News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by throwanem on Monday January 30, 2023 @09:05PM (#34589949)
Compliance with EAS regulations is a condition of broadcast licensure. This isn't a free speech issue under law; it's a violation of a term in a contract freely entered upon by a broadcast network with the US government, and fines are one of the possible penalties enumerated for such violations.
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by charcircuit on Monday January 30, 2023 @10:29PM (#34590503)
Is there a way to broadcast on the radio or tv without getting into such contract that limits what you can broadcast?

If you can only talk if you are prohibited from saying something don't you see how that violates free speech?

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by brewdad on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:49PM (#34591290)
Pirate radio is a thing but there’s a reason it’s illegal.
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by throwanem on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @04:00AM (#34592909)
You would about as reasonably argue that laws prohibiting espionage violate free speech, because one should be able to say what one likes to an agent of a hostile foreign power with no need to fear any consequence.

This absurdly absolutist conception of free speech bears no resemblance however remote to anything ever actually codified in US law, and I don't see what you mean to achieve by advancing it other than to give the impression of being entirely unserious.

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by charcircuit on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @04:18AM (#34593046)
>You would about as reasonably argue that laws prohibiting espionage violate free speech

Yes.

>This absurdly absolutist conception of free speech bears no resemblance however remote to anything ever actually codified in US law

It's not absurd. It's quite a simple ideal of being able to freely express things. Whatever US law is doesn't change my ideals of existing in a society which is not bound by a govemment on what they can and can not express.

>I don't see what you mean to achieve by advancing it other than to give the impression of being entirely unserious.

This could be said about any compromise of free speech. Many groups desire to take away people freedoms of speech and they start by taking away things people think would be absurd to want to express.

Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by throwanem on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @04:26AM (#34593091)
That's well and good, but arguing with deliberate disregard for the entire history of US jurisprudence dating all the way back to the Federalist produces results not meaningfully different from arguing in complete ignorance of same.
Re:FCC proposes 504k fine for broadcaster's misuse of Emerge... by palmscenter on Tuesday January 31, 2023 @11:25AM (#34597218)
> Is there a way to broadcast on the radio or tv without getting into such contract that limits what you can broadcast?

Not in the US. Even if your station or device does not require an individual license, you are still subject to US law and must comply with FCC rules based on that law (the Communications Act). There is no free speech right to broadcast by radio.