News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by MadSudaca on Thursday February 23, 2023 @02:12PM (#34914977)
I’m gonna be that guy: cryptocurrency fixes this.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by JohnFen on Thursday February 23, 2023 @02:27PM (#34915173)
It might prevent you from being banned without reason, but it also eliminates the ability to claw back scammed money.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by peyton on Thursday February 23, 2023 @02:45PM (#34915445)
You mean the PayPal buyer protection program? How does it work?
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by JohnFen on Thursday February 23, 2023 @02:47PM (#34915468)
I mean using cryptocurrency to pay for things.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by peyton on Thursday February 23, 2023 @02:55PM (#34915576)
How does using crypto eliminate the ability to claw back scammed money? There are services that use crypto as payment rails and also offer scam protection.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by mr_mitm on Thursday February 23, 2023 @03:32PM (#34916075)
Then we're back to being at risk of being banned for no reason, though. Can't have it both ways.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by JohnFen on Thursday February 23, 2023 @05:54PM (#34917909)
What mr_mitm says. Also, once you're using services like that, what's the point of using cryptocurrency at all? What is it buying you?
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by latchkey on Thursday February 23, 2023 @03:02PM (#34915697)
Zelle is in the US, backed by major banks, and good luck with a claw back.

"But Zelle’s terms are clear: You can’t cancel a payment once it’s been sent if the recipient is already enrolled with Zelle. And if you send money to someone you don’t know for a product or service, you may not get your money back for a product or service that’s not delivered."

https://www.elliott.org/problem-solved/how-to-get-your-money...

Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by kube-system on Thursday February 23, 2023 @04:16PM (#34916571)
That page explains exactly how to do so, via legal protections.

The difference with crypto is that you're not going to be filing a Regulation E dispute against someone on the other side of the planet.

Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by latchkey on Thursday February 23, 2023 @04:22PM (#34916643)
>That page explains exactly how to do so, via legal protections.

"Since Regulation E is virtually unknown outside of the financial services industry, few people — let alone customers — know the process of filing a claim."

Oh come on. Zelle and the banks are literally banking on the fact that they are protected by exactly these sorts of unknown processes. Are you really advocating for more of that?

> The difference with crypto

The difference with crypto is that contracts, written in code, can be used to do escrow that don't require a third party centralized company like Zelle to handle the transfers. They also work across borders. No need to tie up the US legal system with 'Regulation E' cases over $1700 rent payments or having to hire lawyers to sue banks.

My point is that, we can work to make this stuff better, or we can keep the status quo of having to learn about 'regulation e'. I'm on the side of working to make this better.

Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by kube-system on Thursday February 23, 2023 @04:34PM (#34916810)
The article in the OP is a great example of why removing humans and relying on code is fraught with issues. The problem is that money is often used to exchange for value and things outside of a computer, where smart contracts have little to no reliable mechanism for determining fulfillment of contract conditions. Although, I'm sure smart contracts will be of great use for moving around digital goods.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by latchkey on Thursday February 23, 2023 @04:40PM (#34916896)
The code can still involve humans, if that is the escrow system you'd like to use. It just doesn't have to involve a centralized entity. For example, I can imagine an escrow system where you can have third party arbitration, by anyone who wants to participate in the system. Incentivized by the two parties involved.

People say that crypto is just re-inventing what already exists and a lot of it is doing that... I'm ok with that. What exists is not always the best solution.

Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by kube-system on Thursday February 23, 2023 @04:53PM (#34917084)
I agree that is the ultimate solution. But crypto is not necessary to facilitate such an arrangement. As soon as a human can override the outcome, you've negated the point of using mathematical proofs. Because now you're trusting in the human rather than the proof. You can't have it both ways. Either the ultimate authority is math, or it is a human.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by latchkey on Friday February 24, 2023 @12:26AM (#34921167)
You're conflating the need for consensus (ie: math) with the need for arbitration (ie: escrow).
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by kube-system on Friday February 24, 2023 @01:09PM (#34927683)
They're all consensus mechanisms. If you use any other mechanism to come to a consensus off-chain, then there's no point to using the chain for consensus. You just have an overly complicated distributed database with bad data in it.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by latchkey on Friday February 24, 2023 @01:57PM (#34928399)
I have funds in my wallet. I choose to send them to you. That is human consensus on top of a blockchain, which is the settlement layer.

In the case of escrow contracts. The funds are in a contract. Those funds will be released to a specific wallet only when two humans agree to their human consensus. The blockchain again, is the settlement layer.

When I bought my house, it went through an escrow process. I had to pay some human paper pusher thousands of dollars to do something that really could have just been done by computers for fractions of a cent and in a matter of minutes.

Escrow is one area that you're going to have a hard time arguing with me that isn't a perfect use case for blockchain. I don't care if it is 'overly complicated'... nothing is more overly complicated than the current process today.

Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by JohnFen on Thursday February 23, 2023 @06:00PM (#34918003)
> contracts, written in code

I wish those were called something else. They aren't actually contracts in the sense most people understand the term. And, being code (and immutable, if I understand it), I don't find their existence reassuring from a safety point of view. But that's neither here nor there.

> No need to tie up the US legal system

As (highly) imperfect as it is, the legal system does, at least, provide mechanisms to correct injustices.

Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by JohnFen on Thursday February 23, 2023 @05:48PM (#34917819)
And I wouldn't touch that with a ten foot pole, either.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by latchkey on Friday February 24, 2023 @12:29AM (#34921190)
A paper check seems antiquated, no? My electrician just did $4k worth of work... am I supposed to drive to the bank, pull out $4k and then risk that being stolen before I give it to them? These seem like common problems.

I did use Zelle for that, required two payments since the limit was $2k/day. Also super lame... why can't I be trusted with my own money? "For your protection."

Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by JohnFen on Friday February 24, 2023 @11:16AM (#34926088)
Perhaps your situation is different, but I can make such payments without using these sorts of services and without using a paper check. Those aren't the only two options.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by latchkey on Friday February 24, 2023 @04:58PM (#34930706)
My electrician accepted check, cash or zelle.

I'd love to know your magical way of paying him $4000.

Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by valcron1000 on Thursday February 23, 2023 @03:06PM (#34915758)
> but it also eliminates the ability to claw back scammed money

I got scammed 500 USD using Wise, so it's not like these services help you in any way.

Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by JohnFen on Thursday February 23, 2023 @05:52PM (#34917875)
I don't understand the relevance, though. I'm not comparing cryptocurrency to other new services. I'm comparing it to the more traditional services.

That said, with things like Wise (which I'd never heard of until your comment), it pays to read the fine print and avoid the ones that don't offer any real protection for you.

Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by ipaddr on Thursday February 23, 2023 @02:29PM (#34915204)
Imagine paypal as a crypto exchange holding your keys. Same outcome. The issue is trust and paypal.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by latchkey on Thursday February 23, 2023 @02:37PM (#34915332)
That's why we have decentralized exchanges.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by weberer on Thursday February 23, 2023 @03:08PM (#34915783)
Don't put your wallet in someone else's computer.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by kube-system on Thursday February 23, 2023 @03:37PM (#34916152)
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by computing on Thursday February 23, 2023 @03:59PM (#34916378)
I'm not batting for either team here, but you just linked one of the PayPals of crypto - ie a company that holds onto your funds on your behalf. So it's not really a rebuttal to their comment.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by kube-system on Thursday February 23, 2023 @04:07PM (#34916477)
I did so intentionally. The fact that crypto has still 'PayPals' is exactly my point. Whatever mechanism of value exchange you come up with, there will be intermediaries who pop up to move it around in different ways. Crypto does not 'solve' this.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by computing on Saturday February 25, 2023 @12:30AM (#34934180)
I know that you know exactly what they meant by “crypto solves this”, but you’re just be snarky here and that’s okay
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by exolymph on Thursday February 23, 2023 @04:01PM (#34916402)
You don't have to custody on exchanges.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by kube-system on Thursday February 23, 2023 @04:07PM (#34916480)
You don't have to put money in a bank.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by ronsor on Thursday February 23, 2023 @04:21PM (#34916632)
You do if you want to send it online.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by kube-system on Thursday February 23, 2023 @04:35PM (#34916829)
And I need to use an exchange if I want my paycheck to become crypto.
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by KomoD on Thursday February 23, 2023 @06:08PM (#34918093)
No you don't need to, you can trade with an actual person if you wish
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by 41amxn41 on Thursday February 23, 2023 @04:30PM (#34916762)
Yea keep the funds in a wallet, not in a fucking exchange. That's the entire point.

Not your keys, not your coins.

Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by kube-system on Thursday February 23, 2023 @04:45PM (#34916971)
"Don't use an exchange, crypto solves this!"

"Don't use paypal, cash solves this!"

Both systems have the same problem, in that people need to use intermediaries to accomplish the transactions they want to accomplish. Crypto solves nothing, it converts problems into different problems.

Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by 41amxn41 on Friday February 24, 2023 @01:49AM (#34921650)
Crypto definitely solves lots of problems for me and for many people I know IRL
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by valcron1000 on Sunday February 26, 2023 @11:34AM (#34946801)
Except I cannot give cash to someone who is not in front of me, while I can send crypto to anyone in the world. You don't need intermediaries to transact in crypto, that's the whole point
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by Heston on Thursday February 23, 2023 @04:54PM (#34917094)
Cryptocurrency suffers from the same problems if not worse. There have been billions stolen in cryptocurrency due to no regulations and a lack of accountability. In many cases the one robbing the exchanges were the owners themselves...
Re:Tell HN: Do not store any funds in PayPal or use them for... by colesantiago on Thursday February 23, 2023 @05:47PM (#34917806)
No it doesn’t at all. It makes the problem even worse.