“wants it for his investors”
His job is to advocate on behalf of his investors to get the best return he can. For this service he is well paid. We need to stop demonizing people for doing their job, successfully. Just because he is rich doesn’t mean his argument is wrong.
Even when their job is to actively hurt you, your family, and those around you?
What I said was that it hurts you if you get fired and thus it hurts your family. There is a lot of research on the negative effects of layoffs on those who are laid off. Also, not everyone is affected in the same way. For example, a US citizen or someone on a green card will need to find a new job. But someone on an H-1B is legally tied to the company that employs them. They cannot just switch jobs. But if they’re fired, they must uproot their lives, cut social ties, leave the country, and find a new job in a completely different economy.
Sure, an employer has the right to fire its employees. But by firing them, the employer also has a causal effect on their well-being. And the employees are in their right minds to protest that.
W.T.F.
I mean I hate to bring up the analogy, but at the Nuremberg Trials we hung people for 'just doing their job' because just following orders can lead to millions dead and other completely and totally terrible outcomes for humanity.
He doesn't go into any detail outside of "fire people and pay the ones you don't fire less"
He's just a parasite on society who wants to suck more blood.
Surely if it drops back below 92 he'll change his mind ...
Seems reasonable to me. We learned how inefficient conglomerates are back in the 60s/70s.
> I don’t like this guy’s job.
You:
> But it’s his job.
Right, they already said that part. They still don’t like his job.
Other people:
> This guy is wrong because of his job and the fact that he's apparently good enough at it that he's become rich.
Me:
> Neither of these facts has anything to do with his argument. He's neither right nor wrong based on his job or his success at his job.
And frankly, if the son of a mechanic can get to the point of earning $2m/day, that's an indication that he has some amount of clue.
He has a clue how he should be paid more, yes.
Google is worth as much as it is because it can afford the best engineers. If it can't, they'll go elsewhere and it won't be worth that much. Obviously they should all be replaced with offshore contractors.
(If you take the class-war rhetoric seriously, that is. Which I know most of you don't. Not really.)
I think painting this as a "capitalists vs the left" thing is reductive and unhelpful. Personally, speaking as someone who Americans would probably consider extreme-left, I very much agree with your second paragraph, but I don't see this as "capitalism vs the left", I see it as the elite rich abusing their position to the detriment of everyone else. A story as old as time.
No, the goal was to keep it tilted in capital's favor. Which group wields greater decision-making power? Which type of income is more lightly taxed? Capital vehicles (corporations) have almost all of the rights and practically none of the responsibilities - or vulnerabilities such as mortality or geographic limitation - of human laborers. Yes, the playing field needs to be leveled ... the other way.
Title should read: "Upper class hedge fund manager thinks engineers make too much money, wants it for himself".