Re:Apple Unveils MacBook Pro Featuring M2 Pro and M2 Max
by darkteflon on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @01:56PM
(#34416952)
I used FCP on an M1 Air with _8gb_ to edit 4K videos for over a year. Assuming you have enough fast storage (or are happy to use a proxy workflow), it certainly can be done, although everyone’s workflow is different. Assuming no storage speed bottleneck, timeline scrubbing was smooth up to about 2x forward or backward, from memory - after that you hit decoder limits. Proxy workflow gets around that too, though. Render times on even the M1 were a big jump over Intel chips. If Apple has a 2-week return policy where you are, why not give a 16gb M2 Air a try and see if it meets your particular needs?
Re:Apple Unveils MacBook Pro Featuring M2 Pro and M2 Max
by cramjabsyn on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @02:28PM
(#34417398)
What’s a proxy workflow in this context?
Re:Apple Unveils MacBook Pro Featuring M2 Pro and M2 Max
by meheleventyone on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @02:43PM
(#34417651)
Do the editing on proxy clips that have been rendered at a lower quality so the performance cost is significantly reduced.
Re:Apple Unveils MacBook Pro Featuring M2 Pro and M2 Max
by grecy on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @02:31PM
(#34417435)
Thanks, that's great to know. It sounds like it will be a huge step up from my 2014 MBP which grinds to a virtual halt on 4k. For that reason I've limited myself to 1080 for now, but when I upgrade I figure I should step up.
I plan on getting a re-furb, not sure if I can return one of those...
Re:Apple Unveils MacBook Pro Featuring M2 Pro and M2 Max
by thewebcount on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @02:00PM
(#34417032)
You can, but honestly, if you can afford 24GB, go for it. Remember that unlike in the Intel days, the GPU uses main memory for its RAM. (Well, I guess integrated Intel GPUs did some of that, too.) That can be painful when you've got a few clips in the timeline and some plug-in wants to have multiple copies of each frame for doing its processing. (Like it applies a blur, then mixes that with the original, or whatever.) I have a 16GB MacMini I sometimes edit video on, and it works, but there are times when things get choppy/slow. I also have a Studio with 64GB, and it's smooth as butter. (I mean it's possible to load it up so it slows down, but it takes a lot more to do so.)
Re:Apple Unveils MacBook Pro Featuring M2 Pro and M2 Max
by djtriptych on Tuesday January 17, 2023 @03:15PM
(#34418218)
I don't do this specifically, but if you can go without $2k for a few weeks you can take advantage of Apple's permissive return policy and just demo for IIRC 14 days.
I'm looking to upgrade, and I want to go for the lowest config M mac that I can get away with for smooth 4k edits.