News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by monero-xmr on Friday January 27, 2023 @10:29PM (#34554841)
Major franchises that have a lot of nerd crossover (marvel, Star Wars, etc.) keep a lot of influencers on the payroll as “advisors” or various types or consultants for events like this. Expect some mea culpas and some Twitter threads from respected people saying, “WotC made a terrible mistake but with the latest changes it’s better now.” Someone at corporate will take a public decapitation as the fall guy with a nice severance package.
Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by beebmam on Friday January 27, 2023 @11:20PM (#34555091)
I have plenty of friends who are emotionally and physically invested in MtG and they certainly want to hate WotC. People love to hate things, especially gaming communities, in my experience. Hating something invigorates a community. Game companies need to make serious plans to not anger their players.
Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by wmanley on Saturday January 28, 2023 @01:13AM (#34555639)
Or make plans to anger them in ways that are useful to the gaming company.

As you say: hating invigorates a community

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by Semaphor on Saturday January 28, 2023 @01:48AM (#34555766)
> People love to hate things, especially gaming communities

Video gaming communities seem to only hate in the lightest sense of the word. I think it was quite a shock for WotCBro to see that TTRPGs players actually put their money where their mouth is, instead of just talking.

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by Ekaros on Saturday January 28, 2023 @08:03AM (#34557243)
I think reality is that bad products can simply just be ignored or not bought.

The insane level of overreach that might destroy all other content, yeah that is something that might really hurt. And fundamentally TTRPG is community of content creation, even if only for private use. Now company like WoTC somehow owning it or taking stupid cut. That really riled up the players.

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by pessimizer on Saturday January 28, 2023 @02:44AM (#34555972)
Somehow, Games Workshop still thrives with a lot longer of a history of fan and customer abuse.
Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by iamacyborg on Saturday January 28, 2023 @06:16AM (#34556737)
They’ve very much turned things around in that respect over the last few years though
Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by shostack on Friday January 27, 2023 @11:27PM (#34555128)
Between this and the recent attempt at looting the D&D community for all it's worth that horribly backfired (https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2023/01/dd-maker-retreats-fro...) what is there not to hate?

As far as I'm concerned I'm done being charitable to them. They've never been fantastic, and Hasbro has clearly been demanding their dues forcing this.

My biggest hope is the Magic community has a great open alternative similar to what the d&d community is likely to do in response to this.

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by EamonnMR on Saturday January 28, 2023 @01:59AM (#34555806)
It's very hard to do an open alternative to MTG. MTG's ecosystem is very closely tied to the economics of the physical cards driving the development and community (ie card shops.) Tools for playing magic without cards of course exist, but the vitality of the community depends on the constant refreshing of the environment tied to carefully balanced development.
Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by riskycodes on Saturday January 28, 2023 @03:02AM (#34556031)
I think this was true in the past, but communities like Premodern, cEDH and, of course, Old School, have managed to sidestep this issue: in the case of Premodern and Old School by sidestepping new releases, and for cEDH by being lenient on proxies. I don't think Magic will ever _die_, but if it did, these communities could well go on for a lifetime longer.
Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by logical_proof on Saturday January 28, 2023 @08:09AM (#34557281)
Let me introduce you to the Star Wars Customizable Card Game by Decipher. It lasted from 1995 until 2001 when Lucasfilm sold toy rights to… Hasbro. Hasbro made a terrible card game to replace it for Episode 2 that has fallen into obscurity. The original game still lives on with a Players Committee and new virtual sets. Compared to Magic the game was a niche of a niche and still exists. If magic ever ‘dies’ I am sure there will be a huge community that steps up to keep it alive.
Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by j_4 on Saturday January 28, 2023 @03:47AM (#34556207)
Of note here is Null Signal Games - https://nullsignal.games/

Android: Netrunner was a great cyberpunk-themed, asymmetrical card game which ran 2012-2018, and ended because of a licensing disagreement between FFG and WotC.

Null Signal Games is a donation and volunteer-driven organization which has been shepherding the game - designing new sets, commissioning artists, providing prize kits, and organizing big events to let the game continue. For the most part, they've been knocking it out of the park. New cards are freely available as print-and-play files. Proxying is allowed and encouraged.

Just to not give a purely rosy picture, I'll note that they foster a very combative social justice element which drove some heavy-handed choices and sour community interactions, but on the whole it's been a laudable effort, and continues to do great work.

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by thaumasiotes on Saturday January 28, 2023 @05:07AM (#34556496)
> Just to not give a purely rosy picture, I'll note that they foster a very combative social justice element which drove some heavy-handed choices

This is also true of WotC.

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by j_4 on Saturday January 28, 2023 @08:55AM (#34557575)
As far as I know, it's a whole different scale of issue. WotC did some fashionable corporate virtue signaling. Some of it sounded reasonable enough to me, some of it was a bit eyerolly but nothing I'm aware of seemed too egregious.

To give one example - Netrunner has (had, I guess) a mechanic called Brain Damage, tied to effects which in lore terms did just that to the runner (hacker) character: heavily damaged by nasty corp tech while jacked into the cyberspace, and having to operate with less capacity/limited resources from that point on. Pretty standard cyberpunk stuff.

Null Signal decided one day that the term is grossly insensitive and now purged from the game, and while they might've told you to print cards containing it up until yesterday, reading it off your cards is now considered literal violence and will get you booted off tournaments. If you're not immediately 100% on board with this decision, you are a morally deficient person and not welcome in the community.

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by angus-prune on Saturday January 28, 2023 @12:15PM (#34559363)
Null Signal's blog post[0] about the topic seems to entirely contradict your narrative about how this change is being approached. Have there been further developments since this was first announced?

"You will not be banned for referring to brain damage. We prefer that you switch to core damage, and will remind you, but it’s not an enumerated infraction.

However, if a fellow player is harmed by any aspect of your behavior (including using the old term instead of the new term) and politely requests that you stop, you are expected to do so. We have always asked players to be polite and make easy accommodations when asked, as is clarified by our Code of Conduct. This is not a change in policy."

[0] https://nullsignal.games/blog/core-damage/

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by j_4 on Saturday January 28, 2023 @01:27PM (#34560082)
You'll notice that was added in an addendum, they must've backtracked. I haven't seen it before. What I saw was the original announcement and the resulting Reddit discussion, in which the article author and several other members of the organization had a very different, self-righteous, and downright combative tone.

That Reddit thread is here. It seems to have been thoroughly cleaned up, but you can still see some slivers. I don't think it's worth wading through it, especially if Null Signal learned to be more diplomatic from it - just wanted to make it clear that I was being truthful, or at least as best as I could. I remember the "violence" and "morally deficient" bits as direct quotes, but my memory might be faulty and hyperbolized.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Netrunner/comments/vvr25h/nisei_an_...

(NISEI is the former name of Null Signal Games, that's also a term they deemed insensitive, and chose to fully rebrand.)

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by ixwt on Saturday January 28, 2023 @08:44AM (#34557510)
I'm quite into this space. I played virtually every LCG that FFG published. I still have all of my original Netrunner LCG cards.

I'm very interested in seeing how Null Signal progresses. The LCG community has always had problems with gaining new members. A new game would launch, tons of people pick up the core sets. The games get into their first few cycles, and then no new people start to join. Then another LCG would come out, and people would go play the new hotness. I don't know if Null Signal is trying to overcome this problem though.

I did find it interesting that WotC has seemingly abandoned their Netrunner trademark [0]. I wonder if that means they Null Signal is effectively in the free in clear. They always seemed to be operating in a bit of a grey area. I don't have a lawyer friend who I've been able to ask.

In this same vein, Pinebox Entertainment [1] has been keeping AEG's Doomtown: Reloaded alive in a similar way. Another fantastic "LCG"* that a big company quit supporting but was picked up a by another small group. Neither of these games have a big following, but I'm interested if either of them will make an economically viable competitive LCG game. As it stands, FFG and AEG have abandoned all of their competitive FFGs. And FFG had several. Only their cooperative LCGs remain.

[0]: https://uspto.report/TM/90791419

[1]: https://pineboxentertainment.com/

* I say "LCG" because that was a trademarked term by FFG. AEG wasn't allowed to call it LCG. I forget what they called it. But it had an identical distribution model.

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by j_4 on Saturday January 28, 2023 @02:38PM (#34560852)
Yeah, LCG seems like such a great and ethical model, but has a proven track record of being hard to keep alive.

I'm currently a very happy player of Flesh and Blood TCG and think it's a fantastic game with great stewardship, but I have very mixed feelings about game economy entirely based on boosters, especially now that I work on games myself.

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by YeGoblynQueenne on Saturday January 28, 2023 @09:29AM (#34557786)
I don't think it's that hard. I gave that a bit of thought when I finished my degree. At the time, I had written an M:tG expert system, for my end-of-year project, that included a rules engine and an ability text parser [1]. The parser was written in Prolog with Definite Clause Grammars so it could generate new ability text as easy as it could recognise it [2].

I realised that all it would take to make a community version of Magic would be to change all the parts of ability text that are IP in my grammar [3]. For example "tapping", "kavu", "merfolk" and "phyrexian mana" would be out. But other than that, about 60% of the game could be basically replicated. That's 60% because it was just a degree project and so incomplete (e.g. Planeswalkers had just come out and they weren't implemented).

Alternatively the entire engine and its language could be re-written from scratch, though that would take a lot more work.

As to having actual cards to play with, I thought it would be a great idea to let the players make their own cards, just like many casual players make their own proxies of published cards. That would add a creative element to the hobby, similar to modelling in Warhammer games, that I thought would make it into something entirely new.

Suffice it to say, after my degree I never had the time to actively pursue this. But I still think it's perfectly possible.

Edit: just to be clear, the reason why it's interesting to have a generator for rules text is that you can generate, and validate, new cards automagickally. Then you can let the players script their own cards and validate them against the parser. So the entire game is completely decentralised with the only authority being the parser (and its maintenance team). Game balance is a problem but that, too, can be dealt with by tweaking the parser so it won't generate or accept imba cards.

_______________

[1] M:tG Arena uses the same idea today, but that was back in 2011. To clarify, the idea is that the ability text on cards is parsed and interpreted just like a scripting language. The interpreter, then, is the rules engine. The alternative is to code each individual card separately, which was done by earlier systems but is complete madness given the thousands of M:tG cards that have to be treated this way.

[2] Prolog programs can be "run backwards" under some conditions, so a parser is also a generator.

[3] Again this was in Prolog so the grammar was the parser. Definite Clause Grammars are syntactic sugar for Prolog so they're executable as any Prolog program. So you write a grammar, you have a parser, and it's also a generator.

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by EamonnMR on Saturday January 28, 2023 @04:35PM (#34562197)
All very cool stuff (awesome to see serious work done in Prolog!) but...

Actually cloning the rules isn't the issue. Convincing the community to use your off-brand version is the issue, and trying to keep the community together in the absence of the trusted central authority of the company producing the game. That can't be easily replicated.

Consider Wargaming: Every tabletop wargamer I know eventually designs their own rule system. Yet none of them can displace Warhammer 40k, despite 40k's rules not even being very good in the first place and GW frequently alienating fans.

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by YeGoblynQueenne on Saturday January 28, 2023 @07:46PM (#34563677)
Yep, that's exactly right. The big problem with a project like that would be to get enough players on board to have an actual community.

But, I know how to write code, not how to make people follow me in my hare-brained schemes :)

>> All very cool stuff (awesome to see serious work done in Prolog!) but...

There's plenty of serious work done in Prolog. My new job is maintaining a 30-year old behemoth of a Prolog project used to manage company car rentals. I'd never heard of it before starting to work with it and I'm betting there's plenty more where it came from.

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by michaelt on Saturday January 28, 2023 @04:47AM (#34556431)
> what is there not to hate?

Presumably what monero-xmr means is: If you're MTG fan, the thing not to hate is MTG, and MTG+WOTC are a package deal.

Much like Star Wars fans have learned to put up with Disney's attempts to wring every last dollar out of the franchise.

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by toast0 on Saturday January 28, 2023 @07:55AM (#34557188)
> Much like Star Wars fans have learned to put up with Disney's attempts to wring every last dollar out of the franchise.

They're just continuing in George Lucas' footsteps. IMHO, either you accept the money grabs, or your acknowledge only the two films, Star Wars and the Empire Strikes Back; even Return was money grubbing.

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by batmanthehorse on Saturday January 28, 2023 @08:41AM (#34557489)
Lucas made 6 Star Wars movies in 30 years. That’s not even close to what Disney is doing.
Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by brookst on Saturday January 28, 2023 @11:11AM (#34558752)
Don’t forget the 39 different DVD releases, each one the most special and unique and definitive must-own version.
Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by rightbyte on Saturday January 28, 2023 @11:45AM (#34559072)
He made 5 right? Not the Empire Strikes Back.
Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by williamcotton on Saturday January 28, 2023 @06:32AM (#34556773)
> Between this and the recent attempt at looting the D&D community for all it's worth that horribly backfired (https://arstechnica.com/gaming/2023/01/dd-maker-retreats-fro...) what is there not to hate?

I’ve been playing Magic since 1994 and I’m still an actively involved player and collector.

I could not give two shits about a marketing piece from a decade ago being removed from a website. Fight that hoarding instinct! You’ll survive without a closet of Duelist magazines from the 90s as well. We’re already hoarding 30 year old cardboard!

If anything I hate how much Magic players are constantly complaining.

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by YeGoblynQueenne on Saturday January 28, 2023 @09:52AM (#34557969)
I don't know, I think maybe there was a lot of the kind of comment that you mean, in what has been deleted, but there was a time that Wizzards' site published high quality articles on strategy and competitive play. I'm thinking of the time when Fires (of Yavimaya) was the deck to beat and Zvi Mowshowitz was one of the contributors, along with other members of ... team fireball, I think it was?

The articles by MaRo weren't that bad either, but I guess those won't be going missing.

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by williamcotton on Saturday January 28, 2023 @09:59AM (#34558020)
From what I can tell they kept the good stuff and deleted the fluff that no one was visiting. Here’s a classic Zvi article:

https://magic.wizards.com/en/news/feature/top-50-artifacts-a...

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by YeGoblynQueenne on Saturday January 28, 2023 @02:07PM (#34560487)
Good stuff! I actually remember reading that one, thanks for sharing.
Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by vlunkr on Saturday January 28, 2023 @12:19AM (#34555391)
Do they really pay influencers? I’m skeptical. There seem to be a limitless supply of megafans who will defend the bad decisions of corporations because they’ve invested their personality in it, not because they’re getting paid.
Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by dmix on Saturday January 28, 2023 @12:24AM (#34555414)
RedLetterMedia's fake "Nerd Crew" podcast [1] satirized the fanboy Youtube/podcast community perfectly.

You don't need to pay influencers heavily. You need to make them feel important. You get mid-tier execs to phone them to give them "inside" information. You give them early access to content so they can have opinions before anyone. You invite them to white-glove events (maybe even fly them there for free) and then have your attractive well-spoken marketing people treat them like royalty.

That goes a long way with megafans and most people who aren't business savvy.

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UCIYCaXNe88&list=PLJ_TJFLc25...

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by vlunkr on Monday January 30, 2023 @11:52AM (#34582521)
Nerd Crew is brilliant.
Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by adql on Saturday January 28, 2023 @04:03AM (#34556261)
Payment doesn't neccesarily need to be money. Send some pack here, give early access to some info there and it's really easy to cajole average youtuber to shill for you just because they want to keep the priviledges of getting the stuff early to review (as that keeps viewers on channel)
Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by Ekaros on Saturday January 28, 2023 @08:06AM (#34557264)
When you think about it, exclusivity of early access to information is essentially free advertising for these companies. Just break up your next product into chunk and distribute it to those eager to do free work and advertisement for you. Just for a chance to get that first chunk of audience.

Actually it is kinda genius. And then on the other side you have those that are potentially manipulating the market for their gains, who don't need that access.

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by rasz on Saturday January 28, 2023 @10:50AM (#34558529)
I think one of the biggest documented cases was Microsoft being caught by FTC(a) for using ad agency thru Machinima to bribe content creators.

https://venturebeat.com/games/ftc-settles-with-machinima-for...

$15-30K payouts per every single video boasting shitty game (Ryse: Son of Rome) and upcoming Xbox One with explicit condition payments are not to be disclosed.

a/ Obviously penalty was saying "sorry we wont do it again" https://www.ftc.gov/news-events/news/press-releases/2015/09/...

Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by charlieyu1 on Saturday January 28, 2023 @12:36AM (#34555478)
I don't think the nerd crowds like influencers. Can't be bothered. Just release better content and less drama.
Re:Magic the Gathering Players Lament the Loss of 30-Year Hi... by asmor on Saturday January 28, 2023 @02:37AM (#34555946)
They certainly tried to do this during the 30A ($1000 for 4 packs of 1993's Beta, not tournament legal) sale, and nobody wanted to be involved. So they went to some people in the Yu-Gi-Oh community who talked up the product for a day until they learned of the collective backlash and pricing for the product and apologized as well.

Overall the community seems to be somewhat forgiving of what Wizards R&D does, but definitely not anything that's a result of Hasbro exercising pressure to milk the franchise, and usually it's quite easy to tell which is which as soon as you hear quiet "sorry I didn't decide this" remarks from R&D people. People don't hate the game or the company as much as the obvious ways to segment the audience and generally increase the price of new cardboard rectangles (as for reprints, they're actually doing those, but investor-collectors aren't so happy).