News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by idopmstuff on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:10PM (#34765143)
Just send the taxpayer a bill that says what the IRS think they owes. That information is already there! It's already being calculated! Just print and send!

(I am being somewhat facetious here, as I'm aware there's always vastly more complexity to anything being done by a bureaucracy the size of the federal government than meets the eye, but still.)

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by kodah on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:23PM (#34765275)
> That information is already there! It's already being calculated!

This is a common misconception, especially on HN. For the average tax payer this might be truthy, but only insofar as the IRS is aware of certain tax events. If you had a kid, the IRS might be able to correlate that you and someone had a child, and they might, depending on the county registrar, be able to determine you're married. This gets even more complicated with business interests and finance in the small business realm.

That's to say, the system you described probably isn't ever going to materialize. The IRS is not some omnipotent entity. They're going to need something akin to TurboTax that asks you a bunch of questions and juxtaposes that with things they know for certain like your net income and net losses that are reported throughout the year. That system also needs to be able to read and adapt to evolving tax code as time goes on.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by ldoughty on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:42PM (#34765513)
They didn't stop the IRS from telling us what they know and what they expect, and if it's accurate and you don't dispute their information, you pay the bill and attest you have no other income.

I wouldn't care if I over pay. After paying someone hundreds in fees to do my taxes I don't usually get much of any money back. I'd rather let the government keep $400 than give it to a tax company that probably won't actually help me in an audit.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by ok123456 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:31PM (#34765377)
Make a buffer of $3k: you don't owe a return unless the difference between what they have per-calculated and what owe is over that. This would eliminate 95% of returns and tax documents.

This is roughly what the UK does.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by kodah on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:40PM (#34765485)
The IRS already kind of does this. They know that when someone itemizes their expenses and their net income is x while net losses are y that their itemization has an error threshold of +/-z, where z is an already padded number. All that does is decrease the number of non-random audits they have to do. I'm not sure it'd really make taxes any more simple or complicated than they already are.

It's probably important to note there's many different camps here:

1. People who want a simpler tax code (eg: flat tax)

2. People who don't want to have to pay tax processors

3. People who don't want the IRS submission to be an exercise in hedging

Personally, I'm more in camp 2, because I recognize our tax code is full of levers we use, that change and adapt, to incentivizes activity in the economy.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by renewiltord on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:50PM (#34765599)
Interestingly, enough, this is yet another thing to add to the list of things that are impossible to do (according to the Internet) but are already done by someone else that I've encountered in the US:

1. Final price including tax

2. Fiber to the home

3. Optional tax returns

4. High speed rail

5. Unarmed alternatives to police

Of those, the following have (despite being impossible to do though already done) managed to find themselves unimpossibled:

1. Fiber to the home (I had it)

2. High speed rail (Acela)

3. Unarmed alternatives to police (Camden, NJ)

The fascinating thing about the Internet is all these things that just are so impossible to do (usually in the US) but are somehow already done elsewhere and then, given time, the impossible is done. At the rate of impossibilities, I think we might actually be the case that dS<0 is possible globally.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by klyrs on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:51PM (#34765609)
For those incredibly rare events, the IRS doesn't need perfect omniscience. For the vast majority of the population, for the vast majority of their years filing taxes, it can be extremely simple. A checkbox "did you have a kid, get married or divorced, or die this year" will pretty much cover it for most people.

Business taxes are different. That's fine. Accountants are a cost of doing business.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by kodah on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:03PM (#34765723)
16% of the US, or roughly 30M people, also own businesses which take advantage of an evolving and incentivized tax code. That's why I said making it more simple doesn't solve the problems people think it does. An e-file system with the appropriate questions asked could leave our tax system in place and eliminate tax processing fees.

Some people have very simple taxes, no doubt, but I wouldn't design a system as important as tax collection that would purposefully over charge a large portion of the population.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by klyrs on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:18PM (#34765872)
Yep, 84% is a pretty big majority, is it not? You aren't really disagreeing with me. The general proposal is that you'd get a "tax bill" that would typically be for $0 for people thanks to automatic payroll deductions, and can be safely ignored if you file your taxes. Businesses would file taxes, the vast majority of people would not.

If your concern is that business owners blindly pay bills without reading bold text that says something along the lines of "if you have additional deductions to report, file your taxes, find more information at https://..." then those business owners weren't going to last a year anyway.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by kodah on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:24PM (#34765941)
I probably conflated OPs argument that the IRS already knows everything they need to know about you, which is not true. Someone else posted the stat on this thread that roughly 40% of Americans could benefit from what the IRS already knows. 60% would not.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by PopAlongKid on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:27PM (#34766535)
>$0 for people thanks to automatic payroll deductions

Only perhaps if you have a single job and no other income. How would one employer know what you (or your spouse) earned at other jobs during the year? They can't deduct the correct amount without knowing your full year result, which is obviously impossible to implement with pay period withholding.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by pessimizer on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:08PM (#34765765)
> Some people have very simple taxes, no doubt

Looks like 84% are left unless you want to peel off a few more.

> I wouldn't design a system as important as tax collection that would purposefully over charge a large portion of the population.

Nobody is asking you to. I would absolutely do work for 100% of people that only 84% would be able to fully use. Imagine not building roads because only 84% of people drive.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by dqv on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:53PM (#34765627)
>This is a common misconception, especially on HN. For the average tax payer this might be truthy, but only insofar as the IRS is aware of certain tax events. If you had a kid, the IRS might be able to correlate that you and someone had a child, and they might, depending on the county registrar, be able to determine you're married. This gets even more complicated with business interests and finance in the small business realm.

The child tax credit and other tax credits are bad examples. The IRS isn't going to bust your front door open because you didn't take a tax credit. What would end up happening under the push tax system is:

IRS: "We think you owe $4,200.69 in taxes"

Parents: "Not so fast! We had quadruplets this year, we're taking a credit!"

IRS: "Yikes, we'll give you $2,000 this year as a refund, good luck."

(I obviously have no idea what the tax credit for quadruplets is, this is not tax advice.)

It just doesn't make sense that we need to ask these questions every tax year: "Did you have kids? Did you get married? How much money did you make according to the W2 your employer already sent us? What other income did you make according to the 1099s we were already sent by other institutions?"

All of this just so a small group of people can be... checks notes... reminded to take a child tax credit? They can always just put a cute little reminder about the various tax credits on the bill.

The only other examples are highly-regulated or people who are already operating under the table (in which case the IRS already doesn't know and the IRS will continue to not know). Business tax returns are almost always going to have to continue as the IRS pulling the information, but for normal people, tax returns should not be a burden.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by Teever on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:58PM (#34765674)
It must be pretty disappointing to be a tech-savvy American who has a rough idea of the extent of surveillance that the NSA performs yet is also aware of how little benefit you're able to get from it.

It's sad that the IRS can't prefile taxes. The information is there.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by theptip on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:58PM (#34765682)
The system proposed above is how other countries such as the UK already do it, so hypothesizing that it’s impossible is an easily refutable position.

In countries that do auto withholding/filing, you still need to tell the tax authority about any tax events, but for most workers, most years don’t require you to take any action.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by Doxin on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:13AM (#34771559)
To add on to this comment, For the last 5 years filing my taxes in the Netherlands has involved logging into the tax app on my phone and then clicking the "yep looks good" button. This year I bought a house so perhaps it'll get a smidge more complex, but my mortgage has already been sent to the IRS-equivalent so I rather expect it to stay roughly the same level of complexity.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by idopmstuff on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:19PM (#34765878)
> For the average tax payer this might be truthy

It's completely true for most people. "And a new paper estimates that at least 41 percent of American households — some 62 million tax filing units — could have their entire tax returns handled this way with no further intervention necessary." https://www.vox.com/23055489/irs-automatic-filing-prepopulat...

Even if that's too high of an estimate, there are absolutely 10s of millions of people for whom the IRS already has the correct amount of taxes calculated based on the forms they receive from other entities. Sure, you might have to ask people a few questions, but my statement is accurate for an enormous percent of the population.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by smileysteve on Sunday February 12, 2023 @08:19PM (#34769051)
This covers not only the average but the 90%.

The IRS doesn't have to have facts on your marriage and children; all w2 employees already keep a w4 up to date with this information - or at least are legally bound to.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by repomies69 on Monday February 13, 2023 @01:33AM (#34770776)
Weird that in other countries it tends to work as described. My experience is from European countries is that most information is automatically filled in, then you fill the corrections. Most years you don't have to correct or add any information as they have already all of it.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by acdha on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:18PM (#34765225)
This is a political problem. It’s not like people at the IRS don’t see the appeal but that Congress hasn’t authorized doing it:

https://www.propublica.org/article/inside-turbotax-20-year-f...

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by idopmstuff on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:21PM (#34765904)
Yeah, it's largely a problem of Intuit doing a huge amount of lobbying of our elected officials.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by throwaway5959 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:11PM (#34765165)
It’s not a problem of technology, it’s a political issue thanks to tax software providers.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by logicalmonster on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:38PM (#34765469)
That corporatism is a part of it, but not the entire story. It's not like the IRS is a helpless victim of capitalist lobbying here. The IRS, and all parts of government, like having power over peoples' lives.

Here's an interesting and relevant news story.

https://news.yahoo.com/irs-urges-millions-taxpayers-delay-15...

If even the IRS doesn't know what their own rules are within the many pages of vague, complicated, and contradictory rules, what chance does an average person have to not mess up at least one thing in their taxes? The immense complexity of the tax code and the chance for getting something wrong gives them power to theoretically try and ruin anybody they want to go after, or at least have them have a lot of influence over peoples lives.

Governments want power and influence, and the IRS isn't going to vote to give away their own power. Having everybody being afraid of the IRS and making people jump through hoops gives them power and influence. This type of power isn't something that will go away with a fight.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by pessimizer on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:13PM (#34765815)
> It's not like the IRS is a helpless victim of capitalist lobbying here.

I'm not sure who you think is concerned about the feelings of the IRS, or its victimization. You've got the victims all topsy-turvy. Congress, an unbroken chain of bipartisan administrations, and their IRS are the perpetrators. The corporate cash is literally the only reason they care.

> the IRS isn't going to vote to give away their own power.

The IRS doesn't vote. Your theories of power are weird.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by logicalmonster on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:12PM (#34766397)
> I'm not sure who you think is concerned about the feelings of the IRS,

The IRS isn't exactly mute and helpless.

If the IRS came out at some inquiry and loudly said "Millionaires and billionaires can hire a tax firm to deal with these piles of paperwork we make people fill out, but it's a disgrace that normal people have to spend a great deal of time/money and life stress dealing with their taxes, when we already very likely know exactly what the upper theoretical bound of their tax payment is."

> The corporate cash is literally the only reason they care.

The reason for anything complicated cannot usually only be attributed to one reason. Money is always big influence, but so is power, and probably other variables.

> The IRS doesn't vote.

They're not literally voting, but they're choosing what benefits them the most, right?

Are you familiar with an exploratory task force or committee being where ideas are sent to be killed?

> Your theories of power are weird.

My theories of power are literally the standard throughout all of human history.

People very rarely voluntarily give up power that exists that benefits them.

Giving up power is so rare that the very few examples of it we have in human history, such as George Washington declining power, are heavily celebrated.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by red-iron-pine on Monday February 13, 2023 @10:16AM (#34774411)
Congress owns the IRS's budget. They control the tax laws.

What the IRS wants as an org is ultimately irrelevant, they're beholden to elected officials, who are in turn beholden to their voters and donors -- with a strong emphasis on the latter.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by tastyfreeze on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:28PM (#34765340)
That is the lobby portion. There is also a fairly large portion of the country that doesn't want to make it easier to file taxes because it encourages complacency with having the government take some of your money.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by snotrockets on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:57PM (#34766266)
Not just them. There's a whole contingency of right wing (both D & R) donors who ask for making taxes frustrating for most, as they don't want people to look favorably on the act of paying taxes, to keep people like the late Justice Holmes Jr. a minuscule minority.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by deelowe on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:18PM (#34765223)
Almost every deduction I take is report both by myself as well as the relevant 3rd party. They literally get a report from brokerages on stock transactions and yet I also have to calculate cost basis and all that. Why?!
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by morpheuskafka on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:39PM (#34765475)
You don't have to calculate cost basis since the brokerages started reporting it several years ago. You just enter the total form your 1099-Bs onto the Schedule D.

There are a few cases (some crypto 1099s) where they tell you the basis on the statement, but don't actually send that to the IRS since it's not a security. In that case, you'd copy

There are a few scenarios where the brokerage doesn't know the right basis though--examples would be a wash sale across two different accounts.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by bradleyjg on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:28PM (#34765337)
You don’t have to. If the bases are all reported to the irs, you just need to put the totals on schedule D.

It’s amazing how much whining there is about these forms. A smart high schooler could do even a moderately complicated tax return. It’s when you own a business of some kind (including investment properties) that things get hard.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by rqtwteye on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:32PM (#34765388)
Some people have a lot of other things to worry about.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by bradleyjg on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:34PM (#34765416)
But plenty of time to complain, apparently.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by kortilla on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:27PM (#34765333)
Those are the easy cases. The hard ones are deducting expenses for businesses.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by deelowe on Sunday February 12, 2023 @11:30PM (#34770132)
I have to do that too. Either way, it’s all a giant pain and seems largely to be a waste of time
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by tastyfreeze on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:20PM (#34765244)
To try to catch you lying of course.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by itake on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:25PM (#34765296)
My employer over-reported my income in 2021 multiple times on multiple w2s by 1.8x. We are still trying to sort it out.

I don't think I want a system where my employer could financially ruin me by misreporting income to the government.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by rqtwteye on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:30PM (#34765365)
This is why the IRS sending you a pre-filled return would help with such a situation. Right now the employer can make mistakes and you don't even know.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by josegonzalez on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:28PM (#34765341)
In which case you'd have the possibility to contest and file something more specific to your situation.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by itake on Sunday February 12, 2023 @05:28PM (#34767815)
Your suggestion sounds like the current system: I have to calculate the correct taxes and file them based on the truth.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by piperswe on Friday February 17, 2023 @04:52PM (#34841085)
Well yes, if you think the numbers the IRS calculated aren't quite right you'd still be free to file your own return.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by Vespasian on Sunday February 12, 2023 @02:28PM (#34765981)
Similar example from Germany:

In one year I had some "extra income" besides my job and had to file a return and pay some extra money.

The next year they asked me what my "extra income" was for that year and when the letter got lost by me they just assumed the same amount as the prior year and sent me the bill for that.

After the initial shock and beating myself up for that mistake, I could simply file a correction and got it fixed with no problem.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by xen2xen1 on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:58PM (#34766870)
Is there a website you could just have updated, or does that require paper forms? Randomly curious.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by Vespasian on Monday February 13, 2023 @04:02AM (#34771515)
I'm not sure and it was a few years ago.

I faintly recall being able to do it online but there is a fair chance that I missremember.

Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by seanmcdirmid on Sunday February 12, 2023 @01:26PM (#34765318)
You have that option if you have a very simple tax return. It’s like the IRS’s version of “I’m feeling lucky”.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by kwhitefoot on Sunday February 12, 2023 @03:36PM (#34766637)
This is how it works in Norway. Same in the rest of Scandinavia I think.
Re:IRS builds task force to explore running its own free e-f... by cvccvroomvroom on Wednesday February 22, 2023 @05:05PM (#34903603)
Norway did this by text message 20 years ago.

That the US makes it a labyrinthine game of special exceptions and complexity belies the obvious gamification geared towards the rich and to frustrate everyone that goes well past any excuse of bureaucracy. It's not a conspiracy theory, it's obvious wealth transfer from everyone not obscenely rich or obscenely poor disproportionately excluding centamillionaires and billionaires.