News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by googlryas on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:03PM (#34825034)
Does the government have the right to destroy whatever it wants in the air? Could this club sue for the cost of the balloon?
Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by shadowgovt on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:37PM (#34825655)
> Does the government have the right to destroy whatever it wants in the air?

Hashtag-its-complicated.

To a first approximation: no. The US scrambling a fighter to blast a plane full of people out of the sky would be a huge mess and incur significant lawsuits.

Refining the approximation: militaries accepts the burden of responsibility to protect their people from threats, including airborne threats. Airborne threats are already traveling with significant potential (and often kinetic) energies so they are default-threatening. So militaries have wide discretion to presume an aircraft with no transponder is hostile and respond appropriately. A lawsuit on that topic would land somewhere between "no compensation" and "Sorry kids; Uncle Sam had to blow up your project to protect mom and apple pie; here's the money for the cost of the mylar and radio parts."

At the boundary-limit of the responsibilities, you can find disasters like the tragedy of Korean Airlines (KAL) flight 007, where Soviet planes failed to establish contact with a commercial airliner and shot it out of the sky.

Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by pengaru on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:08PM (#34825116)
> Does the government have the right o destroy whatever it wants in the air? Could this club sue for the cost of the balloon?

I assume the reason nobody seems to be eager to claim these downed balloons is fear of their liability for flying unregistered, transponder-less hazards to other flights.

Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by pc86 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:32PM (#34825564)
Transponders are not required for payloads below approximately 100x the weight of these types of balloons. There is zero liability, but also zero recourse.

It's hard to argue that if the government can't identify something operating in controlled airspace that it can't take measures pretty solidly in the realm of "national defense," up to and including blowing it up.

Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by bdcravens on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:07PM (#34825104)
According to the article, the balloon cost $12 (though I'm sure there whatever equipment attached to it was much more)
Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by Consultant32452 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:40PM (#34825709)
I'm imagining the Commander in Chief having to show up to small claims court because he shot down your $12 balloon with $400,000 worth of ordinance.
Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by not2b on Thursday February 16, 2023 @04:00PM (#34826057)
No, sovereign immunity.
Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by apendleton on Thursday February 16, 2023 @04:33PM (#34826660)
Minor nit: an "ordinance" is a rule or law; "ordnance" is the stuff that blows up.
Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by kube-system on Thursday February 16, 2023 @04:40PM (#34826773)
Is it because they shoot their 'i' out?
Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by thaumasiotes on Thursday February 16, 2023 @06:56PM (#34828566)
> I'm imagining the Commander in Chief having to show up to small claims court because he shot down your $12 balloon with $400,000 worth of ordinance.

The president can't be sued over official actions. Your suit would just be thrown out.

https://www.law.cornell.edu/constitution-conan/article-2/sec...

Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by ceejayoz on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:06PM (#34825080)
> Could this club sue for the cost of the balloon?

Almost certainly not. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_immunity_in_the_Unit...

Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by michaelhoffman on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:18PM (#34825308)
If you read the linked article, you will find that the United States has laws that waive sovereign immunity for torts committed by people acting on behalf of the federal government. Which is what I assume would be alleged here.

That doesn't mean that they would win such a lawsuit, however.

Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by ceejayoz on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:27PM (#34825479)
They can waive torts, yes. Doing so is a very specific process.

Cops regularly get qualified immunity for absolutely egregious conduct. The military is not going to get successfully sued for shooting down a $12 balloon while acting in good faith on national security duties.

Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by michaelhoffman on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:38PM (#34825664)
What do you think the "very specific process" involved for the federal government waiving immunity to tort claims? I assume that is what you mean by "waive torts" which is a phrase that doesn't really make sense. Since it is "very specific", can you describe it?

Again, you may want to carefully read the article you linked, and linked articles within such as the one on the Federal Tort Claims Act: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Federal_Tort_Claims_Act

Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by ceejayoz on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:52PM (#34825909)
You ask what the procedure is, and then link right to it. Legislation giving citizens the right to sue in certain scenarios. Without the government's OK, no suing the government.

The decision here would be "there's no clearly established law that the US can't shoot down a balloon with an F-22" on qualified immunity grounds.

Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by michaelhoffman on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:59PM (#34826041)
That legislation has already been passed. The Federal Tort Claims Act has been the law of the land for 77 years.
Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by ceejayoz on Thursday February 16, 2023 @04:01PM (#34826072)
And qualified immunity in these sorts of scenarios (and much, much more deliberately egregious conduct) has been the reality of the land since 1967.
Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by hgsgm on Thursday February 16, 2023 @04:39PM (#34826743)
Qualified immunity is for personal liability, not government liability.
Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by gnopgnip on Thursday February 16, 2023 @05:54PM (#34827781)
Individual government employees are covered by qualified immunity, not their employer
Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by karaterobot on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:15PM (#34825251)
I don't think you should be downvoted for asking a question. I'm sure there are legalities we don't understand, so it's legitimate to ask about them. I'd also like to read a response from an informed source.
Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by throwawaysleep on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:11PM (#34825173)
I believe there are rules on flying stuff.
Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by jabroni_salad on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:27PM (#34825482)
With hobby balloons they are usually small enough to be exempt from FAA 101.

Even if they aren't, you just need permission from whoever controls your airspace (call them 20 minutes ahead of time) and only launch if there is very good visibility around the ascent path.

Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by shagie on Thursday February 16, 2023 @03:47PM (#34825818)
The key treaty on this is the Chicago Convention https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chicago_Convention_on_Internat...

https://www.icao.int/Meetings/anconf12/Document%20Archive/an...

Appendix 4 - Unmanned free balloons

2.1 An unmanned free balloon shall not be operated without appropriate authorization from the State from which the launch is made.

2.2 An unmanned free balloon, other than a light balloon used exclusively for meteorological purposes and operated in the manner prescribed by the appropriate authority, shall not be operated across the territory of another State without appropriate authorization from the other State concerned.

2.3 The authorization referred to in 2.2 shall be obtained prior to the launching of the balloon if there is reasonable expectation, when planning the operation, that the balloon may drift into airspace over the territory of another State. Such authorization may be obtained for a series of balloon flights or for a particular type of recurring flight, e.g. atmospheric research balloon flights.

2.4 An unmanned free balloon shall be operated in accordance with conditions specified by the State of Registry and the State(s) expected to be overflown.

---

Section 2.2 and 2.3 is applicable here. That they didn't know, and the government didn't know, and this wasn't a exclusively used as a weather balloon... there are possibly some things that the hobbyists did that may not have been completely within the bounds of the treaty.

There are also things like:

FAA guidance - https://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/publications/atpubs/atc_html...

Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by throwanem on Thursday February 16, 2023 @05:24PM (#34827378)
> there are possibly some things that the hobbyists did that may not have been completely within the bounds of the treaty

Given the geopolitical moment, I'm inclined to think it might work out for the best if that were so.

Not that today's neocon China hawks are any more in the habit of listening to reason than they were when they were the neocon Iraq hawks of a couple of decades ago, but anything that gives everyone else another reason not to listen to their incessant warmongering is in my view entirely welcome.

Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by qwery on Thursday February 16, 2023 @07:37PM (#34828978)
The story is about US civilians' balloons, launched domestically, being shot down while over the US (I think).
Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by shagie on Thursday February 16, 2023 @08:13PM (#34829352)
The civilians know where they are (GPS or other tracking back), but the various government agencies don't.

While this is applicable for balloons with a larger payload (that the size of the balloon was specifically under to be unregulated) ... https://www.faa.gov/air_traffic/publications/atpubs/atc_html...

Post the balloon flight on flight progress strips along the planned trajectory and revise routing as tracking/position reports require.

Radar flight follow balloons to the extent that equipment capabilities permit. If radar flight following is not possible, tracking should be attempted by communication with the “chase plane,” telephone contact with the operator, pilot, or ground observation reports.

Provide traffic advisories to all affected aircraft during initial contact specifying the balloon's known or estimated position, direction of movement, and altitude as “unknown” or “reported,” as appropriate.

Unless ATC requires otherwise, operators of unmanned free balloons are required to monitor the course of the balloon and record its position at least every two hours. As required in 14 CFR Section 101.39a, balloon position reports are not forwarded by the operator unless requested by ATC.

    UNMANNED FREE BALLOON OVER (name of location),
    or
    ESTIMATED OVER (name of location), MOVING 
    (direction of movement).
    LAST REPORTED ALTITUDE AT (altitude as reported by the operator or determined from pilot report),
    or
    ALTITUDE UNKNOWN.
---

If this was followed, and someone could say "there's a balloon near this location which is similar to the last reported location of Northern Illinois Bottlecap Balloon Brigade balloon 12345" this probably wouldn't have happened.

As it is, they're getting into the airspace used by airliners at a time when peoples' hackles are raised with unknown balloons.

As it is, this still falls under the Chicago Convention.

> 2.2 An unmanned free balloon, other than a light balloon used exclusively for meteorological purposes and operated in the manner prescribed by the appropriate authority, shall not be operated across the territory of another State without appropriate authorization from the other State concerned.

> 2.3 The authorization referred to in 2.2 shall be obtained prior to the launching of the balloon if there is reasonable expectation, when planning the operation, that the balloon may drift into airspace over the territory of another State. Such authorization may be obtained for a series of balloon flights or for a particular type of recurring flight, e.g. atmospheric research balloon flights.

This is not exclusively a meteorological balloon. It is not getting authorization from the airspace it drifts into. That is not being done prior to a launch and as it travels.

Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by qwery on Saturday February 18, 2023 @09:47AM (#34847278)
Thanks for explaining!
Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by sam345 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @09:00PM (#34829712)
I'm not an international lawyer but I'm fairly certain the Chicago convention has nothing to do with states within the US, it has to do with nation states. So the above is totally irrelevant.
Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by shagie on Thursday February 16, 2023 @09:35PM (#34829987)
It sets down the rules for which civil aviation (including unmanned free balloons) follow. You could argue that "a balloon launched in Illinois and found in Alaska is within the US"... but it transited other countries airspace (there is no way for a balloon from Illinois to get to northern Alaska except the long way around) and should have been following the rules there.

And so, the question that I'll ask - "did the people launching balloon obtain permission to launch from the United States and prior permission for countries that it passed over?"

This isn't exclusively a weather balloon - which has a different carve out for permissions.

But it is an aircraft that traveled internationally and through the airspace of multiple different countries.

Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by Rimintil on Thursday February 16, 2023 @04:51PM (#34826932)
Why would someone sue over what is likely less than $100 in total costs? That's silly. You can only recover actual cost.

Plus, who wouldn't be proud to be able to claim "I launched something that was shot down by an F-22!"?

Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by CydeWeys on Thursday February 16, 2023 @04:57PM (#34827032)
It's not quite the right question to ask. The government is going to destroy whatever it wants to in the air, and there's only ever gonna be potential consequences (of a diplomatic nature) if it accidentally results in the injury/death of an innocent party.

The Supreme Court is not going to intervene here in matters of military discretion, and no one is going to be able to sue here over this.

Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by tshaddox on Thursday February 16, 2023 @05:14PM (#34827256)
> Dad, I tried to go to school, but this guy won't let me.

Oh yeah?! Him and what army?!

> The U.S. Army.

Oh that's a good army.

Re:Hobby Club’s Missing Balloon Feared Shot Down by USAF by markjenkinswpg on Thursday February 16, 2023 @05:52PM (#34827752)
Not only does the government have the right to destroy it, but so does anyone else.

There's no reasonable expectation of recovery when you launch a balloon calibrated to go globe-trotting.

It's basically no different than the person who abandoned a mattress at my apartment block's dumpster. It's littering. They're giving it away, they're not expecting to be able to come back for it later.

Furthermore, nobody has a right to unregistered, unmanned, long duration balloon flight. Such a right would only exist if a state constructed it for its citizens. (and it would end at their boundaries)

I think it's cool that in practice people have been able to do so, but it seems the cool times are coming to an end.