Re:Voice.ai: GPL Violations with a Side of DRM
by RobotToaster on Monday February 06, 2023 @04:15PM
(#34684444)
Isn't a copyright violation already some sort of grounds for removal? If someone uploaded an app with a bunch of disney copyrighted stuff it would be pulled pretty quickly.
I imagine at the least the original developers could file a DMCA notice.
Re:Voice.ai: GPL Violations with a Side of DRM
by intelVISA on Monday February 06, 2023 @04:35PM
(#34684743)
Seems like it should be, after all if you publish an app that plays copyrighted music it'd be folded by The Powers That Be pretty quickly.
Re:Voice.ai: GPL Violations with a Side of DRM
by JohnFen on Monday February 06, 2023 @07:01PM
(#34686447)
In law, the size of your warchest matters a whole lot more than you think. Disney has an enormous warchest. You probably don't.
Re:Voice.ai: GPL Violations with a Side of DRM
by saurik on Monday February 06, 2023 @05:01PM
(#34685076)
Re:Voice.ai: GPL Violations with a Side of DRM
by cwillu on Monday February 06, 2023 @05:18PM
(#34685291)
I mean, if Voice.ai doesn't have the rights to distribute a piece of software, then google and apple also do not have rights to distribute it. (They may have required that voice.ai (or whoever) indemnify them against legal action resulting from voice.ai's actions)
Perhaps the authors of praat or libgcrypt could issue a DMCA takedown request to apple and google?
In general I abhor the whole concept of the "blessed app" walled garden gatekeeping, but if they're doing it anyway (and they are) they may as well do some good while they're at it.