News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by olalonde on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @09:24PM (#34890764)
This is an ancient fallacy in economics going back to the mechanization of farm labor. The beauty of capitalism is that what's good for capitalists is also good for everyone else. Jobs will be lost but the standard of living will increase for everyone and new jobs created. Until we reach AGI, at which point we can all collectively retire and just do whatever we want.
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by thebradbain on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @09:34PM (#34890845)
Or, more likely, based on all of human history, you have a few people at the top who “own” the AI, gatekeep and charge for access to it, own the IP-equivalent of whatever it produces, and life will continue as normal for 80%-99% of peasants/laborers working for the lucky few AI-aristocrats.

Even if AGI itself was “good”, that does not mean it will be used or deployed fairly and equitably. In fact, I’d posit without major regulation it will just increase the wealth gap

Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by anomaly_ on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @09:43PM (#34890936)
You need a reality check if you think life today for most people isn't materially better than 50, 100, 500 years ago thanks to improvements driven by capitalism.
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by selimnairb on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @09:49PM (#34890999)
Think of how good life would be if socialism had been allowed to flourish and not smothered in the cradle by the US.
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by belltaco on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @10:01PM (#34891094)
Can you explain how empty grocery stores in USSR is somehow the US's fault?

http://beelineblogger.blogspot.com/2016/01/how-supermarket-v...

Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by skinnymuch on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @11:45PM (#34891757)
I was going to start this but the first few paragraphs already have tons of lies. Where are the non capitalists saying any of these things? The reason for the collapse of USSR is wrong in the first paragraph.

I bet this author thinks Russia isn’t where it is today because of capitalism and the US. Or Putin isn’t a result of US intervention of capitalism in Russia.

Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by Nasrudith on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @11:42AM (#34898277)
He didn't say anything about 'non-capitalists'. Your little noisy clique isn't as large as you think it is. Besides, given how expansively I've seen "capitalism" defined on the internet by its detractors, conservation of energy qualifies as capitalist oppression.
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by skinnymuch on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @07:20PM (#34905073)
> He didn't say anything about 'non-capitalists'. Your little noisy clique isn't as large as you think it is.

The Soviets and Socialists are anti-capitalists. How are you defending OP/OP's link that attempts to show the evils of socialism/Soviets but don't know the Soviets and socialists are anti-capitalists?

> Besides, given how expansively I've seen "capitalism" defined on the internet by its detractors, conservation of energy qualifies as capitalist oppression.

Capitalism is the means of production being owned by private individual capitalists. Think private property. There's one basic definition of capitalism. None of this was difficult to learn once I did some reading. Or even just watching some non-mainstream and non-right wing videos. Just like I've done with media from the mainstream and the right to see where they are coming from.

Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by biscottigelato on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @10:03PM (#34891106)
I am assuming you are sarcastic instead of extremely ignorant.
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by bigDinosaur on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @09:58PM (#34891072)
The biggest Communist ('socialist' is not well defined at all and shouldn't really be used in a serious discussion) enterprise, the USSR, failed on its own merits (or lack thereof). It was in no way strangled by the US. A major reason was that central planning doesn't work that well and you need a market economy - strongly associated with Capitalism - to actually achieve success. Perhaps in some AI-driven future a planned economy etc. could work well, but that certainly hasn't been the case so far. China famously realised this in the late 80's.
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by skinnymuch on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @11:51PM (#34891793)
Where did you do your learning? Why are you using the word communism? Socialist and Socialism are well defined. Capitalist is a sillier word when used for avg citizens who are exploited and oppressed.

Russia was dirt poor in 1917. They became a super power in 30-40 years moving an enormous amount of people out of poverty and lack of modern niceties.

China changed in 78 enough already. How do Cuba or Vietnam survive? How did they survive when heavily sanctioned and attacked by capitalist westerners? We have yet to see a capitalist country do that.

Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by kazinator on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @11:52PM (#34891804)
Whom they couldn't move out of poverty, they just killed.

I can't speak for grandparent, but when I say "communist" disparagingly, I speak as someone who was born and raised in communist Czechoslovakia, who remembers actual communism.

I remember being in kindergarten, learning how there was a great, kind man Lenin who loved children. And I was already somehow thinking, something is off: this shit shouldn't be taught to kids like us.

So you kids can crumple that up in your woke pipes and smoke it. Pardon me, vape.

Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by freemanon on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @12:29AM (#34891992)
Czechoslovakia didn't have actual communism. It was oppressed by a stalinist Soviet Union. Lenin was nothing like Stalin.

People mistake oppression and basically incompetence of the soviet union as proof that communism will never work, but it wasn't communism. During the Lenin era, industrial output actually far outpaced western countries, millions were lifted out of poverty. Same in China, Mao's madness with the great leap forward plunged the country into famine. These weren't communism.

There has not been a real communist society in human history. It'll require the population to change its mindset first from greed, ignorance and blind faith, towards critical thinking, socialism (care for others). These are pre-requisites for any ideals, even democracy.

The falacy of the neoliberal order is to think greed, excess consumption and the paramount right of the individual will magically bring a prosperous society, where in fact it sets up an exploitative system where the vast majority toils for the tiny minority and stays poor and stupid.

Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by kazinator on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @01:52PM (#34900700)
Actual True Scotsmans communism could easily be worse than the ones we actually had. Because there would be no way for anyone who is capable to use that to their own advantage rather than that of the collective. It could easily be the scummiest form of communism, where even the hope of partaking in corruption, or clandestine free-market activity would be taken away from you.
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by skinnymuch on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @05:48PM (#34904152)
You can't use True Scotsman sort of fallacy push back in an adult discussion. It's obvious Stalin's Russia was not proper communism. Lenin was nothing like Stalin. Stalin was still at least a communist, but he was not a good person and was not good for communism. Besides the capitalists in America and all the right wing govts America put in power in its cruel crusade against Communism.

Your argument is a typical one. See this 18 min video for why that isn't necessarily true: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nbkMDb1jJCw

Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by bigDinosaur on Tuesday February 28, 2023 @02:15AM (#34966557)
Socialism is notoriously poorly defined. Where did you develop such certainty about its definition?
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by skinnymuch on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @11:43PM (#34891751)
The capitalist defenders are in full force. They can’t imagine right wing ideals may not be the best.
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by chii on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @09:46PM (#34890959)
> own the IP-equivalent of whatever it produces, and life will continue as normal for 80%-99% of peasants/laborers working for the lucky few AI-aristocrats.

this wasn't the case for other capital goods that was invented in the past, so why is AI going to be different?

In the past, other forms of automation brought on more wealth, which did enrich the rest of society (on top of bringing personal wealth to the founders).

The only difference is that _your_ current view has been normalized to see the products of that capital goods as normal!

Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by celeritascelery on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @09:47PM (#34890973)
> based on all of human history, you have a few people at the top who “own” the AI, gatekeep and charge for access to it, own the IP-equivalent of whatever it produces, and life will continue as normal for 80%-99% of peasants/laborers

It really seems like “all of human history” tells a different story. The standard of living for virtually everyone is much higher now than it was in the past. Obviously there are people who capture a large share of the value. That is true is in any competitive system. But technological advancements have improved the entire world on average.

Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by olalonde on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @10:04PM (#34891107)
Today's peasants live far better lives than yesterday's kings and emperors.
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by BMc2020 on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @10:05PM (#34891116)
except for the part about having power.
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by failuser on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @09:36PM (#34890867)
That’s not a given, it needs to be fought tooth and nail to be true. And we have slid back on many of the those fronts: anti-trust laws are almost dead, tax evasion is rampant and not pushed in any meaningful way, the power to influence elections with money in unchecked. Adding AI to that mix will be explosive. My hope that this catalyze the movement to claw back some of those achievements.
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by nwiswell on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @09:32PM (#34890830)
You should probably read some Piketty. There is absolutely nothing which structurally ensures that the wealth created by capitalist pursuits will be distributed sufficiently to ensure that standards of living will increase for everyone, and in fact there are a lot of reasons to believe that the past century was an anomaly in that regard.
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by andsoitis on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @10:00PM (#34891092)
Why does Pikkety think that capitalism is not the major engine that has been increasing the standard of living for people worldwide? Does he think something else has been the essential motor behind that improvement in the material condition of humans around the world?
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by nwiswell on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @12:08AM (#34891891)
Re:AI Is Useful for Capitalists but Probably Terrible for An... by flangola7 on Tuesday February 21, 2023 @10:23PM (#34891229)
This reads like satire