I'm often downvoted to hell for comments like the one above and I'm really surprised its getting a positive response. Maybe a different subset of HN is discussing it. I don't hold an extreme position on this at all but I'm often a little afraid to speak my mind on this as I usually get a very negative response.
Also, many of us really do make a living thanks in part to copyright protections and to reiterate, I usually see and am responded to with comments saying that we shouldn't use copyright like that and should find another way. But not all works like that lend themselves well to models like paid support for free software or live performances instead of paid recordings.
Anyway, I'm relieved to see that people around here do see the validity of my argument.
I think many of us object to copyright extremism, as you point out. Dr. King certainly would never have guessed that someone could be extradited from another country to face jail time for publishing a link to an unauthorized copy of his speech. Yet here we are.