News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by news_to_me on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:33AM (#34806214)
My first “real” job after college (2013) I started at $60k. It was more than my mom, an elementary school teacher, ever made. It felt embarrassing. Teachers are at least as valuable as software developers (probably more), given their impact on society. Why do they make so little?
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by RajT88 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:41AM (#34806412)
Impact is huge, but they don't generate revenue for the organization which pays them. Therefore - their pay is a function of the budget that is available.

Public school budgets are set of course by property taxes. If you teach in a rich district, you get paid more. If you teach in a poor district, you get paid less. The way public schools are funded helps keep the rich rich, and the poor poor.

Unfortunately, the political clout is held by the rich who want their tax money to go only to their children and not those other children (or "those othered children" if you like). Even though, if we switched to a more equal funding model for public schools, we'd see improvements in the wealth gap and society in general within a generation or two.

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by toast0 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:06PM (#34806967)
> Public school budgets are set of course by property taxes. If you teach in a rich district, you get paid more. If you teach in a poor district, you get paid less. The way public schools are funded helps keep the rich rich, and the poor poor.

That depends on the state. In California, most school districts have their budgets set by the state funding formula which provides state funding above the local property tax revenues. There are a handful of school districts where local property tax revenue provides more than the state formula, although I haven't been able to find a list of those districts recently.

The California funding system was in place since 1972 (with major changes in 2013). Have we seen improvements in the wealth gap and society in general?

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by RajT88 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @04:28PM (#34810818)
I wasn't aware of this funding system, so I had to look it up. The (quite prolific) literature suggest that the funding system was severely limited in 1978 by Prop 13.
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by toast0 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @05:22PM (#34811605)
Sure, school funding has been limited; but the point is that excluding the basic aid school districts (which are mostly smaller districts, afaik, the largest is Newport-Mesa Unified), all of the school districts across the state have been subject to the same funding formulas.

Your comment was that equalizing funding would make society better; my question is, given that funding has been mostly equalized in California, is society better?

In Washington state, funding for basic education is apportioned from state revenues; local districts can raise taxes for enrichment, but there's a cap, and state funds are provided if local taxes don't meet a minimum. I'm not familiar with other states, but there have been several court cases where states were forced to reform systems that relied on local property tax [1]; and I'd imagine many states would have changed their systems after seeing those results, rather than waiting for their own case.

[1] https://edeq.stanford.edu/sections/section-4-lawsuits/landma...

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by mwint on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:35AM (#34806260)
Supply and demand, like always. The market cares not one bit about what someone “should” be paid, it cares about the price where no one is left willing to do the same job for less.

If you want teachers to be paid more, increase the requirements to be a teacher. I’m a proponent of requiring at least n years experience in real world work, plus education in a hard science or trade.

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by news_to_me on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:42AM (#34806434)
What demand though? Nobody “buys” what public teachers produce - it’s a public service. It’s up to the state (and ultimately, voters) to decide what teachers make. And it’s even harder for teachers to advocate for themselves in states where teacher unions are banned.
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by mwint on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:45AM (#34806507)
There’s absolutely a supply demand cycle here. If wages are too low, teachers will do something else. School quality suffers, parents (may) make noise, politicians raise the wages (or do something else to appease their constituents).

The voters are the customers.

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by kristopolous on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:49AM (#34806607)
Can you give any material historical examples to support your hypothesis?
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by monocasa on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:40AM (#34806389)
I mean, we already have massive teacher shortages. Class sizes keep going up, and many school systems are switching to four day schedules because of staffing issues.

Not everything can be looked at from a macro econ 101 supply and demand take; the real world is much more complicated than that.

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by jacobr1 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:05PM (#34806954)
Sometimes it is more complicated, but in this case the analysis does apply. The problem isn't on the demand side, but on the supply. And one way to increase supply is to charge a higher price, or otherwise compensate (more time off, better work environment, prestige, etc ...) and a big part of the reason we have a teacher shortage is that there aren't enough compensatory incentives.
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by monocasa on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:12PM (#34807066)
Sure, my point was more about the parent's analysis of "if you want teachers to be paid more, make less teachers".

ie. I'm saying that we don't have to put our hopes in the basket of hoping that economic pressures force higher wages if we make teachers less prevalent; we can simply pay them more.

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by giardini on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:51PM (#34807723)
Supply and demand aren't part of macroeconomics but of microeconomics
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by monocasa on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:53PM (#34807771)
It's part of both.
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by nfRfqX5n on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:39AM (#34806381)
What other requirements? Teachers require at least a 4 year degree. Specialists like speech therapists require a masters degree. Try paying off a masters degree with a teachers salary.
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:40AM (#34806399)
> Supply and demand, like always.

Not everything follows the rules of capitalism, especially when public school teachers are paid by the government. There are giant teacher shortages across many locales in the US, so according to you we should see skyrocketing teacher pay, but that hasn't happened (pay has gone up in some locales but nowhere near the amount needed to fix teacher shortages).

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by kimbernator on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:43AM (#34806478)
The government doesn't have traditional shareholders like a corporation. Obviously they have their citizens as shareholders of a sort, but at the moment it feels like the loudest groups are prioritizing budget over outcomes.
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by kimbernator on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:41AM (#34806407)
Ideological divides aside, this is an obvious downside of modern capitalism; Value is defined as what brings in money, which I would wager 99% of people would generally agree is not the best definition for the public interest. It is the easiest to measure, though.

Trite as it may be to say, there's an obvious value to attracting a larger amount of people to teaching, it's just hard to quantify and takes longer than most politicians' term limits to see the larger benefits.

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by kneebonian on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:46AM (#34806544)
> this is an obvious downside of modern capitalism; Value is defined as what brings in money,

And in communism value is defined as what will get you promoted.

And in autocracy value is loyalty to the party line

And in Neo-Nazism value is what kills the most Jews

And so on and so forth, let's not pretend that people making short sighted decisions for personal gain is limited to a single economic system it may be more visible or exactrebated by one system or another but it isn't like Lusheynkinism was pushed because it helped the students of the USSR better feed their people.

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by kimbernator on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:52AM (#34806699)
The problem I'm trying to highlight is that the capitalism and focus on the short-term of business is leaking a bit too much into the operation of government. Instead of directing resources in a thoughtful way, it seems more like we're trying to check boxes for the lowest price and forget about the purpose of that funding.
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by jacobr1 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:09PM (#34807010)
Except with something like K12 education we don't actually allocate resources in a market/capitalist fashion. So is your argument that we have a "mindset" problem?

One could suggest the opposite problem, we don't have enough markets in eduction and could do more with charters and vouchers, or programs like magnet schools.

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by kristopolous on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @02:21PM (#34809151)
"brings in money" is so specious. The whole system is subject to how the accounting is structured.

Education certainly produces community value. Moving around what column the cost and benefits should be attributed to is a kind of social gerrymandering.

It's a function of ideology and power asymmetry. A well educated populace will of course be better off.

You're not going to find out why police make twice as much as teachers with neoliberal economics. Fabulists depict things this way to remove human agency and make specific legislative and policy decisions take on the authority of natural law, as if it's a scientific absolute.

It's just a slight of hand. All these things can be changed and the sky will not fall.

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by dividefuel on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:22PM (#34807271)
I think we tend to see the opposite cycle playing out more often:

"We can't hire enough teachers" -> "Let's reduce the requirements" -> "These teachers aren't very good or qualified, there's no reason to give them a raise" -> "We can't hire enough teachers!"

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by AndrewGaspar on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:38AM (#34806340)
I'm sure your mom is great, but teachers have low value over replacement. Teaching is not a particularly high skill or difficult job.
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by _bohm on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:47AM (#34806560)
Difficult how? A relative of mine is a teacher in a high-poverty area and it seems like a very taxing job. Regularly having to deal with children who are emotionally or physically abused, or who recently immigrated and don't even speak english, and trying to teach them math. I daresay this is not a set of challenges most software engineers I've met would be well equipped to handle.
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by AndrewGaspar on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:48AM (#34806589)
I haven't seen a lot of evidence actual teachers handle problem children all that well either.
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by _bohm on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:51AM (#34806666)
Right, seems rather difficult!
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by kimbernator on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:48AM (#34806576)
I'd strongly disagree with your assertion that teaching is not a difficult job. I won't address the exertion that goes into individual parts of it, but all of the teachers I know regularly work nights and weekends in addition to handling the emotional stress of teaching, which itself is a huge burden, especially for those working in less affluent schools.

In any case, the measure for teachers should not be "how hard is the job" but rather "how important is the outcome". It might be easy enough to replace a teacher without raising the salary (another assertion I have issues with - there are rampant teacher shortages nationwide), but could you not be potentially getting a better teacher and having broadly positive effects on society if you're offering more money?

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by AndrewGaspar on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:56AM (#34806780)
> all of the teachers I know regularly work nights and weekends

There's a difference between difficulty and exertion.

> how important is the outcome

It's pretty damn important that the garbage man comes and collects the trash every week, but we don't pay him the marginal value of trash collection to the county.

> another assertion I have issues with - there are rampant teacher shortages nationwide

I actually agree that the market doesn't seem to be clearing due to stingy education departments and state government. We should probably break their monopsony power by privatizing education.

> could you not be potentially getting a better teacher and having broadly positive effects on society if you're offering more money

If you want to make the argument we should fire all the current teachers and replace them with people who would otherwise be accountants or actuaries or software engineers, I'd be amenable to the argument.

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by toast0 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:31PM (#34807404)
> I actually agree that the market doesn't seem to be clearing due to stingy education departments and state government. We should probably break their monopsony power by privatizing education.

If the state is still paying, they're still going to be stingy.

A private school has roughly the same administrative staff as a public school. Their buildings may be a little bit less expensive, as they probably can get away with less ADA accessibility. They probably don't pay into pensions and may not provide as nice of health care, so they may be able to move more of total comp into salaries, but they may also compensate their board members more. Word on the street is private school teachers get paid less and have less due process, but also have less stringent degree requirements and fewer mandates in their classroom. But they also get a lot more parental engagement, and a rather different cohort of students.

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by jacobr1 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:21PM (#34807242)
Note we tend to pay garbagemen more than teachers! I think that probably seeks to the job desirability. More people are willing to be teachers than haul garbage and that is reflected in the pay, net of other impacts.
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by astura on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @02:32PM (#34809339)
Where are people getting this shit from?

According to the BLS garbage collectors have a median annual wage of $ 42,780[1] whereas elementary school teachers have a median annual wage of $61,400[2].

[1]https://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes537081.htm

[2]https://www.bls.gov/ooh/education-training-and-library/kinde...

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by jacobr1 on Thursday February 16, 2023 @04:46PM (#34826846)
thanks for the correction
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by spyremeown on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:53AM (#34806718)
>Teaching is not a particularly high skill or difficult job.

Even though I disagree with you I can see where you're coming from with this sentence, but: the impact is HUGE. The impact of good teachers on society cannot be overstated. It's an amazing ROI and everything we can do to further the education of humankind is worth doing.

Programming (mostly) isn't that hard as well, compare software engineering with electronics engineering, for example, but the impact is huge: that's why you're probably well paid to do it and your company makes your life really easy, with all the bells and whistles to make you happy.

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by jacobr1 on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:18PM (#34807187)
> Programming (mostly) isn't that hard as well

More people could be trained to program, especially in a casual way many more (spreadsheet formulas, low-code forms or glue) but working as mentor in high-school CS programs, I've been surprised in both directions. There are a bunch of bright people out there that could move into programming with just a boost to their training to enable them to bootstrap further ... and there are lots of people that just don't have the mindset. Abstract reasoning or modeling the world is just not something they are capable of doing without intense concentration, if that. It just doesn't come naturally to these people.

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by AnIdiotOnTheNet on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:37AM (#34806304)
Because of targeted propaganda and attacks by an organized political group that holds, as an ideology, that public institutions should not exist and everything should be done by the private sector.
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by mattmcknight on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:38AM (#34806355)
If this were true, wouldn't private school teachers be paid considerably more? In my area, they are paid considerably less.
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by monocasa on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:41AM (#34806414)
Why would that follow that private school teachers would be paid more?
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by aisengard on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:55AM (#34806758)
Yeah, the horrible pay in private school is proof enough that the "free" market is the absolute wrong way to go if you want better teachers.
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by mattmcknight on Thursday February 16, 2023 @12:24AM (#34815384)
The claim was that school teacher salaries were low "Because of targeted propaganda and attacks by an organized political group that holds, as an ideology, that public institutions should not exist and everything should be done by the private sector. reply".

Since private schools are not subject to these attacks, their salaries would not be lowered by these attacks, making them relatively higher.

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by sangnoir on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:41PM (#34807546)
That could only happen if private schools hired from a closed environment. In reality, there's a large pool of underpaid public school teachers that private schools can hire from while giving a 5-10% raise, which leaves private school teachers with 1.1x of a low salary.
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by kristopolous on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:47AM (#34806555)
This suggests a large disparity that's culturally based which I've been unable to find. I can find a comparative disparity such as https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2021/10/teachers-pay-countrie...

But this isn't helpful. Those need to be normalized by the median by country and then expressed in some deviation metric to get a real idea.

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by bfeynman on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:44AM (#34806498)
maybe because "impact on society" is a totally delusional way to make pay scales. Pay is almost entirely based on talent scarcity. Thats why low skill jobs are lower pay, and highly skilled professions pay more accordingly. It doesn't matter at all what your impact is, think of people who work(ed) in mines or in the fields.
Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by kneebonian on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @11:48AM (#34806602)
I'd argue it's not just talent scarcity it's measurable talent scarcity. There are really great teachers out there that do a fantastic job there are terrible teachers that suck, they are mostly paid the same because it's hard to differentiate between a good teacher and a bad teacher.

Whereas with a software developer especially at small orgs their ability is easier to measure and evaluate.

Re:Sanders calls for minimum salary of $60000 for public sch... by giardini on Wednesday February 15, 2023 @12:47PM (#34807664)
All explained, without embarrassment, by the undergraduate economics concepts of supply and demand.