News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: What Next After Ubuntu? by asdfkjhasdfhuh on Sunday January 29, 2023 @11:49PM (#34575869)
systemd is "easier" for people used to cisco/microsoft/etc.

The huge list of services with not-for-human names so your job can look complicated and essential.

Re:Ask HN: What Next After Ubuntu? by happymellon on Monday January 30, 2023 @01:23AM (#34576458)
It may be easier for them, but as someone without Cisco experience, systemd was a lot easier for configuring service dependencies once I understood it.

It's been 10 years now? I wouldn't go back, most of the suggested alternatives are so basic that troubleshooting becomes a chore. Almost all the hate is because they don't like Lennart.

We should fork it, get someone else to head that with a different name to get them on board.

Re:Ask HN: What Next After Ubuntu? by asdfkjhasdfhuh on Monday January 30, 2023 @04:53PM (#34586966)
i also accepted it. And made a point to forget the cisco experience.

Yeah, the dependency is a fine feature, but before it was even *easier*... just put a number on the rc.d symlink.

c'mon, if you think that is harder than editing a dozen files, remembering weirdly named camelCase attributes and then pointing to randomly named services, then i don't know what to say. But again, i also accepted it, for better or worse.

Now, i don't care about lennart, but i hated systemd for most of the time because they pushed an incomplete crap over something that was working, just to get contributors. If redhat wanted their cisco/windows services management clone, they could have worked on it. Doing what they did (i call it to pull a gnome) was just shitty behaviour and they should always be remembered for such action.

Re:Ask HN: What Next After Ubuntu? by UK-AL on Monday January 30, 2023 @09:54AM (#34580310)
Eh? systemd unit files are tiny compared to the huge massive scripts that came before it. Often those scripts we're only understood by a few people as well.

I think this why a lot of people really hate systemd. Suddenly a bunch of arcane knowledge used to maintain specific scripts got made redundant.

Re:Ask HN: What Next After Ubuntu? by bayindirh on Monday January 30, 2023 @02:41PM (#34585293)
I have a thousand gripes about systemd, but “it made my knowledge obsolete” doesn’t make that list.

Also, I have only seen two or so massive scripts about services. Most of them were slight variations of a standard boilerplate code.