You'll find a more recent discussion in "Why is There so Little Money in U.S. Politics?" (2003). [1]
[1] https://www.aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.1257/08953300332116497...
TOO MUCH DARK MONEY IN ALMONDS (2019)
https://slatestarcodex.com/2019/09/18/too-much-dark-money-in...
> In 2022, several members of Congress called for investigations into the company’s practice of hiring “revolving door” lobbyists who previously held government positions
is also bribery.
This is why Bill Gates can't just spend $1 billion to lobby for a carbon tax, despite advocating for one. This would cause a lot of short term pain as the economy needs to readjust with no short term positive benefit, which would be politically disastrous.
It's dumb, but... there you have it.
They then use the money they receive from these lobbyists to lie to the people regarding what their job actually entails and self promote themselves as serving their community and country?
Oh and they get to play in the stock market with insider knowledge with impunity to further enrich themselves and a path to become a lobbyist and get paid millions afterwards?
What point are you trying to make - that there is a convoluted game of politics they engage in to enrich themselves, rather than the simplified bag of money exchanging hands?
If so, you're describing a distinction without a difference as far as I can tell.
Either this article disagrees or the lobbyists are raking it in:
https://www.cnn.com/2018/02/23/politics/nra-political-money-...
To secure those huge salaries politicians will accept proposals from companies that hire ex politicians as lobbyists. This way you get to pay for proposals, but the pay is an indirect transaction, but everyone knows how it works so politicians play ball. That is the main reason they wont listen to just anybody, its because you wont pay them huge salaries in the future, not because you come up with bad proposals for them, that doesn't really matter if they get tons of money from you when they retire from politics.
Do we know that's a truly-held belief by this politician, or do we only know that it's an assertion or claim?
Plenty of conservatives genuinely believe, for whatever reason, that it's impossible for "Government" to do something well. They then elect people who promise to make that reality and then point to the obvious, purposeful struggles of our government as their reasoning.
A politician is supposed to represent all citizens equally, even those which did not vote for them.
In a proper democracy, the voter is assessing candidates for a job. Once elected, that job is to do right by all citizens, by doing what they believe is the correct choice, correct way to do their job.
We are supposed to be electing someone to make decisions, based on their beliefs. The election is a job interview.
anudatt
At that price we should all purchase access to legislators, it's a screaming bargain.
Even if Americans did, since there's a fixed supply of representatives, as demand goes up, so will the price :)
0 - https://news.gallup.com/poll/103123/lobbyists-debut-bottom-h...
If I ever have a dispute with some bureaucracy, I will definitely do that again as perhaps a 2nd or 3rd step - it's about similar in terms of cost to retaining legal counsel, and I have to imagine a letter from a congressperson would open a lot of doors.
It isn't as simply as "the smallest piece of the pie the better," companies pay a lot of money for well-connected people who can get someone to sit down and talk. So while the public could pump tons of money into a GoLobbyForMe site, how you'd measure success Vs theft is tricky.
Plus there's often other corruption less easily combatted, like post public-office jobs, or their spouse/family getting a seat on some board, or similar.
Because I 100% would meet reality where it is and buy my own lobbyist if I could get better outcomes than spitting into the wind at the ballot box
The idea here is that you donate in favor of/against a bill you want. Then representatives that vote favorably to your preference receive a portion of the funds as campaign contributions. If lobbying is so cheap why can't it be done by the people for the people? I see dogs raise more than politicians on GFM.
SCOTUS said you can't regulate campaign funding basically at all, because money spent to effect speech is speech, and thus money spent on a political campaign is political speech.
If you actually were to say "I will pass this bill for $X", then that would be a bribe, and you could get kicked out of office or go to jail for that. But spending 30 minutes with a lobbyist behind closed doors and them just handing your campaign a check later on? Perfectly legal. The hush-hush nature of the operation means the only way you can squeeze a business for money is by getting everyone else angry at them too so that the business starts throwing campaign contributions around.
From the congressperson's side it's less "I sold my vote to this person" and more "If I vote for this, then I won't get all these contributions anymore."
The difference between a bribe and a tip is solely in the order of operations.
Yes, and the SCOTUS is wrong.
Maybe if the people deciding our laws made enough to not be woo’d by practically a $300 gift card we’d at least make corruption more expensive.
Because it's not insider trading if you're a congressman. It's total crap.
https://www.cnn.com/2013/12/04/politics/real-alpha-house/ind...
And it's not about why should they get rich. It's about aligning incentives. Relying on good will does not work long term.
Sometimes, humor is hard on the internet.
A you not on the complete wrong way to equality and same rights for everyone? ;)
The market sets the prices.
Sure, the politicians might want more, but I'm sure there are others who would be just as effective who could want less. Then the political contributions flow to your competitors instead of you.
And there are other factors. If you're too obviously corrupt, maybe you get voted out anyway. Maybe you don't even see what you're doing as corruption. Things just happen to align. Or maybe you see it as a win-win. You get something, you do good for your constituents, the lobbying group gets what it wants, etc.
The truth is way more complicated than "corpo stooges carrying big sacks of dollars to fat cat politicians".
there's also a thriving business of laundering money through politician's shitty books they have ghostwritten for them
Lobbyists are the glue that makes those deals happen. So the $3.5M went to pay the lobbyists to negotiate the much bigger deals that ultimately sway the opinions of the politicians.
If the limits came off and it became more expensive it might put an end to it. If it cost $10 to get $1 in tax savings people wouldn't bother turning the tax code into Swiss cheese,
If Intuit spends (just) $3.5M to significantly impact decisions that are worth Billions to them and potentially hundreds to every taxpayer (!), I think I'm frustrated that corrupt politicians aren't doing more to leverage their corruption.
This kind of illegal influence should cost... at least $100M? Selling everyone out for fractions of a penny on the dollar is frankly just kind of embarrassing.
Crime harder, elected reps, if you're going to get out of bed.