Re:A Lost Hiker’s SOS Signal Sparked a Wildfire. Now He Must...
by bryanrasmussen on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @08:13AM
(#34894921)
you think you bring enough water, and then you find out oh damn.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:A Lost Hiker’s SOS Signal Sparked a Wildfire. Now He Must...
by carabiner on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @08:17AM
(#34894959)
Not a mistake I can see a hiker regularly making. It's like a driver who regularly runs out of gas and is stranded on the freeway every week. Something is really wrong with their self-assessments if this is an activity they've done "plenty of times."
If you're really that bad at estimating water needs bring 2x as much as you think, dump out the extra half way into the hike.
Re:A Lost Hiker’s SOS Signal Sparked a Wildfire. Now He Must...
by mrbombastic on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @08:54AM
(#34895471)
Water is heavy, people don’t want to bring 2x the water they need on a 14 mile hike.
Re:A Lost Hiker’s SOS Signal Sparked a Wildfire. Now He Must...
by tekla on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:04AM
(#34897691)
I'm sorry that attempting to not enter a survival situation is considered too hard.
This is the attitude that causes people to burn down forests in panic mode.
If you're constantly out of water on trail, I heavily recommend taking up another hobby, like crocheting.
Re:A Lost Hiker’s SOS Signal Sparked a Wildfire. Now He Must...
by mrbombastic on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:42PM
(#34900540)
Tone is not really necessary, I am mostly arguing with the point that it is not a common mistake. It is pretty obvious if you run out of water that it is a mistake.
Re:A Lost Hiker’s SOS Signal Sparked a Wildfire. Now He Must...
by grumple on Thursday February 23, 2023 @09:15AM
(#34910826)
The amount of water required for a 17 mile easy/moderate hike and an 18 mile or more much harder hike that includes getting lost may be quite different.
Re:A Lost Hiker’s SOS Signal Sparked a Wildfire. Now He Must...
by bryanrasmussen on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @12:42PM
(#34899460)
I agree that it's not a regular mistake, and I sort of think that the context of the comment we never bring enough water was hyperbole, but it's I think a common enough mistake WHEN things turn problematic to find out oh damn, I don't have enough water for this problematic situation.
Had more than enough for things going good, not enough now.
Re:A Lost Hiker’s SOS Signal Sparked a Wildfire. Now He Must...
by apple4ever on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:27PM
(#34900283)
In the article, it says it is a mistake a hiker regularly makes.
Re:A Lost Hiker’s SOS Signal Sparked a Wildfire. Now He Must...
by seattle_spring on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @08:19AM
(#34894979)
I go hiking 50+ times a year and never have found myself with too little water. For longer trips I'll bring a filter. There's really no excuse here.