News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by peterwwillis on Friday January 13, 2012 @04:10PM (#3462424)
A comment on the G+ post from Joshua Mwaniki:

Richard Champling...I couldnt hold back from commenting on your accusations that we may have ochestrated this deliberately. I head the Mocality team in Kenya...and we did not 'Ochestrate' this. Building a directory in Africa isnt as easy as just going around and knocking on doors. Our success was largely based on our ability to build and maintain a large agent network (15,000+ strong). These agents collect information that forms the bulk of our directory. However, for the agents...work isnt as simple as going around and knocking on doors. A lot of the population is still very suspicious about the internet and new technologies. People have fallen prey to scams for merely giving out their cell phone numbers...people are kidnapped etc.

Agents have the task of building trust with business owners in many cases just to extract their correct business details. Convincing them of the 'need' to be online, is not as easy as it seems. To facilitate this, the Mocality team in Kenya spends a lot of time travelling around, holding agent and business seminars and slowly turning our name and mission into something the local business person can trust. Therefore...when google launch a new product like KBO into the market, it is quite clear to us in the country, that they would have similar hurdles to climb when recruiting businesses. These hurdles are in some way a competitive advantage to us, as we've already spent tons of man hours going past them. Google would still need to build the trust...and the business owner would need to be comfortable working with them.

For Mocality, the businesses trust our agents and we use our agents to introduce products to them. Therefore, when google employees/agents call and say that we are working together, they are taking advantage of the relationship of trust we have worked so hard to build...in order to release their product easily into the market. How does this look for us? It's a domino effect... Our agents have no idea about the sites business owners call to ask them about, and their confusion makes the business owners suspicious about working with them further...the agents get upset with us for not informing them of new products or partnerships with google, as they are losing livelihoods...and we are left perplexed that a company of the stature like google is blatantly telling lies. Perhaps worse for us here are the allegations being made that we plan to charge Kshs 20,000 for some services...which is way more than an average business would be willing to spend. So...did we orchestrate this? we clearly did not. And as my CEO Stefan said in his blog...we have always been keen to form viable partnerships within Kenya, and google is a company we have looked at working with. So we dont understand why we werent asked about partnership possibilities if they really wanted to use our information. Really encouraged by the massive support we've seen online from so many people so far though. Very encouraging.

Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by badclient on Friday January 13, 2012 @04:17PM (#3462443)
I am not sure why he even needs two paragraphs before coming to the point: Google was basically phishing by pretending that they were partnered with Mocality.

Isn't that what a phishing scam is? I lie and tell hotmail customers, for example, that I am from hotmail or somehow partnered with hotmail and that I need your password(or credit card). That's almost criminal.

Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by michaelcampbell on Friday January 13, 2012 @04:53PM (#3462557)
> Google was basically phishing by pretending that they were partnered with Mocality.

It's a bit disingenuous to equate some Google employees from doing this with Google as a company doing it. I could be very wrong here (and would be extraordinarily disappointed in the company if so), but I doubt this was a corporate-sanctioned activity.

Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by badclient on Friday January 13, 2012 @05:02PM (#3462591)
When an engineer at google comes up with a great idea during work hours not sanctioned by google, google still owns that idea and its success. Not the individual.

Same should apply when shit goes bad.

Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by idspispopd on Saturday January 14, 2012 @03:15AM (#3463795)
This is an important point. I am reading a lot of defence on here for google and there is little to back it up. This isn't a minor oversight executed by a small team, rather the precise opposite.

I would say Google's reply has been a lie(dare I say "utter bullshit") - an idea like this doesn't accidentally become implemented. It wasn't even implemented in a small way, both being executed from inside google and google finding it worthwhile to pay a separate company to expand the program for them. (A company doing exactly what google has asked of them, to the point of google having to approve the scripts used by callers.)

This is incredibly bad of them, and while "HQ" might not have fully understood the methods being used they wouldn't have not known nothing about it. It's about on par with News Corp executives pretending they didn't know about voicemail-hacking.

Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by michaelcampbell on Friday January 13, 2012 @05:48PM (#3462751)
Taking responsibility for something stupid your employees do, sure. Equating that stupid thing with a sanctioned corporate action is ridiculous.
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by tripzilch on Friday January 13, 2012 @06:24PM (#3462858)
Following the same reasoning we shouldn't laud Google for all the great stuff they did either, like GMail, Search, etc.

Sorry it's one or the other.

I know I like to say, we're IT and if anything goes wrong it's not our fault, but if anything goes extremely well, we'll take the credit--but then I know I'm being facetious :)

Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by derefr on Friday January 13, 2012 @10:14PM (#3463370)
> Following the same reasoning we shouldn't laud Google for all the great stuff they did either, like GMail, Search, etc.

You know, why not think of Google (or Microsoft, or any other Zaibatsu-pretending-to-be-one-brand) as companies resident within a start-up incubator? Treating Google's Adsense team as the same "culture" as Google's Search team makes about as much sense as treating Sony Pictures as being the same company as Sony Computer Entertainment, or Virgin Airlines as being the same company as Virgin Mobile.

So, don't say "Google did this to GMail today" or "Google's search is amazing" or "Google merged their Page Creator into Google Sites"; instead, say "The GMail team launched this today" or "I love the Google Search folks" or "Google Page Creator got bought out by Google Sites."

Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by Klinky on Friday January 13, 2012 @11:13PM (#3463440)
If YCombinator funded/supported say a company that allowed your house to get trashed with no reparations or attempt to make good, then yes I'd hold that against YCombinator. Ultimately Google Inc. is where the money funnels to & is ultimately responsible for it's subcultures.

This idea that Google can't be held responsible for bad employee behavior is borderline religious. Praise Google when it does something good, let Google off the hook when it does something bad.

Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by michaelcampbell on Saturday January 14, 2012 @10:22AM (#3464390)
Google has mentioned a lot of times that various projects started from 20% projects of specific people. The post you're replying to was so ridiculous it wasn't bearing me responding.
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by yock on Friday January 13, 2012 @09:53PM (#3463332)
Nonsense. You can't draw an equals sign between two actions just because they sounds similar. One is a completely legal action by an employee in good standing. The other is a crime. They are not the same thing and should not be treated as such.
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by awakeasleep on Friday January 13, 2012 @10:20PM (#3463379)
Yet they are both done for the profit of the company. What is the difference you see?
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by ori_b on Friday January 13, 2012 @11:02PM (#3463427)
Are you sure? Are you sure that people working at Google didn't just do something for their own profit?
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by TallTalesOrTrue on Saturday January 14, 2012 @04:53AM (#3463920)
The guy talking to businesses wasn't talking on his own behalf. He was representing Google and acting on Google's behalf. It's stupid to suggest that he was doing this for his own profit.
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by ori_b on Tuesday January 17, 2012 @10:02AM (#3475090)
Have you looked at the transcript of his conversation? Would he be using an '@gmail.com' address instead of an '@google.com' address if he was doing it on Google's behalf?
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by yock on Sunday January 15, 2012 @03:05PM (#3468075)
I'm sure his compensation was dependent on his performance.
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by pork on Friday January 13, 2012 @05:02PM (#3462595)
> It's a bit disingenuous to equate some Google employees from doing this with Google as a company doing it.

Um...no, it's not disingenuous at all.

Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by ZeroMinx on Friday January 13, 2012 @05:26PM (#3462666)
Um...yes, it is. Take any 10k+ employee company, can you as a company guarantee that no employer will "do no evil"? That's impossible.

I'm not trying to defend Google here, but just saying that an act made by an employee at a company is equal to a given strategy by the same company is just ludicrous.

Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by y0ghur7_xxx on Friday January 13, 2012 @05:40PM (#3462718)
The scam was going on for months. It's not something that some employee did without telling anyone, hidden away in some office. You can't possibly contact all those businesses during work hours at google without some boss asking you what you are working on and what you are doing. And if that is possible inside google, imho something is very wrong.
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by VMG on Friday January 13, 2012 @06:24PM (#3462856)
I find it very hard to believe that anyone significant knew about this at Google. Do you really think that they are in such dire straits that they have to scam Africans for profit?
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by tripzilch on Friday January 13, 2012 @06:28PM (#3462868)
It went on for months, even if they outsourced a team that just happened to interpret its orders "creatively", having such a scam operate under your watch, while you're paying them, is--to put it mildy--quite the oversight.
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by methodin on Friday January 13, 2012 @07:38PM (#3463078)
You clearly have never worked with an outsourced team. Shit like this can happen with the utmost of ease - unless Google has an internal time constantly involved in the actual area of the outsourced team.
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by mbell on Friday January 13, 2012 @06:57PM (#3462966)
>It went on for months

Months is an incredibly short period of time for a large organization. Especially when considering a small, probably low priority group. A large organization isn't like a startup, for a small low priority group the feedback loop isn't daily, its at best weekly and quite possibly longer even monthly (and gets longer as you go up the corporate ladder). What you may identify about a groups activities in a couple weeks at a small company can easily take months in a large company.

Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by WettowelReactor on Saturday January 14, 2012 @10:10AM (#3464361)
I would be curious what your thoughts are on Murdoch and the News of the World scandal. In that case everyone seems to think that Murdoch new or should have known yet in this case Google execs get a pass?
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by VMG on Saturday January 14, 2012 @02:37PM (#3465059)
Different risk/reward ratios.

I'm much more certain that they aren't stupid than I am certain that they aren't evil.

Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by michaelcampbell on Friday January 13, 2012 @05:51PM (#3462756)
> It's not something that some employee did without telling anyone, hidden away in some office.

Awesome; since you seem to have more facts than anyone else in this emotion-laden thread, please lay them out for us. Perhaps you're right; I simply don't know, but since you seem to have evidence of this, I'm sure Google legal would love to see it.

Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by y0ghur7_xxx on Friday January 13, 2012 @06:03PM (#3462794)
> since you seem to have more facts than anyone

I don't. I just repeated what Nelson Mattos wrote on his blog.

"a team of people working on a Google project improperly used Mocality’s data and misrepresented our relationship with Mocality to encourage customers to create new websites."

Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by DanBC on Saturday January 14, 2012 @06:53AM (#3464066)
There's some slight differences between "Google as a company is responsible for the actions, even the unknown unsanctioned actions, of their employees" and "Google is responsible, and they did it deliberately."

The former is recognised in some laws in some jurisdictions (off the top of my head: In England a company director is responsible for the piracy of their employees during company time, even if the director doesn't know about it and didn't ask for it.)

In my opinion it's fine to say that Google is responsible, even if they didn't know about it. Maybe they need to start improving their governance procedures, especially in cultures where bribery and corruption are rampant. "Don't be evil" should include "don't be evil, even if evil is usual in the region we're working in".

Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by pyre on Friday January 13, 2012 @10:59PM (#3463424)
This idea is the reason that employers want the ability to see all your private details on Facebook when making the hiring decision. Just sayin'.
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by gabaix on Friday January 13, 2012 @08:34PM (#3463196)
Why is this downvoted? His point is valid, even if you disagree with it.
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by maratd on Friday January 13, 2012 @11:50PM (#3463487)
No, it is not a valid point. A company must take responsibility for its employees or contractors. It hired them. It is responsible for them. It must be held accountable for them. Why? Because a company is its employees. And yes, a few rotten apples will spoil the party. You judge a company by its worst employees, not its best. That's the way you judge any group. That's why a group worth admiring has the highest standard for membership and mercilessly purges its ranks of bad apples.
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by myko on Saturday January 14, 2012 @12:21AM (#3463545)
No one is saying Google should not take responsibility - they should, and appear to be. Continue being angry at Google as a whole about this incident if they try to sweep it under the rug and do not get rid of those responsible.
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by tripzilch on Saturday January 14, 2012 @05:31AM (#3463976)
I'll also continue being angry until they come up with a better response than a half-assed paragraph on a social network by some guy that doesn't even bother introducing himself or his function within Google.
Re:Google responds to the Mocality blog post by eternalban on Friday January 13, 2012 @07:58PM (#3463125)
I think Joshua Mwaniki made an error in relegating the transcripts of the phone calls to the "technicalities" section.

If I were him, I would update that post and put the links to the transcripts in the "conclusions" section.