For the record, single origin beans for black coffee have lost most of their top notes 2-3 weeks after roasting
nah. Sey coffee, one of the top roasters in the country (who also buys very high quality green coffee to roast), puts on the package "best after 2 weeks"
and it's relative, top grade coffee after it gets "old" (for whatever value of old) is still better than lesser quality that never tasted that good in the first place. I'm talking about aromatics, tea like fruit notes, etc.
I can imagine that the same probably doesn't hold true for espresso, since the back pressure from out gassing is crucial to extraction.
edit: I am thinking mainly of espresso and now that I fully read your comment, I see you acknowledge that. Espresso in a sealed bag is pretty good for months. But once you open it, the flavor changes day by day and after a week or so the special qualities are basically gone. There are various things you can try but I have yet to find a great solution to this.
https://planetarydesign.com/product/airscape-classic-coffee-...
Flavor compounds: my understanding is that flavor compounds continue to develop post roast, with the consensus suggesting that 5–10 days post roast rest is required to develop peak flavor.
Outgassing: beans continue to outgas after roasting, and a tightly sealed bag wouldn't prevent it. However, once most CO2 has been lost, it doesn't necessarily imply that the beans are stale. Espresso techniques are designed around the back pressure from outgassing, and 'flat' grinds would pose a problem. I'm sure it can be addressed, though - by reducing flow rate, for example.
Stale: The real issue with aging is the oxidation of coffee oils, and that's where proper storage is required.
If your beans are approximately identical then parameters are: - grind size and consistency (e.g. surface area in ratio) - amount of coffee & water (consistent mass) - temperature - pressure - steep time
With an aeropress you're going to have to work a little on keeping these all the same, but that's all doable so long as your grinder is consistent.
The big difference with James' technique is that it spends more time immersion brewing, almost like a french press, vs the stock technique that's really rushing you to extract and then percolate with the push. I find the longer immersion brew is a lot more forgiving and repeatable as a technique.
So why not just use a French press? It's much less complicated.
My first week with aeropress, a majority of the attempts were dogshit. More dogshit coffee in one week than in 10 years with French press. And really only one way to fuck it up in French press. Forget it on the counter (10+ minutes). There's more ways to fuck up aeropress than I can count. I admit I can usually only count to ten.
The beans taste different at an individual level so what you are tasting is an average of the beans that are used to make that cup of coffee.
Typically beans grown under similar conditions will taste similarly. Because of this coffee farmers will sometimes separate the coffee grown on parts of their farm into "micro lots" that contain particular individual characteristics.
In regards to the temperature you are right also. There is dynamic interplay between bitter, sweat, salty, sour and umami that goes on while the beverage cools. After all, brewing coffee is just applied chemistry whether you realise it or not.
The only time you should not trust your senses is when they are compromised or if you are someone who is highly open to suggestion. Even then your senses are still correct in your experience. You just can't extrapolate this experience out to a percentage of the general population.
Language makes also makes discussing taste confusing too because when people are saying "this tastes bitter" what they are often saying is "this tastes bitter to me" Also taste often gets bundled with smell so when people say "this tastes like raspberries" it can be unclear whether they are referring to the sugars, acids etc. that are tasted or the aromatic compounds that are smelt or both. Synesthesia can also be experienced too ie. things that smell like vanilla can "smell sweet" to some people.
I don't trust my senses here entirely, and as it's not blind I can easily fool myself. But the amount of agitation and differences in pouring might affect the taste here sometimes. Though my impression is that this is not always noticeable, but if I'm on the border of the coffee becoming bitter or sour it gets noticeably variable between preparations.
The other part that I'm quite sure of is that the temperature you drink at affects taste a lot more than I thought. If I drink the coffee too hot it tastes bitter, and it noticeably improves at lower temperatures (which is different from what I remember from cheap, pre-ground coffee, which tends to taste really bitter when it gets colder).