News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Justice Department says Google destroyed evidence related... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday February 26, 2023 @12:24AM (#34943295)
> Or on paper, maybe by memo.

You're not getting out of the problem that the distinction is essentially arbitrary. You could record everything you say in private. Every single frame that appears on any screen in the company was in some piece of memory at some point in time. What principled distinction are you proposing between what is and isn't a crime to not actively retain?

If the feds essentially want to wiretap you, why should that happen at your expense instead of theirs? Even in cases when you're innocent?

> This is literally what evidence is. It's something that you carefully collect and store to review later in connection with something else. You don't have to "store" the knife you stabbed somebody with or the gun you shot someone with (you've already got enough use out of them) but if somebody destroys them, they're destroying evidence.

There is a distinction between physical objects and information. If you have a knife, destroying it isn't an ordinary thing to do. Meanwhile we have serious concerns about TLC solid state drives which make them unsuitable for many purposes because you can only erase and rewrite them about a thousand times.

Computers inherently operate by rearranging bits. Writing something new coincides with erasing what was there before. Keeping everything forever isn't feasible. So where's the line?

There are no comments on this comment yet.