Re:The Missing Semester of Your CS Education
by bazoom42 on Sunday February 26, 2023 @05:53AM
(#34944605)
Thanks for calling this out. I belive Knuth remarked that Dijkstra himself didnt’ program the way he thougth CS students should.
Re:The Missing Semester of Your CS Education
by MacroChip on Friday March 03, 2023 @03:09PM
(#35014393)
Fwiw, your rant did not convince me.
I estimate that astronomers need to know about tradeoffs on a telescopes' settings for the data they are looking at. But I'm unconvinced that they necessarily need to know how to operate it (would depend on the workplace) and I certainly disagree that how they are constructed is absolutely necessary for all astronomers.
More knowledge is always good, so of course learn what you want. But it's not being "ashamed of tools" to say that a CS degree should "do one thing and do it well".
Additionally, we can simultaneously say that a university should encourage tool mastery while also saying that they don't need to teach entire courses on it.
Dijkstra was full of it. He wanted to think CS was just a branch of abstract mathematics but that's never been the case. The quote is just math envy.
And as for astronomy: knowing how telescopes are constructed, how they work, their optical characteristics, limitations, failure modes, all of that is essential to observational astronomy. And if you study astronomy, you sure as fuck are taught how to use a telescope!!!
Astronomy as we know it didn't exist until we had good telescopes. Cosmological theories have risen and fallen on the advances in optical theory and engineering. The same is true for computer science.
What other field is so ashamed of its own tools? Like, art isn't about pencils, but art students are taught how to hold a pencil! Stop repeating this thought-terminating cliche.