Re:The Shit Show
by postmeta on Sunday January 15, 2023 @05:36PM
(#34394375)
I think he reached peak ad hominem:
"a prick"
"Space Karen"
"King Shithead"
"shitty person"
"arrogant bastard"
"billionaire bozo"
"a clown"
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Shit Show
by Ensorceled on Sunday January 15, 2023 @05:49PM
(#34394505)
Insulting people who've done you harm is not an "ad hominem"; he's not debating Musk here.
None of these are ad hominem arguments.
Re:The Shit Show
by pessimizer on Sunday January 15, 2023 @06:03PM
(#34394623)
None of these are arguments.
Yes, one of several reasons they can't be ad hominem arguments.
Re:The Shit Show
by DonHopkins on Sunday January 15, 2023 @05:51PM
(#34394519)
A billionaire attacking somebody else as "Pedo Guy" was peak hominem plus outrageous power imbalance, and the post you're replying to doesn't hold a candle to that. Plus Musk really is "a prick" "Space Karen" "King Shithead" "shitty person" "arrogant bastard" "billionaire bozo" "a clown". Truth is the best defense against libel.
Thing is, that level of invective just makes me think he's got politically motivated brainworms. In terms of performance and features, Twitter is better than it's ever been.
Using "politically motivated brainworms" multiple times in this thread seems like a politically motivated brainworm.
You don't have to be politically motivated to realize Elon is an ass.
Elon just killed a sizeable chunk of their business without a word of explanation, let alone at least heads up. He’s pissed, rightfully so - it’s “livelihood motivated”.
It's admirable elegant variation. [0]
Ah, much thanks for this. The concept has been with me for what seems like forever, but I'd never come across the term.
Re:The Shit Show
by giantrobot on Sunday January 15, 2023 @06:06PM
(#34394654)
It's not an ad hom if he's not claiming Musk is a shitty person therefore he's wrong about X. He's saying Musk is a shitty person and he's wrong. He's just using Musk's chosen pronouns.