News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by tomp on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:03PM (#34632983)
> men have a bigger tendency for violent behavior than women

Why is this considered good / normal / expected, but s/men/blacks/g and s/women/whites/g (or asians, or muslims/christians) and it's discriminatory? (Statistically, both statements are justified. Morally, neither is, as we should treat people as individuals, not as members of X group.)

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by debacle on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:10PM (#34633088)
I think it's fair to point out that men commit most violent crimes. That's not good/normal/expected it's just a fact.

AI could be used to better understand these associations (e.g. why is there a correlation between Asians and academic performance) and maybe help social leverage advantages more equitably.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by jfoief on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:21PM (#34633261)
Parent's point was that it wouldn't be acceptable when done regarding some protected group (ex. blacks vs whites), so it shouldn't be acceptable when it comes to men vs women
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by elefanten on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:38PM (#34633494)
Especially when the world never stops turning and social change / idea propagation move orders of magnitude faster than they did for most of human history.

Consider one of the (largely liberal) discourses rising in the past few years that many vital social metrics and trends indicate men/boys are screwed and women/girls are outcompeting them and thriving much better in present era.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by gwright on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:56PM (#34634482)
There is no reason to think that interpretation of metric that compared "men" and "women" must be aligned with that same metric when men/women is substituted with some other populations. When you make the substitution you completly change the nature of the comparison. Whether either comparison is "acceptable" depends on the metric and the populations. There is no ethical rule that says all comparisons for group X must be acceptable or all comparisons for group Y must be unacceptable.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by standardUser on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:15PM (#34634678)
Then that's a lazy point, because it should be immediately obvious that studies for gender can be conducted easily across time and space whereas most demographic splits being discussed in this thread cannot because they are highly dependent on time/space and have therefore have endless variables that cannot be controlled for.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by edgyquant on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:25PM (#34633307)
Again, replace “men” with “African Americans” and you also have a statistically true statement (in America at least) that would be considered taboo.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by jonathanlb on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:34PM (#34633427)
That is a falsehood.

Per the FBI: "White individuals were arrested more often for violent crimes than individuals of any other race and accounted for 59.1 percent of those arrests."

https://ucr.fbi.gov/crime-in-the-u.s/2019/crime-in-the-u.s.-...

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:41PM (#34633548)
Maybe I'm not looking at the right number[0] (there is a 59.3% lower on the page which appears to be a more specific response: "White alone, not Hispanic or Latino") but it looks like 59.1% of arrests are against 75.8% of the population.

[0] https://www.census.gov/quickfacts/fact/table/US/RHI125221

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by antihipocrat on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:43PM (#34633579)
Relative propensity to commit violent crimes is the key metric here, not overall volumes.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by jonathanlb on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:59PM (#34633804)
No it is not.

> I think it's fair to point out that men commit most violent crimes. That's not good/normal/expected it's just a fact.

> Again, replace “men” with “African Americans” and you also have a statistically true statement (in America at least) that would be considered taboo.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:08PM (#34633898)
It makes sense for someone to say "most" in the dichotomy of man / woman more so than it does in the polychotomy of white / black / hispanic or latino / etc. This argument relies on that phrasing to Dwight Schrute them on a technicality rather than arguing related points.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by antihipocrat on Thursday February 02, 2023 @08:50PM (#34636139)
Men and women are split almost 50/50 in the population, using volumes is completely sound in this case.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by axpy906 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:11PM (#34634626)
Comment inspired me to ask it about rape stats in men women. Fist prompt was calling my information incorrect. Second prompt I told it to include prisons, said I was right and then contradicted itself. Go figure.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by yterdy on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:22PM (#34634760)
This is a failure of mathematical (and, frankly, verbal and philosophical) understanding. If you have 10 arrests shared between 7 white men and 3 black, with 1 black man having allegedly offended 5 times and 5 white men having allegedly offended once, where do your resources go? Or the opposite, 1 white guy with 5 arrests, 5 split between 2 black men? Howsabout in a country with presumed innocence? In a country - in individual police jurisdictions - with a history, in living memory, of frivolous arrests made for economic purposes? In a country whose only peers in incarceration are dysfunctional, systemic human rights abusers?
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by antihipocrat on Thursday February 02, 2023 @09:02PM (#34636232)
Yep, the data was counting arrests, not individuals.

You raise some great points, but in the context of the discussion I don't see how any of the comments represent a failure of mathematical, verbal, and philosophical understanding.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by yterdy on Monday February 13, 2023 @11:32AM (#34775721)
You didn't understand the issue and jumped to a conclusion not supported by the numbers. Verbal, philosophical, mathmatical.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by legolas2412 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:46PM (#34633629)
Why would you not normalize by population to quote per Capita numbers?
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by isleyaardvark on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:51PM (#34633695)
Because the original comment said “most” and not “more”.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by honkler on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:23PM (#34634779)
because then it would be apparent that blacks make up 13% of the population, yet commit 56% of violent crimes.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by mshake2 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:47PM (#34633637)
Whites are 60% of the population though, so they're being arrested in proportion with their representation. They also do not separate white-latino and white-non-latino, so the colloquial "white" is being lumped in with another ethnicity. Also, in 2019, blacks were just under 13% of the population, yet they are represented 2x-4x over in virtually ever crime category in that table.

So it is true and you're distorting the table.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by jonathanlb on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:13PM (#34633955)
How am I distorting the table if I reprinted verbatim what the FBI itself reported?

In any case, the picture you're suggesting is itself distorted given that other correlating factors such as social class, are ignored.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by mshake2 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:20PM (#34634043)
You're responsible for the truthfulness of the statements that you make, especially when the data is right there on the page for you to verify for yourself. "Oh I'm just parroting someone else's distortion as fact" is not a defense.

>the picture you're suggesting is itself distorted given that other correlating factors such as social class, are ignored.

The picture I'm suggesting is that which the data shows, and you seem to be making some other leap to say something that I have not said.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by jonathanlb on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:55PM (#34635108)
But I'm repeating what the actual purveyors of the data said about their own data? They analyzed their data and came to the conclusion you seem to have an issue with- that whites account for 59.1% of violent crimes.

In any case, the picture the data suggests is incomplete (because it is missing a crucial data point: social class), therefore the picture you're suggesting is also incomplete.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by mshake2 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @07:15PM (#34635295)
So if 100 people in group A average a total of 10 crimes, and 5 people in group B average a total of 9 crimes, you think you are being intellectually honest when you say "group A commits more crimes" in the context of comparing the crime levels of those two groups?
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by jxramos on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:03PM (#34633840)
the thing that's always confused me is why would this category of white lumping together latino even be a thing in the first place? Just seems like a really harebrained idea. That association always confuses many hispanics I know during each census. Was there a rationale for this lumping? I never understood it, just seemed to beg for fuzzy/blurred/confusing metrics.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by dmix on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:31PM (#34634181)
Maybe it's something that made sense at some point in the past and now it's too difficult to change because it will mess up historical analysis/trends? Not to mention motives will immediately be questioned by anyone who tries to fix it and who really wants to die on that hill in the current political climate?

South Asian vs East asian is another group that often gets lumped together in demographic statistics as 'Asian'. Despite significant differences in geography/race/culture/etc.

Regardless, I'd also be curious to hear the real rational for the Latino one

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by the_af on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:13PM (#34634644)
What does "white" mean? Light skin tone, certain physical features? If so, many Latinos are white and that would explain the grouping.

Or does it only mean anglosaxon heritage? If so, why?

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by jxramos on Thursday February 02, 2023 @07:16PM (#34635303)
yah I'm fuzzy on what white is too precisely. I was going to say caucasian but I don't even know what caucasian means exactly. I guess going by today's landscape I think most people would assume European, but that's a pretty broad swath too with lots of variation in it.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by the_af on Thursday February 02, 2023 @08:26PM (#34635929)
Well, Italians, Spaniards, etc. are European. Latinos have a lot of heritage from those countries.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by jxramos on Friday February 03, 2023 @02:32AM (#34638216)
they certainly do. You know I wonder if the mixing of the category was a reflection of what the majority of latinos presented as in some region in the US at the point in time the category was developed. Most of the latinos in the US dating around the time of the genesis of the white category were European phenotype looking. Who knows.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by yterdy on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:15PM (#34634670)
People of color are also more likely to be arrested without having committed a crime.

Arrest statistics are also self-reported by police, both on an individual officer and department-to-FBI level, with no accountability for the accuracy or completeness thereof that I'm aware of.

Violent crimes also account for only a portion of the economic damage crime-in-general deals to society, if we want to get utilitarian. Wage theft dwarfs all types of robbery and burglary, and that's only one type of white-collar theft (perpetrated, in the US, overwhelmingly by white people).

Thank you for correcting this disinformation. It's something that gets trotted out regularly without acknowledgement of how ridiculously imperfect our law enforcement and justice systems are.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by chitowneats on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:13PM (#34633129)
Is there anything we could point about women? Nothing as terrible as being violent as far as I know, but what about other things? I agree with your premise but I believe it follows we must speak clearly in all cases.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by jfoief on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:31PM (#34633396)
Women are a protected group, so people have biases that prevent them from seeing the reality when it comes to this topic. As evolved beings made to maximize fitness, there were a lot of strategies that worked for women and shaped their psychology that noone dare point out. Also anyone coming too close to the truth will quickly get banned.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by debacle on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:16PM (#34633184)
Women tend to be bad at salary negotiation, and less likely to change jobs. Middle aged women being taken advantage of in the corporate world is tragic.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by chitowneats on Thursday February 02, 2023 @07:26PM (#34635421)
How about behaviors that have detrimental effects to society at large? It seems like many in this thread can't think of any. I certainly can.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by mxkopy on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:17PM (#34633188)
This 'men are violent, therefore women must also be bad in some way' rhetoric makes no sense. There's no purpose for it other than assuaging sore feelings.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by Jensson on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:25PM (#34633320)
Women are bad at higher level math in the same way men are violent. Not all are, but its a trend.

However you aren't allowed to say that for one group, but you are allowed for the other. So this has nothing to do about statistical accuracy, its just political pressure from one side.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by mxkopy on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:11PM (#34633923)
It's nothing to do with political pressure and more to do with ill-formed comparisons.

You can't just substitute in random groups for another. In order to make a statement you need to know what you're talking about. And it seems like the HN crowd that so desperately wants to say blacks are more violent than whites, these people have no clue what they're talking about. If you go and look at history you'll quickly see how that statement is just ill-formed.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by throwaway557211 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:38PM (#34634928)
A woman walking alone at night who encounters a stranger does not care what generative process led to a group disparity, she cares whether she is likely to be in danger. It is politically palatable in polite society for her to be afraid of an unknown man on the basis of his sex. But it is not acceptable for her to even consider that a statistical disparity may exist on the basis of race, or take precautions on that basis, unless it is in the context of condemning society as solely responsible for creating that disparity.

A statement of empirical observation cannot be "ill-formed" unless you have appointed yourself ultimate arbiter over why a person might care.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by chitowneats on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:01PM (#34634535)
I didn't say they must be bad. I asked if we could make any group-based observation at all.

Also, your implied statement of "women, on average, have no traits that are unhelpful to the flourishing of human civilization", strikes me as terribly naive.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by mxkopy on Thursday February 02, 2023 @08:57PM (#34636197)
> Also, your implied statement of "women, on average, have no traits that are unhelpful to the flourishing of human civilization"

Please point to where I said this.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by chitowneats on Thursday February 02, 2023 @09:04PM (#34636247)
You should look up the definition of the word "imply" if you're confused about it. Arguments have implications. Disagree with that rather than lazily claiming I'm misquoting you when I didn't quote you.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by mxkopy on Thursday February 02, 2023 @09:09PM (#34636281)
I'm only confused because I don't think it was ever my intention to say

>"women, on average, have no traits that are unhelpful to the flourishing of human civilization"

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by chitowneats on Thursday February 02, 2023 @09:21PM (#34636366)
Then I would agree with you that women don't have those traits just because men do. But they do have them. We're all human. I wasn't trying to argue the former.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by mxkopy on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:25PM (#34636762)
IDK it just seemed like you were espousing whataboutism. Men are violent, but what about women? in this case.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by chitowneats on Thursday February 02, 2023 @10:40PM (#34636858)
Ah. I see you know all the memes. Good luck.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by lmm on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:55PM (#34634471)
Women who never marry get paid more than men who never marry once you adjust for hours worked.

(Once you adjust for education level this disappears)

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by 735892568 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:14PM (#34633958)
Nothing is just a fact. If it's fair to point out that men are charged/arrested/convicted at a higher rate, it's also fair to point out that black people are charged/arrested/convicted at a higher rate. Neither of those statistics are "just a fact". They are complex phenomena that we don't fully understand the cause of and should avoid drawing unsupported conclusions from.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by camdenlock on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:32PM (#34633399)
A popular belief system insists that people be treated as members of X group before all else, and all such groups must be ranked by their oppressive power.

That ranking is effectively arbitrary, and so the system is used mainly as a bludgeon of mobs who wish to silence and abuse others.

That’s why we’re seeing the kind of warped reasoning you’re alluding to.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by jMyles on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:31PM (#34633377)
> Why is this considered good / normal / expected, but s/men/blacks/g and s/women/whites/g

...because the former holds true across correlations (and is difficult to confound anyway, since the group 'men' and the group 'women' are distributed in like proportion through correlated groups - rich and poor, white and black, around the world, etc), while the latter is very difficult to convincingly show because controlling for economic status alone eliminates more than half of the gap.

Men are genuinely, testably, provably, empirically more violent than women. It's hard to apply any numerate approach to the data which does not support this conclusion. The correlation between melanation and violence is murky and very plausibly non-existent except as artifacts of confounding factors.

Moreover, the definition of "violent behavior" for the purposes of essentially all major research on this topic excludes major wars. If you include projection of military force around the world, it seems likely that the violence perpetrated by white folks is likely to be proportionally greater.

> Morally, neither is, as we should treat people as individuals, not as members of X group.

I broadly agree with this statement, but I think we can still, eg, teach boys not to rape without running afoul of this standard.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by sterlind on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:35PM (#34633439)
It also makes a lot more sense biologically. Testosterone and estrogen have strong mental effects, and alter brain development. The brain is sexually dimorphic in complex ways, borne out by many studies. The brain is not racially dimorphic at all.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by dotancohen on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:22PM (#34634069)

  > The brain is not racially dimorphic at all.
It does not need to be. Culture differences are a reasonable enough explanation.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by erichocean on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:52PM (#34634437)
> The brain is not racially dimorphic at all.

Well, since dimorphic means "occurring in or representing two distinct forms", I think you are likely 100% correct.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by cataphract on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:41PM (#34634295)
Your standard for saying A is more X than B is a bit strange. For me, all it means is roughly that when picking two individuals from A and B the one from A is more likely to have greater X (assuming here the distributions are not weird).

How can you be sure than men are intrinsically more violent than women anyway? Couldn't it just be because of the way men are raised (i.e. the patriarchy)?

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by erichocean on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:51PM (#34634422)
> Men are genuinely, testably, provably, empirically more violent than women.

It's widely known among researchers that women initiate domestic violence more frequently compared to men.

Example (1s on Google): https://aliesq.medium.com/extensive-research-women-initiate-...

I first learned about this from a famous feminist (woman) from the UK.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by oneeyedpigeon on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:44PM (#34633588)
These statistics you're referring to, how comparable are the relative differences? Do they show that men are 4 times more violent than women and black people are 1.1 more violent than white people, for example? What are these figures?
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by gwright on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:41PM (#34634303)
I'm not an expert in this area at all but my understanding is that the differences are not all like 4X more violent but due to the nature of distributions, a small difference in the median of a distribution can lead to an enormous difference in the tails of the distribution.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by michaelt on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:35PM (#34634211)
Presumably prison/jail population statistics - there are certainly more males imprisoned for violent crimes than women, it's like a 10:1 ratio.

Of course, the likes of Brock Turner and Prince Andrew demonstrate that some demographic groups are relatively less punished or relatively more able to avoid punishment, so the prison population surely doesn't directly measure inherent tendencies.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by nhchris on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:53PM (#34634452)
That's a fair question. According to FBI homicide statistics for 2018 [1] and US demographics [2], the Black homicide rate is 7.9 / 100k, while the White+Hispanic rate [3] is 1.2 / 100k. The female (of all races) homicide rate is 0.42 / 100k.

So the Black homicide rate is 6.7x higher than the White+Hispanic rate, while the White+Hispanic homicide rate is 2.8x higher than the female (all races) rate.

Edit: A different source [4] gives different figures, but these are "age adjusted": 20.9 / 100k homicides for non-Hispanic Blacks, and 2.6 for non-Hispanic Whites.

[1] https://ucr.fbi.gov/crime-in-the-u.s/2018/crime-in-the-u.s.-... - and using homicide instead of something as nebulous as "violence" because it is the statistic most difficult to distort, and is immune to over-policing.

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_the_United_Sta...

[3] The FBI counts Hispanics as White, and has a separate 'Ethnicity' category where they mark Hispanic or Latino. Assuming all Hispanics in that table were counted as White yields an even lower White homicide rate.

[4] https://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/volumes/66/wr/mm6631a9.htm

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by mxkopy on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:55PM (#34633744)
Because men are not blacks and women are not whites, I feel like this is basic comprehension

We have different names for different things because they are different. They're not all just "groups of people", you're literally talking about different types. I.e. what generates a man is not what generates a black person

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by slg on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:04PM (#34633848)
>Statistically, both statements are justified.

What can you point to that statistically justifies that "Black people have a bigger tendency for violent behavior than white people"?

Showing crime statistics isn't enough. You need to show that given all the details about a person being the same, a Black person is more likely to act violently than an identical white person. You basically need to correct for all the societal reasons that result in people committing violent crime.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by 735892568 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:08PM (#34633897)
The same thing applies when the statement is applied to men or any of the other demographic groups that it's applied to from time to time.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:15PM (#34633977)
> men have a bigger tendency for violent behavior than women

> black people have a bigger tendency for violent behavior than white people

It seems way easier to justify that first statement. Are there physiological differences between a black man and a white man that are as significant as the differences between testosterone and estrogen?

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by tomp on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:31PM (#34634177)
The causal relationship between testosterone and violence in humans is weak and disputed.

Should be as much of a reason to doubt it and brand such statements as bigotry as “blacks are more violent”, no?

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by slg on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:56PM (#34634473)
That may be true, but we should still avoid false equivalencies. There is scientific evidence for a casual relationship between testosterone and violence. Even if that is debated and there is no full consensus, there is still more evidence for it than there is for the idea that a person's race has a casual relationship on their propensity for violence all else being equal.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by lcnPylGDnU4H9OF on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:29PM (#34634841)
Your second statement doesn’t logically follow the first. It suggests that there is a similar claim of a cause for the statement that black people are more violent which is as strong (however weak and disputed) as the claim of this cause of testosterone.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by mxkopy on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:14PM (#34633960)
What's your justification for "the thing that applies to black people should be equally applicable to men"?
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by 735892568 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:21PM (#34634751)
I'm not sure what you mean. Everything in the comment I responded to apply to the same extent to women/men and white/black. Both the question in the first paragraph and the statement about crime statistics not being enough. It seems to me that the burden of providing a justification is with whoever wants to treat them differently. Why isn't the question just as applicable to gender? Why are crime statistics enough to come to a conclusion about gender but not race?

We know that there is a large sentencing disparity among both women/men and white/black people who are convicted, even when controlling for everything imaginable. We know that there are significant differences in the social and cultural expectations that are usually placed on both women/men and white/black people, and we know that there are on average psychological differences between both women/men and white/black people. The base assumption and the analysis required to come to a conclusion should be the same. The conclusion may or may not be the same.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by mxkopy on Thursday February 02, 2023 @07:34PM (#34635482)
> Why isn't the question just as applicable to gender?

The assumption is that gender and crime aren't related. The burden of proof is on showing that two things are related IMO. Black history and criminalization are related so you need to give context for that relationship.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by 735892568 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @08:11PM (#34635817)
Why would that be the assumption? If Black history is the reason for the disparity between white and black people (in the US, presumably), why can't the history of treating women as delicate quasi-children without agency be the reason for the disparity between women and men? Or perhaps the history of mass sacrificing men as expendable soldiers? Or any other past or present practice that no doubt has an effect on current cultural norms?
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by mxkopy on Thursday February 02, 2023 @09:03PM (#34636242)
Show me how the precession of Mercury affects violent crime rates and I'll bite. Until then, I'd say the assumption is that two arbitrary things aren't related
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by philwelch on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:24PM (#34634097)
> Showing crime statistics isn't enough. You need to show that given all the details about a person being the same, a Black person is more likely to act violently than an identical white person. You basically need to correct for all the societal reasons that result in people committing violent crime.

I think you're conflating the questions of "which demographic group engages in higher rates of violence" and towards the question of "why do different demographic groups engage in different rates of violence".

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by slg on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:56PM (#34634477)
They are the same question when one implies that the membership of the demographic group is the "why".
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by belorn on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:13PM (#34633950)
It is culture. Actually science on violence and aggression tend to show a bit different picture, and also why such statistics is of such a low value. Good research tend to explore the null hypothesis and alternative explanation for statistical results.

A common used data point is that men commit most violent crimes. Using the same data from Sweden one can also say that today Muslim are 20 times more likely per person to commit rape than Christians, and about similar likely per person to commit murder. Same numbers can also be used to replace Muslims and Christians with immigrants and natives, or Arab and Germanics. For social scientists that data wouldn't be hugely interesting, as they would look towards social economic status and war refugee status (i.e. things related to PTSD injuries). The conclusions would more likely be that there are a bigger tendency for anti-social behavior by people with minimal social connections and economical destitute, especially if they experience severe emotional trauma.

One fairly interesting statistics to me is that households with either man-woman, man-man, and woman-woman all have equal rate of violent behavior. Statistically that is to me much more interesting. If men inherently had more violent behavior and women less violent behavior, man-man and woman-woman household should show a difference in violence. It also a rather strange statistical phenomenon that if a bisexual woman go from a heterosexual relation into a homosexual relation, her statistical data for violent behavior increases by 200%. A man who does the same decrease his violent behavior by half. Why would that be if there existed a biological difference in violent behavior?

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by Llamamoe on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:37PM (#34634251)
One claim I've seen is that men commit more violent crime because it's more common for a man to be physically stronger than another person, while the rates of non-physial violence are much closer across gender boundaries.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by xp84 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:44PM (#34634341)
> non-physial violence

Come again? What's non-physical violence? Mental violence? Writing someone a mean letter?

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by icefo on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:05PM (#34634560)
You can inflict extreme pain on someone by just talking without raising a finger nor your voice. Especially if this person cares about you.

It can be voluntary or not but dismissing it like that seems strange to me. It's not because it doesn't leave physical scars that it can't cause trauma.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by honkler on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:19PM (#34634720)
"Stab the body and it heals, but injure the heart and the wound lasts a lifetime."
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by DaveExeter on Thursday February 02, 2023 @06:01PM (#34634542)
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by belorn on Thursday February 02, 2023 @07:19PM (#34635337)
That is one theory I also suspect but I have yet to see a study that look at physically strength during conflicts between people. If it is true then among homosexual relationships the person with less physical strength should be detectable when looking at who is the attacker and who is the victim.

It might also be non-linear. A person who has half the strength of their partner might be significant less likely to be the attacker than if a person has just 10% less physical strength. It would be an interesting read.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by Llamamoe on Friday February 03, 2023 @03:37AM (#34638759)
I think things change a lot when a dynamic is already established, and involves boundaries being pushed and probed, rather than being "crimes of opportunity" so to call them.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by belorn on Saturday February 04, 2023 @04:15AM (#34653022)
Based on the data it seems that the rate of conflict is a human constant. Two women living together will have a lower average absolute strength than two men living together, but from the data the rate of domestic abuse is identical. Similar, the strength difference in a heterosexual relationship is going to be greater than homosexual, and yet again the rate of domestic abuse is again identical to homosexual relationships.

It seems that the only thing that changes with gender is that when there is a conflict and it "eventually" develops into physical attacks, which is a strange concept in itself, the person who will be the attacker (or at least be found guilty in courts) will be significantly more likely to be a man if the relationship is heterosexual.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by barbazoo on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:30PM (#34634168)
> Why is this considered good / normal / expected, but s/men/blacks/g and s/women/whites/g (or asians, or muslims/christians) and it's discriminatory? (Statistically, both statements are justified.

Are BOTH statistically justified in ways that control for other, socioeconomic factors and such?

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by broast on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:43PM (#34634332)
I think it is because one is a historically disadvantaged minority group and the other is not.