We have a significantly higher number of derailments. Even the worst European rail is more safe than US rail.
That it could be even better does not mean it is not a substantial improvement.
US passenger automobiles are more unsafe.
Even with the largest possible investment in rail, cars will exists in large numbers.
So yeah, rail and cargo tram ways in cities are great. But we can't just leave car infrastructure unchanged.
Specially because existing car infrastructure is already there and cheap to modify. Changing a 6 lane road into a 3 lane road with large space for bikes and people is pretty easy.
They are not serious. The rails are a great idea, along with drive-able 'rail' cars for individuals.
Transportation safety is important but it shouldn’t be considered in isolation when there are potentially catastrophic consequences to prioritizing safety at the cost of everything else.
Road systems should always be worked on, but when a crash happens its usually the drivers fault, except in a minority of cases where bad road engineering is to blame. this self driving is fucking up enough that it cannot be blamed on the roads anymore, if it ever could.
> Cambridge Mobile Telematics also found that people driving Teslas were 21% less likely to engage in distracted driving with their phone in their Tesla compared to when they drove their other car.
Maybe the software integration helps avoid this? Lots of other cars have much more complicated interfaces to hook up calls and reading texts. My mom struggled to figure out her car even supported Android Auto.
It might just be it's a higher end car, but they didn't see it for an EV Porsche
> These findings include an analysis of Tesla drivers who also operate another vehicle. These drivers are nearly 50% less likely to crash while driving their Tesla than any other vehicle they operate. We conducted the same analysis on individuals who operate a Porsche and another vehicle. In this case, we observed the opposite effect. Porsche drivers are 55% more likely to crash while driving their Porsche compared to their other vehicle.
The reduction in speed is likely influenced by automated driving, especially considering how fast a Tesla car can accelerate vs normal cars:
> They were 9% less likely to drive above the speed limit.
https://electrek.co/2022/05/27/tesla-owners-less-likely-cras...
With auto pilot on the car is watching you. If you take eyes off the road it issues more pay attention nags. Failure to comply removes FSD Beta. So you have a feedback loop where paying attention becomes more important then your phone.
Well yes, and that is literally exactly the problem. That is exactly why its so unsafe in the US. Because instead of building a safe system everything is blamed on people.
In countries that take road safety seriously, every crash is analyzed and often the road system is changed to make sure it does not happen again. That is why places like Finland, Netherlands and so on have been consistently improving in terms of death and harm caused by the road system.
Again, the book I linked goes into a lot of detail about road safety engineering.
> We suspend the drivers license until they can prove they are capable of being a safe driver.
An unsafe designed street often leads to situation where even good drivers intuitively do the wrong thing. Again, this is exactly the problem.
If you build a system where lots of avg. drivers make accidents, then you have a lot of accidents.
> We should hold this software to the same standard. Until it can demonstrate safety at or above human level, it should be outlawed.
Yes, but its a question of how much limited resources should be invested in analyzing and validating each piece of software by each manufacturer. In general software like Tesla AP would likely pass this test.
I am not against such tests but the reality is that resources are limited.
> Road systems should always be worked on, but when a crash happens its usually the drivers fault, except in a minority of cases where bad road engineering is to blame.
I strongly disagree with this statement. Its a totally false analysis. If a system is designed in a way known to be non-intuitive and leading to a very high rate accidents then its a bad system. Just calling everybody who makes a mistake a bad drive is a terrible, terrible approach to safety.
Once you have a safe road system, if somebody is an extremely bad driver, yes taking that person of the road is good. However in a country where so much of the population depends on a car, that punishment can literally destroy a whole family. So just applying it to anybody who makes a mistake isn't viable, specially in system that makes it incredibly easy to make mistakes.
The numbers don't even show the problem, the unsafe road system leads to less people walking in the US, and somehow still creating a high rate of deaths for people who walk.
We think the solution should always be human. That the way to solve climate change is homesteads, the solution to poverty is individuals working harder, etc.
When anything we don't want happens, we think "I'll try harder next time" not "We will eliminate this as a possibility".
People treat life as a sport rather than an engineering challenge, they want to "win fairly", not make it impossible to lose, they want everything they do to say something about their own ability rather than say something about a clever process that makes individual skill irrelevant.
I really don't exactly like that aspect of humanity, constantly making everything into a sport.
They truly seem to want the whole world to succeed together, just... excluding the people who want to put you in jail for sneaking lead fuel in your truck, and anyone who doesn't lift weights and eat lots of meat, or anyone who complains about them going out while having a cough spreading germs.
https://nyc.streetsblog.org/2022/02/15/excerpt-there-are-no-...
Go look at Salt Lake City. Its is true, Salt Lake City despite horrible bad road design, like Huston. But because people drink less they have slightly less accidents. However international they are still terrible. And that is with there being very little walking.
If they had pedestrian and cyclist numbers like Amsterdam it would be 24/7 mass murder.
If people really wanted to fix transportation that’s great, high speed rail and public transportation reducing the number of cars on the road seem to be the best solution.
But hey, Elon’s hyper loop was a publicity stunt to discourage investment in that. So I say, whether you want to shit on Tesla or public roads, shit on Elon.
No actually its actually not. Less concession in a system that depends on concession for safety will lead to more accident not less.
That is what was shown during Covid, less driving, but accidents per mile went up.
So yes, of course public transport, bikes are great, but if you don't fix the underlying problem in the road system, you are gone have a whole lot of accidents.
> But hey, Elon’s hyper loop was a publicity stunt to discourage investment in that.
This is a claim some guy has made, not the truth. What is more likely is that Musk actually thinks Hyperloop is great (its his idea after all) and would have wanted investment in it.
> shit on Elon
I prefer not to shit on people most of the time.
Musk is the outcome of a South Africa/American way of thought that is more in line with the US avg then most people who advocate for public transport. That is the sad reality.
And the problem in the US road system or the US bad public transport can 100% not be blamed on him. There are many people with far more responsibility that deserve to be shit on far more.
Would smart roads be expensive? RFID responders seem super cheap compared to how much actual asphalt costs. Authorities are currently unable to remotely control flows, speeds and safety which is completely bonkers.
Yeah its not actually that easy. Go and look into train signaling. And cars are not even able to do coupling.
Making a train system operate like a super-railway with cars is crazy difficult and has never been done before.
That said, I think even just basic machine-readable road metadata like signs, speed limits, lanes etc would improve matters.
That assumes that sign reading is the primary issue with AI cars and it isn't.
If you are willing to go to that expense and infrastructure investment, why not just build thing like trains (trams, subways, S-Bahn) and things like Trolley buses and so on.
They are far more space efficient, you get much higher threwput then your untested fancy road infrastructure.
Another issue with your solution is that there are 1 billion cars out there that do not have any of these things so after decades of working on it, you will still have decades where most cars don't use any of this stuff.
More importantly, even if this kind of stuff doesn't enable full self-driving, it can still be used to make basic driving assistance much better - think of even the most basic cars having lane assist on most road, for example.
I don't think it's a significant expense, either. I'm not talking about ripping up roads and replacing all signs in one fell swoop. But e.g. when they redid the highway near me recently, it got little reflectors to mark the lanes. What if, say, every Nth of those had some kind of RFID thing in it? Or when they replace signs, why not put up a new one that broadcasts what it is? None of this is particularly expensive.
As to why not trains and buses - because they do not actually offer the same features as cars, and many people want those features. If you want to argue against cars on principle, it's a different conversation entirely. I do think that more quality public transport is desperately needed, but, speaking as someone who used it nearly exclusively for the first 25 years of my life (and in places that are designed around it, unlike US), it does not replace a car.
My point the road metadata isn't for collision avoidance, but for better lane and speed assist.
Saying this is like saying we should ignore sex offenders in favor of reworking our society. Instead, we should solve both problems rather than bicker over priorities.
And I would say that I'm not proposing to rework society in sociological sense, but rather to throw out the standard engineering standards and replace them with better standards.
And actually it does matter even in the case you suggest. If a car rolls into an intersection, what speed that car is matters. It matters from what points it is clear that the car is out of control. It matters if there are speed bumps or something along those lines that can send strong signals to a driver.
If you have all raised intersection then the top speed of cars will simply be lower and if somebody human or AI makes a mistake that lead to a crash, that crash will be at far lower speed.
And proper road design also leads to less intelligence and fancy car design being required. I rather get hit by a shitty designed unsafe old car at 20mph then a fancy new car at 30mph.
Lets be real here, automated driving or not, having actually save roads helps prevent death and harm in many cases.
The hyper focus on high tech software by all the agencies engaged in 'automotive security' is totally wrongly focused. What they should actually do is point out how insanely unsafe and broken the infrastructure is, specially for people outside of cars.
See: "Confessions of a Recovering Engineer: Transportation for a Strong Town"