How dare I use a self-proclaimed currency as a currency. I lost all interest once I realized very few people actually want it to be a currency and the main excitement stems from the potential to make money, not the tech or a very idealistic view of banking independent from banks.
You ultimately need a financial authority to promote "stable" prices, and even that statement is highly political. You also need some serious gravitas to protect the currency, and this is where the crypto episode is most curious. Governments that for years prohibited "competition" of this nature for years in the most draconian of ways, suddenly have been missing in action. That created an environment where crypto metastisized into something socially corrupt, and also it fosters doubt in the competency and motivation of governments to protect what has forever been their turf.
1 type of person "Bicycle for the mind", another type of person "porn machine". This has no bearing on the value prop of personal computers.
Guess which kind of person is building better and better things?
There is a legitimate argument for creating KYC-light rails for small global transfers. That argument is not advanced by crypto's wanton criminality.
Then let's do it! I keep hearing that we "should" fix regulation or we "should" improve global transfers. Competition spurs innovation. The global financial hegemony can now consider themselves competed against. The proper move is not to ban your competition, the proper move is to build a better product.
If, for every citizen in every country on earth, we fix regulations, build efficient payment infrastructure, solve corruption, and stop money printing and hyperinflation, crypto truly will have no use case and will quickly go to 0. Your move, incumbents.
This isn’t how politics works. Crypto threw a flaming lint ball of fraud at the rich world. Pleading that it’s also helping the disenfranchised doesn’t help advance a KYC-light discussion as much as a regulatory-vacuum one. It’s easy to ban (or heavily tax and erect stricter KYC guardrails at the interfaces between crypto and the fiat and real economies, what I’m concluding is the best middle path) and punt the “what did we learn” bit to a committee with a few years to write a report. Especially when the beneficiaries don’t vote for you.
1 BTC currently is 22,987 USD. "The 2023 Honda Civic has a base MSRP of $24,650" [1]. No sane person, i.e. person not having more money than they can count [2], wanting to buy a car would ever spent the 1 BTC today for a Honda Civic, maybe the 'market' will go up and they will be able to afford a 48K Mustang Mach-E, or maybe it will go really up and be able to afford a 250K Lucid Air Sapphire. Actually spending the crypto 'money' is irrational behaviour, from an economical standpoint: just wait a few months/years, maybe it will go up: crypto forces the users into typical pyramidal thinking, a forever delayed gratification.
In theory, in practice it's a supply / demand game that can be manipulated by news, sentiment, and rich people.
Tesla does not have the underlying asset that made its stock worth as much as it did. It is/was a small player in the car manufacturing world in terms of sales and profits etc, yet its stocks and the company was somehow worth more than all the other car manufacturers combined.
There is no such thing as intrinsic value, value is only ever determined inter-subjectively. Crypto has value as long as people want it, just like every other asset or currency.
One must stop once in a while and ask themselves: what are they are trying to achieve, do they really want to be an effector in maximizing the pain and suffering of the world through vapid technology.
That's exactly what you're doing when you buy something: trading an asset (dollars) that can appreciate in value in a savings account for some good you want or need right now.
I'm also not sure how you delineate between speculation and gambling. Are you for the current system of speculative trading of regular currencies?
Coming to your question, to regulate or not to regulate [3]. I come from the very far left field (pun intended). The most different approach that I've seen recently, one which could maybe move the world in a significant way, is the financo-fiction detailed in Yanis Varoufakis' Another Now [4]. One of the more radical proposals from the book is that the persons starting a company should have only one share each: more of a library card system than a market. In another presentation, Varoufakis says something along the lines: compounding interest becomes a tool of exploitation when the poor are forced to borrow more and more from the rich which only get richer. Therefore, no, I am against the status quo as much as you can get, and although I am not an optimist, I believe it is up to us to decide in what kind of world we want to live and what kind of future we want to nurture.
[1] https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/largest-a...
[2] https://wordhistories.net/2019/08/23/how-many-divisions-pope...
[3] I asked ChatGPT to make a poem starting from Shakespeare's verse:
"To regulate or not to regulate, that is the question asked,
Whether 'tis nobler in the realm of finance to keep markets free,
Or to take action against the sea of risks and save us from a crash.
The pitfalls of speculation oft bring economic pain,
Should we not protect, regulate, and keep it in check to gain?
The choice is ours, the consequences dire,
Let us ponder, deliberate and make a wise decision, not retire."
[4] Varoufakis presentation https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bJKHWrs4h5w, in depth explanation https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sNfvR0lwP4QNothing I do is illegal; I pay my taxes; sometimes I make mistakes. Why would I ever want to use crypto over real money?
But legitimacy and legality diverge.
Not sure if it’s marketing BS or similar, but I’ve read that some people used it to circumvent defunct government or hyper inflation.
If that’s true, then I side with those that want to live a decent life despite corruption and (international) politics exploiting and oppressing them.
Again, I don’t know how reliable that info is, and I doubt that there isn’t a better solution.
Capital controls are a political topic. You can disagree with them, dissent is important, but it’s also important to be honest and say that you’re seeing an advantage through breaking the law, which is like discovering that your business is more profitable if you don’t pay taxes.
Lots of things would be vastly improved if only improbable things would happen (Google fights SEO-spam! Fusion brings unlimited energy too cheap to meter! Humanity unites in peace!), but would you place your bets on them happening instead of assuming the messed up reality we're in an dealing with it?
So you shouldn't use non-crypto convenient near-realtime payments? Stripe seems to have similar events regularly judging by the "Support HN" posts.
It's an issue that seems to arise from misaligned incentives, and regulators are looking the other way, as they do on many things in banking.
It is definitely an area where regulation can help but the point is that you don't need to wait to give your business to someone else.
Sure, that's true, but you don't need the exchange to transfer value if you're using Bitcoin. Granted, you need them to get that value in your local currency and in cash (just like you need another Bank to transfer Paypal into cash).
> No exchange will touch it, and in extreme cases, the blockchain can be forked to undo a transaction.
How often has the fork happened though ... twice? three times? If we're getting into that kind of rareness, we'll lose all relevance. Banks sometimes outright steal from their customers, but it's so rare that I wouldn't put it up as an argument against using a bank.
As for receiving tainted coins: that's a more interesting point. Has anyone ever tried tainting large wallets by transferring known-bad coins to them?
someone not using a product doesn’t mean it’s not useful
I hear this quite a lot. Do we have any figures that say it’s actually happening at any scale?
https://www.freethink.com/hard-tech/crypto-argentina-black-m...
Same as companies using offshore bank accounts for the same purpose, or paying out cash in envelopes.
People getting paid in USDC of course still need to convert a large amount of it into local cash/cash-equivalent because they still have to pay rent, pay for food etc.
So, "people in countries with high inflation"... is immediately reduced to just "freelancers".
I struggle to imagine how freelancers were paid before the advent of crypto.
1 - Banks can make mistakes.
2 - Banks can be slow.
3 - Banks making it really hard to do transfer large sums of money.
I can't solve 1, but I can tell you that crypto definitely doesn't solve it. Because making a mistake with crypto is irreversible. The money is just gone. Mom forgot her password because she's getting old? Well, too bad, now Mom is broke and her money is gone forever.
Two is a solvable problem and it's getting better over time. It used to be even slower.
But 3, I'm in favour of. I want it to be hard for me to transfer away my life savings. I want there to be many steps in which my ID is checked and people look me in the eye and verify that yes, this is the thing I want to do. Because I am an idiot, and if you give me a gun I will shoot myself in the foot. I don't want it to be easy to accidentally go broke.
If I could have paid with, say, a dollar-backed stablecoin from a reputable institution, I could have made the payment digitally and closed the sale/rental without waiting days for a bank to mail me a check. In the apartment rental case, I might not have gotten passed up because someone else arrived check-in-hand ready to close the deal.
Curiously, this also describes the process of mining the next block in a PoW blockchain...
Being able to anonymously transfer value should be a fundamental right, as part of our fundamental right to privacy. In the past, cash could be used for that, but with society going increasingly cashless and some governments trying to make large cash transfers illegal, crypto is now the only way to keep this right.
Crypto is never going to be the option that is best for me. Nor most of 8 billion other people on the planet.
It’s like saying money laundering should be a right or evading taxes should be a right.
Cash transactions and commerce has been regulated for most of human history, whether it’s been for tax collection purposes or to regulate certain types of transactions.
People who work in cash businesses have never had a right to anonymity. They’ve always had to report sales receipts and earnings so they can pay income, sales taxes or value added taxes.
If you want to buy things with cash, you can. If they don’t take paper currency, use a gift card.
Keep in mind, you’re on camera everywhere and your phone is always tracking you. Practically speaking, it’s very unlikely you’ve been anonymous for some time.
Most of human history. People were born with this right.
Even in Hammurabi's code, receipts for agents, witnesses, and contracts, were only used for settling disputes in court where fraud may have been committed. Those instances with conflicting claims were a tiny minority of overall transaction volume, meaning receipts were optional and not required for the vast majority of transactions; especially between trusted parties.
As far as that "state" was concerned, all transactions were anonymous until a dispute was brought to court.
How long do you believe KYC has existed? How long do believe believe banks have existed?
When Mansa Musa decimated the global gold market for atleast a century by distributing large sums of money to millions of people on his Hajj (possibly the single largest event of anonymous value transfer in human history), what regulation or law did he violate?
As far as the vastness of human history is concerned, this was a very recent event.
Why? That doesn't seem like that would produce good outcomes. It's not a 'fundamental right' to transfer unlimited amounts of money with no oversight.
Money is not speech. If you care at all about governments being able to function from taxes, financial regulation, and myriad other things, you don't want people to be able to anonymously transfer as much money as they want.
Even cash has regulations about reporting, especially over certain amounts.
Tomorrow, I might not be able to buy goods from some of their vertical intergrated partners.
Freedom to transact has many forms. Sue you pay youre taxes and do nothing illegal now. But that is only true as far as you follow their laws of what is right and not illegal.
It was useful to me for that use case. How would you have done that?
Payment processors are currently a form of zero representation government that decides what businesses are allowed to exist online, and they frequently abuse this power. They can only by avoided by using crypto. This is the one big use case of crypto i see as important, really...
The big difference is the infrastructure required. If crypto goes out of fashion, your random numbers get riskier to test as virtual silver because transactions will get slower and riskier.
The other big thing is that crypto fills a void between dealing with bank settlement costs and cash. Once the US government or Eurozone come up with a digital currency model, crypto is pretty much dead as a means of transacting.
These risks are what make it so attractive to scammers.
Hawala https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hawala is in practice for long long time, and it is almost exclusively used to avoid tax and for underground operations (ex. illegal betting).
Huge volume is moved, so should it made legal? No.
Is your argument seriously that crypto shouldn't be illegal so it can remain a convenient method of payment for illegal activities?
should it be possible to transfer 100k to a friend without the government knowing?
i support paying taxes btw
i also hope that cash never goes squat but i great it will within 50 years
Yes. It has been this way since Babylon. It is a principle of financial civilization.
> should it be possible to transfer 100k to a friend without the government knowing?
Of course not.
Cryptocurrency is used for illegal activity.
Therefore, cryptocurrency is a moral good.
^ This is a classic logical fallacy called a false syllogism. The archetypal example is "All men are mortal. Socrates is mortal. Therefore, all men are Socrates."
I assure you that all cryptocurrency is neither a moral good, nor is it Socrates.
Therefore, cryptocurrency can sometimes be used for moral good.
For example, anonymously supporting opposition in dictatorship regimes. Can you offer a better alternative than crypto?
People will disagree about which laws are immoral and which regimes are oppressive. It is fundamentally a matter of conscience.
Saying that cryptocurrency should be made illegal is a stupid idea, of course. However, cryptocurrency miners should have to declare their activities and pay much higher electricity prices, so that we could actually use that electricity for more useful things.
EDIT: because the argument of "how is this different than the dollar hurr durr": it's not! The dollar has value because people trust the US government to keep existing, because I can exchange it for actual goods and people want it. The primary goal of the USD isn't to speculate, it's to exchange goods. The same cannot be said about your favorite shitcoin.
Your bitcoin only has value because it can be used to... have more value. It's worthless, and should speculation be gone, you'll go back to it being an unused toy.
No, you speculate that you're going to be able to use it. Like, you know, people did in Venezuela.
Wyoming allows people to pay taxes in Bitcoin...
Yes, there should be something better for these people.
Payments are fast and relatively easy if the recipient wants to be paid in crypto. There are lots of fast and easy payment options if the sender gets to dictate how the value is stored. I can email you an IOU right now. But most people would prefer their local currency, and getting currency A -> crypto -> currency B is neither fast nor easy and almost always involves a KYC process.
As far as I know there is no alternative with the same level of convinience that crypto provide (KYC-less and fast payments to anyone in the world with just one secret). Remember that next time you suggest something among the lines of "crypto should be made illegal".