News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by xoa on Friday January 27, 2023 @10:47AM (#34547324)
I think these discussions can be higher quality if you spend a minute thinking through your hot takes and doing a bit of research. In this case, if a device is given to you, why can't you have the person giving it to you (assuming they're the legitimate owner obviously) remove activation lock if they forgot? Why not check the device quickly at time of transaction? Whether it's a purchase or gift, there is a basic civic responsibility to make sure it's a legitimate transaction. If you're being given it by someone you know well and fully trust, then why is it any issue to have them do the "Erase All Content And Settings" flow?

>but it's a family member who died

OK, Apple has a process for this too using an official death certificate and tying into executor etc. Same if it's a friend not family who died: assuming they willed it to you, there is a legal process. Apple doesn't ignore probate division/court decisions.

I'm sure you can theorycraft some scenarios where somehow everything is impossible, but then those have to be weighed in terms of probability against the significant rates of theft, not just in terms of financial loss but any added risks to our incredibly critical data and the disruption being without something at a bad time could cause. If you can't present an equally good solution to the theft issue, keeping in mind that thieves always have a story. A lot of us have helped moderate forums and seen years and years of "oh yeah I totally forgot this dog ate the password anyone know any hacks to turn off activation lock!?" where upon a bit of digging reveals that these "owners" have curiously zero familiarity with the systems and their stories are full of holes etc. Many more can get the basics straight and look a retail agent in the eye and give a well crafted and convincing lie.

It's not wrong that a lot of us want powerful tools to combat that in turn. And it's not as if it's required either, you can disable Find My specifically without losing access to iCloud services even if you wish. But in order to not just be trivially social engineered around it's necessary there be some effort on the part of owners as well. Same as with encryption, there's no real way around the trust/risk tradeoff. The most secure is if only authorized people have access. But that means if they forget/lose their access, that's that. Adding in more fallbacks adds in some extra ways to get in by definition. Where the balance falls will vary but I think Apple has gotten it right. The burden for legitimate ownership shifts is minimal and flow is straightforward, with significant help available. These are compact very high value items, easy to resell worldwide. "E-waste" shouldn't be a magic term that makes everyone's brains turn off.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by trinsic2 on Friday January 27, 2023 @11:09AM (#34547595)
think these discussions can be higher quality if you spend a minute thinking through your hot takes and doing a bit of research. In this case, > > if a device is given to you, why can't you have the person giving it to you (assuming they're the legitimate owner obviously) remove activation lock if they forgot?

Because it creates too much friction at the point of transfer.

Decryption security should be handled in a way that the decouples user data from the device itself. There will always be theft. The impact that we have on the planet is something we can no longer afford to ignore.

This isn't an issue of turning off our brains. We have two problems we have an issue with theft and how security mechanisms that are tied directly to the device strongly prevents reuse and resale.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by NovemberWhiskey on Friday January 27, 2023 @11:24AM (#34547787)
>Because it creates too much friction at the point of transfer.

The definition of the desired process outcome is "it is demonstrable that the asset was transferred willingly". What is your idea of "less friction at the point of transfer" that achieves that goal? Otherwise, we're back to "this is indistinguishable from theft".

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by widowlark on Friday January 27, 2023 @01:29PM (#34549783)
Who is the authority that determines that "it is demonstrable that the asset was transferred willingly"?
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by fnordpiglet on Friday January 27, 2023 @01:52PM (#34550076)
Receipts from Best Buy
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by trinsic2 on Friday January 27, 2023 @03:59PM (#34551772)
No, its Apple inserting themselves into the process. The same process apple uses to deny independent computer repair centers access to parts. This isn't about preventing theft. Its about apple controlling how hardware is accessed and used and you can see that be how the treat their customers and repair centers.
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by NovemberWhiskey on Friday January 27, 2023 @06:25PM (#34553203)
>No, its Apple inserting themselves into the process.

How exactly do you think this works, without a trusted third party?

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by trinsic2 on Saturday January 28, 2023 @10:13AM (#34558166)
By trusted 3d party do you mean Apple? The same company profiting of off making hardware less accessible, forcing people to by new devices instead of being able to repair there own stuff. You mean that trusted 3d party?
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by foldr on Friday January 27, 2023 @11:14AM (#34547654)
>Because it creates too much friction at the point of transfer.

It takes literally a minute.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by veilrap on Friday January 27, 2023 @12:32PM (#34548966)
There should be a tiny (a couple minutes at most) amount of friction for the transfer of $1000s of dollars worth of property.

Activation lock doesn't prevent resale, it prevents theft.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by trinsic2 on Friday January 27, 2023 @03:56PM (#34551746)
I don't agree. We don't need a company the same company that provides the product tell its users how to protect themselves. Thats up to the people purchasing the product. It creates a conflict of interest and it causes people to loose the freedom on how they wish to protect their devices.

Apples walled garden protects the hackers more than the people that actually use their products: https://www.macworld.com/article/338547/maclope-apple-securi...

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by brookst on Friday January 27, 2023 @01:25PM (#34549721)
“There will always be theft so we shouldn’t try to reduce theft” is pretty circular.
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by trinsic2 on Friday January 27, 2023 @04:02PM (#34551811)
There will always be theft, but only one livable planet. You do the math. The way Apple is implementing this security makes the impact on the planet worse. In the long run, its not worth it, for user control or for the environment.
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by LightHugger on Friday January 27, 2023 @11:24AM (#34547785)
These discussions would be higher quality of blatant apple shills didn't write 4 paragraphs defending an obviously flawed policy that is objectively sending good hardware to the landfill.
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by dang on Saturday January 28, 2023 @09:21AM (#34557733)
You can't post like this to HN, regardless of how wrong other people or you feel they are.

If you'd please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules when posting here, we'd appreciate it. Note this one:

"Please don't post insinuations about astroturfing, shilling, bots, brigading, foreign agents and the like. It degrades discussion and is usually mistaken. If you're worried about abuse, email [email protected] and we'll look at the data."

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by fnordpiglet on Friday January 27, 2023 @12:10PM (#34548565)
I would say not everyone who has the activation lock enabled knows it exists or how to remove it. My parents, for instance. I fully expect one day they’ll take it to goodwill and it’ll be slag.

I’m actually not concerned about this. The security value is higher. I’m just pointing out ownership doesn’t require a receipt.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by jeroenhd on Friday January 27, 2023 @01:01PM (#34549429)
My dad was given an old company laptop a while back. He has since switched jobs. The laptop is locked with an UEFI password but is no longer in anyone's system and I doubt anyone ever stored a real receipt. He has a receipt from the company that gave him the laptop I believe, but the manufacturer won't ever take that as proof of ownership.

> In this case, if a device is given to you, why can't you have the person giving it to you (assuming they're the legitimate owner obviously) remove activation lock if they forgot?

The device was given away after it was written off. The data related to it has been deleted, there is no receipt any more. I don't have the receipt of the laptop I bought seven years ago, why should I?.

> Why not check the device quickly at time of transaction?

They could have, but they forgot. Now they can't.

You can think of processes and procedures all you want but in real life people lose receipts and forget to check some stuff.

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by donmcronald on Friday January 27, 2023 @01:25PM (#34549722)
> In this case, if a device is given to you, why can't you have the person giving it to you (assuming they're the legitimate owner obviously) remove activation lock if they forgot?

What happens if the original owner died?

Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by pulisse on Friday January 27, 2023 @01:45PM (#34549995)
Apple will transfer control to a legal heir.
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by zakki on Friday January 27, 2023 @02:03PM (#34550225)
Does it also need the receipt?
Re:Apple’s Mac security is so good, it’s sending used M1 Mac... by LarryMullins on Friday January 27, 2023 @01:32PM (#34549810)
> I think these discussions can be higher quality if you spend a minute thinking through your hot takes and doing a bit of research. In this case, if a device is given to you, why can't you have the person giving it to you (assuming they're the legitimate owner obviously) remove activation lock if they forgot?

She died you insensitive clod!