News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by billpatrianakos on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @01:53PM (#3475990)
This is interesting on a number of levels. I'm part of the minority around here that is in favor of copyright but don't write me off as a knee-jerk reaction to my stance.

An article like this could easily become a rallying cry for abolishing copyright but when you dig deeper it really doesn't lend itself to total copyright abolishment as much as you'd think.

It's interesting when you bear in mind that Dr. Martin Luther King held copyright on this speech and used the copyright laws to control how his speech was used. The way he wielded the power afforded to him by copyright is a great argument for copyright, not against it! If we make some conservative assumptions based on his actions and what we know of the man then it's safe to say he would allow the speech to become part of PBS documentaries but not used in corporate advertisements. Isnt it fair to believe that most of us these days would agree that his Dream speech be used in historical documentaries and other works that promote his legacy but be upset if we saw that speech used in a Nike commercial?

What I'm getting at here is that copyright itself isn't bad. It's how it is used that can be harmful but not always. Using copyright to keep MLK's legacy from being sullied is a legitimate and reasonable use for copyright. This particular case reminds us that copyright can be used for good too. If we fast forward to today and consider the King estate's attempt to make money from Dr. King's legacy we see what I'd call a gray area. Not everyone would want to see money being made in MLK's name. But far more people don't want to see the right to his words and likeness belonging to a corporation like EMI.

I want to encourage all of us to take a less extreme, more balanced perspective on this. Laws like SOPA/PIPA have backed us into a corner where we're forced to take extreme positions against extreme laws but here amongst friends, why not discuss this in a balanced way and save the extremism for fighting those with equally extreme stances on the other side? I do support copyright but I don't support it in its entirety. This story is a prime example of why the length of copyright needs to be limited. But this isn't only about copyright. We forget that other US laws in combination with copyright are what cause some of the trouble. Corporations should not be considered people. I think taking a stance that promotes complete abolishment of copyright is like chopping off your head to cure a headache.

The "I Have a Dream" speech should be in the public domain by now, there's no question about it. Copyright has hurt us in this case but while Dr. King was alive it had every opportunity to help us. It could have ensured that his speech wasn't taken advantage of. We seem to forget that copyright helps us promote freedom just as much as it can be used to restrict it. It can help ensure not just freedom as in liberty but freedom as in gratis, for free, free beer, pay zero moneys. We can't stop people from using copyright in ways we don't approve of without abolishing it but abolishing it opens another can of worms. So instead let's focus on trying to make copyright a little more sane, less biased, by scaling it back instead of ripping out our hearts to cure high cholesterol (I didn't want to use the chopping heads to cure headaches metaphor again, hopefully that wasn't too awkward a metaphor).

Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by sehugg on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @02:32PM (#3476138)
I don't think the majority here advocates abolishing copyright (although a poll would clear that up). Many of us make their living due in part to copyright protections, nor do I think a sane person would think it could be abolished unless society changes radically.

I think many of us object to copyright extremism, as you point out. Dr. King certainly would never have guessed that someone could be extradited from another country to face jail time for publishing a link to an unauthorized copy of his speech. Yet here we are.

Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by billpatrianakos on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @03:07PM (#3476268)
I think the majority here does favor copyright abolishment. I would hope I'm wrong but whenever the the subject of copyright comes up the vast majority of the comments talk about how we need to get rid of it, how all works should be free and in the public domain, etc. Especially when you bring money into the discussion I've seen everyone say that copyright is no longer necessary or helpful and we all need to find a way to make a living without it implying that creators should have no right to restrict how their works are used or distributed. I'm so glad this article was posted because it shows us the benefits of copyright.

I'm often downvoted to hell for comments like the one above and I'm really surprised its getting a positive response. Maybe a different subset of HN is discussing it. I don't hold an extreme position on this at all but I'm often a little afraid to speak my mind on this as I usually get a very negative response.

Also, many of us really do make a living thanks in part to copyright protections and to reiterate, I usually see and am responded to with comments saying that we shouldn't use copyright like that and should find another way. But not all works like that lend themselves well to models like paid support for free software or live performances instead of paid recordings.

Anyway, I'm relieved to see that people around here do see the validity of my argument.

Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by Lagged2Death on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @06:04PM (#3476952)
If we make some conservative assumptions based on his actions and what we know of the man then it's safe to say he would allow the speech to become part of PBS documentaries but not used in corporate advertisements.

King's speeches are used in corporate ads. Did you watch the embedded videos?

Likeness rights, not copyrights, are what prevent the images of public figures from being used commercially in ways that imply endorsement. If I take a photo of the President (or any other famous person, in public or in private), I own the copyright for that photo. I can sell copies of it for a profit. But it can't be used in a way that implies endorsement. I need a model release for that.

I'm not a lawyer, but I believe it would be perfectly legally possible for the King estate to release all aspects of the speech into the public domain and still prohibit the use of King's image or voice in advertisements. Or it would have been.

Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by billpatrianakos on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @09:16PM (#3477530)
I did see the videos, I know they are used in ads. I knew without watching any online videos as I've seen them on live TV. What I'm saying is that if he were alive today we could safely assume he wouldn't have allowed such advertisements to be made. Part of what I'm saying requires us to imagine what would have happened had Dr. King not died as it relates to copyright. He could have exercised the powers afforded to him by copyright to combat some of the uses of his speech the author talks about.
Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by serge2k on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @02:27PM (#3476118)
I don't disagree with copyright in general. I do disagree with the idea that it should extend beyond death.

You write something it should be protected for life, but thats it. Anything else is unreasonable.

Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by stan_rogers on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @02:56PM (#3476229)
Believe it or not, publishers (and galleries) used to make extensive use of the simple expedient of waiting for the creator of a work to die (often leaving the family/estate without the means for a burial), which is why the posthumous extension exists at all. Mind you, it has grown from the reasonable protection it once was (something on the order of a dozen or twenty years, depending on the jurisdiction -- enough to inconvenience the vultures or to provide a modest widow's pension) to something utterly ridiculous.
Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by Dylan16807 on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @04:25PM (#3476525)
It's still waiting for someone to die. I think a flat term in all cases is best, still living or not.
Re:Copyright King: Why the "I Have a Dream" Speech Still Isn... by billpatrianakos on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @09:18PM (#3477538)
It might or might not be. My hope is that the conversation turns toward discussing issues like these instead of either trying to expand copyright or completely obliterate it.