He suggested that criminals make enough opsec mistakes that would be recorded that the government need not be worried.
They should prioritize prosecuting other parts of the government for known offenses. Then when those high level officials are serving long prison sentences they can take the same action against private entities without looking like hypocrites.
If they're the good guys.
CIA operates in the National interest, at least hypothetically. Google can operate against national interest to make money, or 'whoever pays most' interest.
The people of USA have granted CIA privileges of secrecy and legal protections explicitly to do ShadyShit. No-one ever gave Google permission to do ShadyShit.
CIA employees go through background checks, US Gov can fire head of CIA for being a dick. Google hires whoever the fuck they want and US government can't fire head of Google no matter what he does.
If Google is ever found doing 1% of what CIA does legally (and there ain't much!), they need to be in jail real fast.
Just don't go driving around Dallas in an open top limo if you do.
But I guess, those countries "shouldn't have been doing it in the first place" right?
Otherwise they would be more like the Iranian Republican Guard -- where raping their own citizens apparently is okay.
Do you support that? I don't.
From the linked internal discussion on the shooting: "changes to ad serving and changes to search ranking are done completely independently, and by different teams". Isn't it a good idea not to serve ads on sites that are discussing a recent national trauma? Or at the very least not really related to politics?
I say no, because that devalues truthful reporting on real and important events, in favour of safe pablum that will pass the censors. Real news is important, but who is paying for news if it's not funded by ads?
It's always funny when Eric Schmidt says stuff like that.
I've shared it before but I'll inline this evergreen quote from a book called In The Plex: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27479152
> One day Denise Griffin got a call from Eric Schmidt’s assistant. “There’s this information about Eric in the indexes,” she told Griffin. “And we want it out.” In Griffin’s recollection, it dealt with donor information from a political campaign, exactly the type of public information that Google dedicated itself to making accessible. Griffin explained that it wasn’t Google policy to take things like that out of the index just because people didn’t want it there. Principles always make sense until it’s personal,” she says.
> Then in July 2005, a CNET reporter used Schmidt as an example of how much personal information Google search could expose. Though she used only information that anyone would see if they typed Schmidt’s name into his company’s search box, Schmidt was so furious that he blackballed the news organization for a year.
> “My personal view is that private information that is really private, you should be able to delete from history,” Schmidt once said. But that wasn’t Google’s policy...
Privacy for google, other corporations and the government is a one way street. You give it to them. There is no reciprocity. That's it. And that's how it's staying. The end.
This is how tyrants are able to talk the talk (but not the walk) and bark out moral high ground orders to those they rule, while doing whatever degenerate acts they like behind closed doors. That's what power is and does.
There are generational labor camps in North Korea and a litany of horrible ongoing civil wars in Africa. They are evil. So is industry pushback against unleaded aviation fuel [1][2]. But comparing the evils of the civil war in Somalia to those of leaded avgas is, at best, pointless.
[1] https://news.sccgov.org/news-release/findings-county-commiss...
[2] https://www.politico.com/news/2023/02/20/aviation-lead-fuel-...
Like you could have a tyranical father, it's not exclusive to Gulags
You aren't necessarily trying to hid conversations. You are trying to reduce the amount of content you have to search through during discovery.
If only they have technology that would help them doing such searches...
If it's anything like their current search tech, then it's not really fit for purpose eh?
Maybe they should outsource this "it needs to work otherwise gov fines!" search piece to something more effective. Like maybe Yahoo? ;)
Discovery was different when most communications were in person and company memos we're on paper. Even then companies shredded memos after a while, they're not worth the cost to store them.
Now with computers and everyone working via slack all day it's cheap to store everything everyone has said in your company and the laws around discovery haven't been updated so all of that content now has to be checked at the cost of the one being sued.
In the beginning, all instant messages were saved. This was handy because a lot of useful, non-sensitive information was sent over IM.
Then, lawsuits and Discovery happened, and "Off The Record" became the default. You could turn things On The Record if your conversation was non-sensitive.
> You are trying to reduce the amount of content you have to search through
This is Google we're talking about here.
This is the corporate response to the modern "show me the man and I'll show you the crime" legal system.
Everybody is always breaking the law, often because following it is impossible (e.g. different laws require mutually incompatible actions), but mostly because nobody knows all the laws and people regularly break them unintentionally.
Corporate lawyers have no ability to change this since it would require making the laws clear and consistent and simple enough for people to understand, so instead they try to make it harder for anyone to find which laws their clients broke.
Then we cheer when the victim is somebody we don't like.
You are probably using the wrong expression.
Corporate Welfare means Welfare for Corporations. So it's when a government bestows money grants, tax breaks, or other special favourable treatment for corporations.
It is nothing to do with employees, not paying excessive salaries, or keeping unproductive ones around.
It does not imply that main beneficiaries are employees, typically it's about C-suite and shareholders.
Sounds like corporate welfare to me.
But that's more just a condemnation on how sickeningly large American media empires are now
Disney was much better off under the old regime, where they could have collected statutory damages from Google each time a movie was uploaded to YouTube.
As for special treatment for corporations, I hope readers, especially Google fans, caught the remark from Brett Kavanaugh earlier in the week. He more or less suggested courts should not interpret Section 230 in ways that might expose Google to liability because of possible "economic dislocation" and negative effects on "retirement accounts". Perhaps it isn't just the executive and legislative branches that can give corporations undeserved favorable treatment. :)
There are 300 million people that live in the United States. Do you think they all agree with the country’s policies with regards to surveillance? How about pretty much any other country?
Even the Devil himself believes he’s doing the right thing because “doing right” is completely subjective.
Anything is possible when values are pliable.
https://gizmodo.com/google-removes-nearly-all-mentions-of-do...
Okay sure, perhaps some serial killers knew they were doing the wrong thing but you don't commit genocide unless you've convinced yourself that you're doing the right thing.
To do evil on a grand scale you must have righteousness and conviction in abundance.
"Don't be evil" at least admits the possibility of asking "Wait. are we the baddies?"
It's kind of weird that we've turned formerly ephemeral things into "evidence" just because they could optionally be stored.
If it was a few decades ago, the kind of things happening in these chats would have happened in person or on the telephone with nobody necessarily recording it. Whether to store them or for how long is an arbitrary choice.
You probably have your phone with you all the time. It has a microphone in it. Is not recording your every conversation "destruction of evidence"? What if the microphone is always on (because it's listening for voice commands) so the audio is stored temporarily in memory before being deleted?
The precedents cases like this set don't just apply to huge corporations.
Or on paper, maybe by memo. And they would have destroyed the paper evidence just the same, and claimed helplessness in the face of so much paper that had to be kept, and that the suspicion of their motives amounts to being convicted before trial. Same sort of arguments, except for the people handling paper holding on to data wasn't a matter of getting a few people to click around for a few days, it was wrangling dozens of banker's boxes of paper. Trucks and warehouses.
> It's kind of weird that we've turned formerly ephemeral things into "evidence" just because they could optionally be stored.
This is literally what evidence is. It's something that you carefully collect and store to review later in connection with something else. You don't have to "store" the knife you stabbed somebody with or the gun you shot someone with (you've already got enough use out of them) but if somebody destroys them, they're destroying evidence. Even if you threw it out with the kitchen trash, and you always take out the trash on Thursdays.
You're not getting out of the problem that the distinction is essentially arbitrary. You could record everything you say in private. Every single frame that appears on any screen in the company was in some piece of memory at some point in time. What principled distinction are you proposing between what is and isn't a crime to not actively retain?
If the feds essentially want to wiretap you, why should that happen at your expense instead of theirs? Even in cases when you're innocent?
> This is literally what evidence is. It's something that you carefully collect and store to review later in connection with something else. You don't have to "store" the knife you stabbed somebody with or the gun you shot someone with (you've already got enough use out of them) but if somebody destroys them, they're destroying evidence.
There is a distinction between physical objects and information. If you have a knife, destroying it isn't an ordinary thing to do. Meanwhile we have serious concerns about TLC solid state drives which make them unsuitable for many purposes because you can only erase and rewrite them about a thousand times.
Computers inherently operate by rearranging bits. Writing something new coincides with erasing what was there before. Keeping everything forever isn't feasible. So where's the line?
The hypocrisy is maddening.
Compare it with Zuckerberg plugging his mic with a dud 3.5mm connector.
Some years ago I got glad and impressed by a friend landing a job as a SWE at Google. Nowadays I just feel pity and disgust for him working there.
I would write "how times change" but the thing is I just hadn't realized how bad Google was 5 years ago.
It's a bit of a stretch for the government to assume this feature exists solely to piss off the government.
https://ia902501.us.archive.org/21/items/gov.uscourts.dcd.22...
Former Google CEO Eric Schmidt appearing on CNBC once said "If you have something that you don't want anyone to know, maybe you shouldn't be doing it in the first place."
If Google is not doing anything wrong, then why not give the Government what they are asking for and let justice prevail.
Google surveils internet users' conversations without a subpoena, for profit. To Schmidt, and 75,000+ other people who work for the company, that's OK. However when the Government subpoenas Google for Google's conversations, for the purpose of determining whether a violaion of law has occurred, then Google becomes evasive.