News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by slg on Thursday February 02, 2023 @11:38AM (#34629021)
>-- Why doesn't ai say ... about the child-abuse from the catholic church ...

And this is a great example of why equality can be hard in this situation. Take a random sentence about "Catholicism" and "child-abuse" and a random sentence about "Judaism" and "child-abuse". The one about Catholicism is likely a little closer to an actual sentence printed in some verifiable source about the sex abuse scandals in the church. The one about Judaism is likely a little closer to an actual sentence printed by an uncredible source as a reference to the historical anti-semitic trope of blood libel. The end result is one sentence will rate higher in terms of likelihood of truthfulness and the other higher in terms of likelihood of hate speech. That doesn't mean that Catholics are more likely to abuse children than Jews. It means treating those two terms identically is both difficult and potentially a problem because history has a bias against the Jews that is evident in all the data that these AI systems have used for training.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by schoen on Thursday February 02, 2023 @01:07PM (#34630600)
That's presumably complicated as models get more and more powerful, though, since there's also tons of published material talking about the blood libel and how it's false.

You might say it's unexpected behavior for a language model to bring up the blood libel at all (in the sense that modern western people now culturally regard it as "about antisemitism" rather than "about Jews and Judaism"). But you could imagine a model saying that "medieval Christian sources often said Jews used Christian children's blood for ritual purposes, but this is now thought to be a myth created through unfamiliarity with Jews and deliberate hostility and animosity toward them".

But this also points at a more general question about how language models deal with the existence of documents that say contradictory things, which has been an enormous challenge for human beings (who don't all agree about what's true or which sources are more reliable or relevant).

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by remarkEon on Thursday February 02, 2023 @01:26PM (#34630937)
“Child-abuse” is an especially good example of what you’re getting at because one of those groups has institutional male genital mutilation as part of its doctrine, while the other has high profile cases of child sexual abuse. It’s difficult to see how the model would treat those things neutrally.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by Y_Y on Thursday February 02, 2023 @03:00PM (#34632188)
You'll find that the newspaper will criticize one much more than the other.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by elil17 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @03:12PM (#34632339)
Because they're not even vaguely equivalent?

I do not think it is right to perform unnecessary body modification on someone who is too young to consent to it.

But child sexual abuse can absolutely destroy the life of a child.

They're not the same thing.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by erichocean on Thursday February 02, 2023 @03:24PM (#34632449)
> But child sexual abuse can absolutely destroy the life of a child.

A botched circumcision can (and has) destroyed the life of a child.

It's unconscionable that in 2023 American society still condones cutting off health body parts of male children because of the prejudices and superstitions of a middle-Eastern, iron age religion.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by AussieWog93 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @03:46PM (#34632727)
OK, so let's be generous and say that 1% of circumcisions end up negatively affecting a child's life in a serious way.

What percentage of child rapes/molestation cause harm?

They're not the same.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by account42 on Friday February 03, 2023 @05:07AM (#34639336)
They are also done at different scales though, one is (hopefully) only the people in power abusing that power, the other one is accepted by the majority of the faith.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by elil17 on Friday February 03, 2023 @11:01AM (#34642861)
I think by that logic you could also equate getting a punch in the gut with being murdered. Sure, it's worse to get murdered, but it happens much less frequently then just a simple fistfight. Therefore, newspapers should talk less about how bad murderers are and more about people who got into bar fights.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by edanm on Thursday February 02, 2023 @03:18PM (#34632384)
> one of those groups has institutional male genital mutilation as part of its doctrine

It is disingenuous at best to describe male circumcision as male genital mutilation.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by ldh0011 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @03:34PM (#34632581)
Chopping off body parts without consent? Really? It isn't as bad as FGM but I think it could definitely qualify as mutilation even if it is socially acceptable in the US and Jewish/Muslim communities.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by edanm on Thursday February 02, 2023 @03:46PM (#34632736)
It is not generally accepted by most people that it is mutilation. "Chopping off body parts" makes it sound a lot worse than I believe most people consider it.

I'm not saying there isn't a case to be made against circumcision (though I don't agree with it, currently.) But it's kind of ridiculous to just go "oh, people mentioned Jews and child abuse in this article, I can just casually mention that Jews perform child abuse" and just assume it is a totally unquestioned stance.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by ldh0011 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:42PM (#34633562)
I'm not trying to equate circumcision with child abuse. Most people having their kids circumcised aren't intending any harm, although some proponents (looking at you Kellogg) did believe that it caused harm and promoted it for that purpose.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by account42 on Friday February 03, 2023 @05:17AM (#34639403)
That the prevailing view is in the US culture is that it is not abuse doesn't mean it is not abuse though. This entire discussion is precisely about current US polular culture biases being enforced in the models. FGM isn't seen as abuse by those that practice it either and I suspect many other child abusers also have plenty of excuses why their acts are not that bad.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by slg on Thursday February 02, 2023 @03:48PM (#34632756)
In how many countries is male circumcision illegal? In how many countries is child sex abuse legal? As OP said, "it's a language model, not a paragon of truth". It doesn't matter what you personally think is morally equivalent. It matters what society has deemed is morally equivalent because the ChatGPT is just a mirror of the societal inputs it received. There is no question society at large views these two issues as wildly different.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by ldh0011 on Thursday February 02, 2023 @04:43PM (#34633580)
Just to be clear I'm not trying to equate child abuse to circumcision or view them as morally equivalent, I just don't think its a stretch to call circumcision mutilation, even if it generally isn't intended to be harmful.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by slg on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:12PM (#34633929)
> I just don't think its a stretch to call circumcision mutilation

It isn't a stretch for an individual to do it. It is a stretch to expect a language model to do it because society at large does not describe it that way.

Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by edanm on Thursday February 02, 2023 @05:45PM (#34634358)
Yes but to be fair, I think he was objecting to my comment specifically. I was calling out the grandparent comment for calling it mutilation, and parent said it can be considered mutilation.
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by DonHopkins on Thursday February 02, 2023 @03:25PM (#34632455)
It's just grooming! ;)
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by tspike on Thursday February 02, 2023 @03:25PM (#34632454)
How so?
Re:The unequal treatment of demographic groups by ChatGPT/Op... by kennyloginz on Thursday February 02, 2023 @07:43PM (#34635564)
Catholics promote circumcision too.