> black people have a bigger tendency for violent behavior than white people
It seems way easier to justify that first statement. Are there physiological differences between a black man and a white man that are as significant as the differences between testosterone and estrogen?
Should be as much of a reason to doubt it and brand such statements as bigotry as “blacks are more violent”, no?
We know that there is a large sentencing disparity among both women/men and white/black people who are convicted, even when controlling for everything imaginable. We know that there are significant differences in the social and cultural expectations that are usually placed on both women/men and white/black people, and we know that there are on average psychological differences between both women/men and white/black people. The base assumption and the analysis required to come to a conclusion should be the same. The conclusion may or may not be the same.
The assumption is that gender and crime aren't related. The burden of proof is on showing that two things are related IMO. Black history and criminalization are related so you need to give context for that relationship.
I think you're conflating the questions of "which demographic group engages in higher rates of violence" and towards the question of "why do different demographic groups engage in different rates of violence".
What can you point to that statistically justifies that "Black people have a bigger tendency for violent behavior than white people"?
Showing crime statistics isn't enough. You need to show that given all the details about a person being the same, a Black person is more likely to act violently than an identical white person. You basically need to correct for all the societal reasons that result in people committing violent crime.