe positions require no knowledge of it.

Directly, sure. I do think there is something about the rigor of the math thought process that lends itself to writing software. Thinking through algorithms and proofs is really not much different than writing code or debugging.

Even with tools I think learning concepts are better. I've used so many IDEs through my career, but they are all roughly the same conceptually. One thing that has helped though is embracing vim keystrokes and using them everywhere.

Re:The Missing Semester of Your CS Education by vitaflo on Saturday February 25, 2023 @03:59PM (#34940398)
This was my first thought too. The tools talked about in the link are useful but they aren’t really computer science. This was also hit home in my CS courses. I was being taught the science behind computers, not necessarily the practical application of them.