Yea he should of phrased the title as a question. As his last paragraph goes:
> I'm hoping someone will read this and tell me what I did wrong.
Spelling nazi hat on
> Yea he should of phrased the title as a question.
... he should have phrased ...
Spelling nazi hat off
That's the grammar Nazi hat.
Pedant hat off.
Re:How I Ruined My SEO
by johnny_reilly on Sunday January 15, 2023 @12:19PM
(#34391042)
Grammar looks fine to me. "Have" is just misspelled :)
And no, Godwin's is about comparing something in the topic to Nazis, not self identifying as a "XXX Nazi".
Re:How I Ruined My SEO
by johnny_reilly on Sunday January 15, 2023 @10:56AM
(#34390294)
Yup - I am not quite sure! But I reckon it's fairly likely that the post contains the "how" of how I ruined my SEO. The hope is that a knowledgeable someone can say what I did wrong.
Re:How I Ruined My SEO
by yellow_lead on Sunday January 15, 2023 @11:12AM
(#34390437)
Title suggestion: "How did I ruin my SEO?"
Usually Hacker News strips out "How" (and "Why") at the start of article titles to prevent this. I'm not sure why there are exceptions sometimes.
Re:How I Ruined My SEO
by johnny_reilly on Sunday January 15, 2023 @12:03PM
(#34390919)
Oh I didn't realise it did that! I assumed I'd copied and pasted incorrectly when I submitted it and added the "How" back after the fact.
You can edit it back in after submission.
Yes, true. I've noticed, though, that more often than not HN's deletion of "How"/"Why" makes the title better when it comes to my submissions. I'd estimate 95% of the time I let the HN-auto-edited version stand.
> How I ruined my SEO
Conclusion:
> I'm not quite sure