This only works if you have enough cash on hand to cover the main bill or you're able to be really pushy and get them to run only the main bill on the card.
Again, literally everything about it sucks.
I'm not sure how I would respond to sneaky surcharges since I haven't encountered it. Most likely, I would pay and never go back. If the amount was excessive and I was on my own, I would likely protest it and never go back.
Still only 7.25 but let's be accurate.
In the 90s I delivered pizzas for one of the big companies. I raised that if I didn't make tips the company was supposed to pay me $5.50 instead of the $3.25 that was my wage. The boss said, ok, but if we do that then you have to report your cash tips" - the "agreement" was quite explicit
But it also means that if you snag a $40 dollar tip or something you're basically down to $2 an hour for that day. By comparison some states like California requires minimum wage + tips.
One could also argue that its a means for companies to intentionally under-pay their staff while also re-directing any anger at being exploited from the company to the consumer.
Perfect divide and conquer tactics that has somehow become culturally engrained to the point that if anyone refuses to be part of this macabre tragedy they are framed the villain.
Just tip, so your server can get closer to a living wage for their hard work.
I also try to tip everyone I can when I have the means. Yes, I’d tip janitors, their job sucks, as do most jobs where you have to deal with the general public, and they’re underpaid.
I say tipping is unnecessary because there exist a few states like California who ban the practice of paying a lower "cash wage" and allowing businesses to keep tips for themselves. Anecdotally, I notice that typical restaurant bills in California are not any more expensive than nearby states like Nevada, Colorado, or Arizona.
If its true what others say tips are deducted so their employers pay below minimum wage then why not pay the server outside of the transaction so the employer is forced to do what they should have been doing in the first place?
I am, admittedly, a leftist and incredibly untrusting of anything where workers are not an equal part of the ownership in a business, so I know I jump too conclusion/assumption quicker than I prob should. But, I think there is no doubt that there is a lot of FUD around what would happen if staff were paid a living wage, all meant to distract to keep profit in pockets of the owner.
(Anecdotally, I don’t remember tipping being the norm when I visited Europe. But it was some time ago.)
Australia has some of the highest minimum wages in the world (with its own negative effect on small business owners) and you pay exactly the sum total of what you ordered on the menu as all prices are quoted inclusive of applicable taxes. Tipping is your prerogative if you feel the service was exemplary.
The US needs to get rid of the idea that it is the customer's responsibility to pay servers' wages over and above what they're already paying for the food.
I believe the kind of character(capital owner) utilizing the current system is going to be best tuned to exploit; a process made easiest (in regards to US service industries) by our “tipping culture.”
> And nothing prevents 'workers' from pooling their resources
You are “technically” correct but really so very wrong in practice. That same exploitation driven by capitalism makes it so hard to “pull yourself up by bootstraps” even in a group, if you’re always (by design) one paycheck away from homelessness. (Also a caste kept alive by design.)
> The US needs to get rid of the idea that it is the customer's responsibility to pay servers' wages over and above what they're already paying for the food.
I completely agree!
I am always surprised that a country like France protects its invisible market hand better than the US that is more capitalist minded. Information symmetry is absolutely essential for market actors to behave in their own best interest.
Usually the owners prop one or two of the middle pages of the menu and a page of the seasonal menu in a wall display by the entrance.
The US now serves 'capitalists', which is different than serving the free market or a capitalist economic system.
Of course, nicer restaurants will retain waiters because it is nice to be waited on by another human being, but you need to pay for that experience!
Let's assume you can make the meal yourself at home. You'd pay for the ingredients, but probably ignore all the other costs.
A) labor is the obvious first candidate. Purchaser, chef, server, host, barman, dishwasher, table cleaner- there are lots of people involved. The price of your meal should include labor at fair rates, including benefits etc. (in the US it doesn't hence the need for tipping.)
By contrast your home-cooked meal uses your (free?) time so already has a head start.
B) location. Your living room is free. Your plates are free. Restaurants pay a lot for space (rent etc). They also pay for equipping the space, and for breakages.
C) wastage. When something goes bad in your fridge you throw it out. Restaurants take this straight off yhd bottom line.
I could go on - marketing, regulation, health standards, parking and so on. It all adds up.
Most restaurants fail because margins are tight - and if there isn't sustained volume small things will drive you under fast. And frankly the food offering at most places is inferior to home-made with only the smallest amount of kitchen skills.
So yeah, small establishments with very low overhead (think food trucks) can be both good and good value. But most places either have to skimp on quality (think most fast food) or try and externalise the cost (via tipping etc)
Put another way. Teach your children to cook. It's not hard. And it's a LOT cheaper than eating out.
And yeah, your cheeseburger at $20 is a bargain.
Option C: charge sustainable prices and honestly post them, like nearly every other business. Why is this so hard for restaurants especially?
I've left notes on my bill explaining to "management" why I'm not returning to a particular restaurant. I don't like doing it, but I think someone needs to call them out.
He explained that he made a point to complain, especially at smaller establishments, because he had worked in failing restaurants with delusional management/owners before. 90%+ of people are just going to be quiet if there's something bad about how their food comes out, they just won't come back and then that restaurant will go out of business, because leadership will not understand the scale and/or root cause of the problems.
So keep leaving notes, you are doing the restaurant a favor, especially a smaller place that maybe doesn't have the funds to do a bunch of market research to get honest feedback. If they choose not to act on it, you can move on with your life with a clean conscience that you did what you could to save a small business.
It's likely much more effective explaining in a review why you're not returning.
But I realized that it was not encouraging for management to have complaint emails. And I hardly had a reply back (I assume most businesses just don't care)
Nowadays I'm once again just the silent customer who doesn't come back.
However, I can hapilly reply to polls, reviews, or send thank you emails to businesses that I liked, to encourage them.
I get a lot of _you welcome_ replies. And a small company even indicating that they would include my review in their staff training, to show what points customers liked.
So instead of being negative, I found it was more constructive to have a positive perspective on services that were worth it, to make them more stable.
Now, the last 2 times I've eaten out the automatic tip calculation was done on the post-tax amount. I live in Alameda county where the sales tax is over 10%, so this is a big difference. Not only that, the default tip options were something like 18, 20, and 25%.
The only reason I can see for restaurants to do this is that the minimum wage here is $15/hour, and if tips alone don't make that rate, the restaurant pays out of pocket because it is illegal for them to pay below minimum wage. This seems like yet another example of restaurant owners passing higher labor costs onto customers in a less than ethical way.
Has anyone else noticed a similar practice?
These are also low-margin businesses. A post-tax surcharge keeps your overall bill lower than if they had raised prices, which would also raise the tax amount. The high labor costs are going to be passed on to consumers regardless. The surcharge shorts the government (which most of us are probably fine with).
It's mainly because the sales tax is over 10.25% in our county. If the tax were only 5-6% like in most places in the US, it wouldn't be as big of a deal.
The food prices are also quite a bit higher here than in most places, but that's just due to cost of living. It is not uncommon to spend $200 to feed a party of 4 even without alcohol, so that tip on the extra $20.50 starts to add up.
Say your food is $12, and with delivery + fees it comes to $20.
The first “tip %” screen is based on the $20 figure. So 20% would be $4 extra.
If you decline that, you still have the option to tip before/after your food arrives. However, you’ll notice now the percentages reflect the pre-fees figure. So the 20% tip is now only $2.40.
There is no exception to minimum wage in California for tipped employees, and many cities in Alameda county have a higher minimum wage than the state minimum (Oakland for example, is $15.97/hr this year and Berkeley is $16.99/hr).
Wrong implies that there's a right way to tip and that it isn't just a way for employers to get away with paying employees less.
Sometimes you can just refuse to pay it and they'll back down because they want a repeat customer more. Sometimes they'll insist, but you can still just... not pay it, if you don't plan on going back. It's not like they're going to call the police, and you're paying the main bill.
Unfortunately, it's not infrequent for restaurants to also withhold any unpaid part of the bill from a server's tips. That's usually illegal as well, but most servers would rather keep their job than complain. So you might think you're not paying the restaurant, but then it's the server who suffers.
In other words, literally everything about this sucks.