And I can assure you that you weren't directly responding to GP's proposal. If your property tax was 1.5% per month for every month that the unit was unoccupied, you'd find renters ASAP. There's no way you'd leave a $500,000 property unoccupied for a year if it cost you $100,000 in taxes to do so.
Yes, we also need default NIMBY laws to make it easier to add new high-quality units. But in addition, we can immediately free up unutilized units with an empty-unit tax of 1.5% per month.
Separately, the enforcement cost of your idea makes it untenable. The law would have so many loopholes, it would be and stay toothless for decades. Even if we assume for the sake of argument that it actually worked and the rate of empty units went to nearly 0%, it would warp the real estate market so much it would eliminate all benefit: because there would be fewer people looking for apartments (because they are housed in the previous vacant units), fewer new buildings get built. After a decade prices would be back to where they are now except that now it would be more of a headache to find an apartment because the vacancy rate is 0%.
As mentioned, we also need to make it easier to build lots of new high-quality units.
Could be a good idea to use the vacancy tax to build.
But if that's our conversation then everybody needs to be prepared for the possible answer to be that the vacancy tax should be negative.
That would just increase the total financial risk of owning rental properties and you might decide that owning rental properties no longer gives you the best risk adjusted return on your investment capital, and sell. Thus decreasing the total number of rental apartments on the market and making harder to find places to rent (while making it easier for people with capital to buy). The people that are still willing to take this risk would have to raise rents to compensate.
If this is a good or bad outcome is left as an exercise to the reader.
This is hard to steel-man.
In this hypothetical, did you also tear down the apartment before you sold it? The neighborhood I grew up in had 250 homes. When my parents sold the house, the neighborhood didn't suddenly drop down to 249 homes! It didn't even lose net families, the new owners moved right in.
It doesn't matter if its put up for monthly rent or sold to a homeowner. As long as someone lives in it, it helps balance the city's supply-demand curve. If you'd rather sell than put someone in the unit, that would be an intended outcome. The rest of the city doesn't care if you continue owning it or if you're forced the sell it to someone else who feels they are capable of finding an occupant for the unit.
This is where you and I disagree. Renters and buyers make up different demographics. Make renting hard and you get less mobility and/or higher rents. Fewer people will move to a city for short term opportunities and it will be slightly harder to hire people from 'out of town' since they'll either have to buy an apartment on basically day 1 or be forced rent a higher priced, lower quality apartment than what they could get in another city. The people who do move to the city will on average be the sort of people with more capital and who can easier make the necessary down payments. People who have a place will be less likely to move to a place the suits their current life situation better since the overall housing liquidity will decrease, meaning you'll get inefficient allocation of housing resources.
Changing the balance of rental opportunities changes the city. Not necessarily for either the better or the worse, but it is a change.
They both exist in one demographic we all live in - the need to have some sort of shelter to live in. So this is true to some degree, but the biggest monetary difference between $2000/month in rent vs a $2000/month mortgage is that unaffordable-to-most down-payment. And where is the tenant? After renting the same place for 15 years, vs paying a mortgage for 15 years, who's got equity built up and can sell, and who's been paying someone else's mortgage?
> have to buy an apartment on basically day 1
Maybe before AirBNB that gap was wider, but if you need a house somewhere for a week or three, it's a great option. Prior to that, corporations had short-term rentals they placed people in but these days it's easier to use AirBNB for that purpose. And it's accessible to way more people.
My underlying belief is that it's better for people to own things rather than rent. Eg buy a car instead of leasing it, because at the end of the loan period, you now own a thing. It is yours. Not everyone will share this belief, but the idea of PE firms owning the majority of housing, with most people renting shitty apartments, and money further concentrating at the top, is quite scary to me and paints a dystopian picture for the future.
The whole point is to screw you (not you personally, but you as in landlords) into making your property available