> The U.S. Justice Department has reached a settlement with dozens of conservative groups that claimed the Internal Revenue Service unfairly scrutinized them based on their political leanings when they sought a tax-exempt status, court documents showed.
I don't know anything about the German guy.
I wouldn't be confident that every piece of equipment in that office was obtained legally in the country, let alone being able to prove it. For example someone whose mobile phone got lost/smashed/blownup last time they were in Kabul, so they bought a new one, then returned to their Delhi office. Or a piece of equipment that was legally imported back in 2012 but the paperwork has gone. Or a UK purchased harddrive that a passing cameraman left in the edit suite, or something bought locally but the receipt didn't list the serial number on it.
I'm confident there will be an "irregularity" somewhere. I'm confident any office in any building in any city in the world will have similar problems irrefutably proving where any equipment came from.
How is that related to the BBC?
I think iso1631 is saying that there may be enough red tape for imports into India that the BBC could technically be breaking the law for failing to declare/pay duties on some equipment they or their employees brought into the country.
If you're in the US, my experience is that it's kind of an anomaly in terms of relatively light enforcement of import taxes for individual citizens. For example, most countries will look at the declared value on foreign parcels and force the recipient to pay import tax before releasing it to them.[1] If someone walked the same thing over the border, and the government wanted to make things hard on that person, they might accuse them of tax evasion, etc.
[1] For those NOT in the US wondering how this is unusual, individuals generally don't have to pay before receiving the parcel here.
It wasn't the employees home raided but the BBC office.
Or at least that's how the law works in a lot of countries.
Assuming the perpetrator is unknown.
Who pays out for the damages ultimately?
Then the same thing. The police and the prosecution find out if this was illegal, if the possession is illegal, who possesed if and who brought it and why, then who is responsible and a court decides if someone is guilty. The court will decide if the company is responsible E.g. because of negligence, they might not have implemented the law, educated their employees etc. In the case of dynamite that an employee brought, the company is not responsible, there might be terrorism charges against the employee.
The company is always ultimately responsible for whatever is discovered on their premises by default.
Well yes
If those phones were bought out of country there may be tax implications
I was arguing with the OP that Capone's sentence was not political but this thing is.
He is in jail because of increased flight risk as he cleaned out his house and was trying to sell it.
The highest German court is currently deciding if his jail time is too long already.
Yes but that doesn't stop comfortably wealthy westerners who've never been harassed by any government or quasi-government institutions will happily do all sorts of mental gymnastics to justify such behavior when it's done to people they don't like and don't see themselves having much in common with.
Twisting the law so you can jail a known criminal for a term that is unreasonable for the charges you can actually convict him on is surely a far cry from jailing political opponents over BS but it is on the same spectrum of odious government behavior and the fact of the matter is that HN types tend to draw the "here is where I stop looking the other way" line on that spectrum a lot closer to the "jailing dissidents" end than people who have adversarial contact with such institutions.
> doesn't stop comfortably wealthy westerners who've never been harassed by any government or quasi-government institutions
It comes across like a prejudiced assumption, and just hurts it. Flames others into an incendiary mess. Why are you so mad, who is it towards? Westerners? Dungeons and dragons of all things has been dealing with these ethics surrounding laws for years. Games. Your anger is misdirected at "hn types" because that is just a generalization.
Regardless, your principle stands. The ends justifying the means as a principle is despised for good reasons even if some laud it as well.
The question should rather be: Is this a good thing or abusing the power?
(Al Capone did tax fraud on a spectacular level, among other more serious offenses. BBC shown a documentary. Feel the difference?)
Also: billion flies eating shit will not make it a good thing. :/
Bad habbit should be a repelling thing not something be repeated and brought forward as excuse for gods sake!
(I cannot tell if the above examples for abuse are founded or not, except Al Capone, my response is for this 'other do so I will too' kind of derailed rhetoric or alibi that I hate so so much)
Financial crimes tend to be a lot harder to hide than bodies, and the witnesses (in the form of records) harder to bribe.
“My father,” Elliott Roosevelt observed of his famous parent, “may have been the originator of the concept of employing the IRS as a weapon of political retribution.”
https://www.hillsdale.edu/educational-outreach/free-market-f...
Nobody is claiming that India's corruption is unique or unprecedented, just that it is happening. Germany and the US have done a lot worse than selective prosecution, and it would be better if India did not do those other, worse things.
"It's all right because the US and Germany did it" gives you slavery and death camps.
I think you have that backwards.
Ballweg is in jail because allegedly he took in donations to support a cause, but then (ab)used them for himself personally, defrauding the donors and evading taxation. That's illegal, and thus he's in jail.
Indeed protesting Covid is not enough to put you in jail, because that's not actually illegal. You're insinuating the government chose to persecute him for his political views. That's a pretty bold claim that I think would need substantiation.
Isn't that what every government do? Remember that Al Capone went to jail because of tax issues, the government couldn't prove anything he was accused to.
If you look at Germany, Michael Ballweg is sitting in jail (without trial) for tax evasion accusations. The fact that the government didn't like his movement that protested against unconstitutional anti-covid measures was not enough reason to put him there.
Almost every government has a history of unleashing a tax department on their political enemies. We call it a legal state when it happens in our country, and a state terror when it happens in another.
A cynic in me would say that, in this case, India is learning from the best democracies in the world, US and Germany.