News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by pjmlp on Saturday January 14, 2023 @12:35PM (#34382055)
No it wasn't, nor are Apple devices given for free to students.

Anyone that can afford Apple hardware as an high school student surely can afford the dev subscription.

Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by smoldesu on Saturday January 14, 2023 @12:46PM (#34382152)
Anyone that can afford a Lexus can also pay for a heated seat subscription. Does that make it right for them to sell it?
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by pjmlp on Saturday January 14, 2023 @12:58PM (#34382271)
Yes, a company has the right to do whatever they want with their products.

It is up for the customers to validate their business decisions.

Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by smoldesu on Saturday January 14, 2023 @01:06PM (#34382362)
Customers can only validate it if they have a choice. How does an iPhone developer validate or invalidate Apple's behavior? They're basically a hostage on Apple's platform, and the only thing keeping them there is the fact that they get paid. Apple shouldn't have the negotiating power they wield, and regulators are taking action to stop them from abusing it.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by pjmlp on Saturday January 14, 2023 @01:18PM (#34382487)
By becoming a developer of something else.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by grishka on Saturday January 14, 2023 @01:21PM (#34382524)
You don't have that choice if you're building a service that relies on having a mobile app. You are required to have presence on iOS if you want any semblance of success.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by pjmlp on Saturday January 14, 2023 @01:59PM (#34382926)
It might be news for you, many countries in the world have a very superficial presence of iOS devices, and not every company is a multinational.

Second, Web also exists.

Third, this whole thread is about macOS.

Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by saurik on Saturday January 14, 2023 @03:46PM (#34384020)
You are the one who tried to introduce an extremely general argument, which I guess you are no longer interested in defending?

> Yes, a company has the right to do whatever they want with their products. > It is up for the customers to validate their business decisions.

So, to verify: you do agree that your argument at least does not apply to the iPhone?

Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by pjmlp on Saturday January 14, 2023 @07:22PM (#34385486)
I wasn't the one moving the goalpost into iOS app store.

Still the point stands.

Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by smoldesu on Saturday January 14, 2023 @08:10PM (#34385750)
I'm the one who pushed the discussion onto the tangentially-related Apple mobile platform, guilty as charged.

Do you want to defend Apple's absolute control over the iPhone in front of God, Saurik and everyone, or admit that the world's richest company operates out of greed sometimes?

Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by sbuk on Sunday January 15, 2023 @07:07AM (#34388803)
Greed? No. Profit motivated. Of course. They are a business. Businesses generally exist to make a profit. The more profit they make, the stronger and more resilient they become. Apple, having been very close to bankruptcy a couple of times means that they have a strong motivation to make a profit. Nothing is without reason, whether or not you like the reason. I guess corporate greed is a thing, but then so are the very real costs of operating services. Ranting about a business being successful or being the wealthiest just smacks of petty anti-capitalist jealousy. I get it, Apple were supposed to fail and they didn’t.

Are Apple’s fees worth 15%[1] of the vendors revenue? Possibly not, though as a provider, they are entitled to make a profit.

[1] Yes, yes; 30% if the vendor make > $1,000,000. Let get real, the significant majority of the app that you are arguing about are likely to be grossing less than that. And of course 15% of $0 is $0, so the argument is completely moot for freely distributed apps.

Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by smoldesu on Sunday January 15, 2023 @10:47AM (#34390211)
> Possibly not, though as a provider, they are entitled to make a profit.

The big thing people seem to disagree with is Apple forcing themselves to be a provider (and thereby forcing their entitlement to a profit). Apple is certainly entitled to compensation when people use their service, but no computer should force it's services on the user. Regulators seem to really hate that bit, and it will be interesting to see how Apple responds to the Digital Markets act.

Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by smoldesu on Saturday January 14, 2023 @01:28PM (#34382605)
That doesn't make them an iPhone developer anymore, does it?
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by pjmlp on Saturday January 14, 2023 @02:01PM (#34382942)
Which is the whole point of how customers make the difference regarding platform business decisions.

UWP died because the large pool of Windows developers didn't want to buy into it.

Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by smoldesu on Saturday January 14, 2023 @02:02PM (#34382951)
UWP died because there were better ways to make Windows apps.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by pjmlp on Saturday January 14, 2023 @02:50PM (#34383489)
Which Windows developers as Microsoft customers decided to keep using.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by saurik on Saturday January 14, 2023 @03:43PM (#34383996)
App developers are not the "customer" of these curated store platforms any more than cereal manufacturers are the "customer" of a grocery store.

If you try to take your business elsewhere, you have no market, because no one else is able to create a store which targets the same market. This is entirely unlike a grocery store, because if Safeway is unreasonable you can launch an entire store just for your own products and people can shop at both.

However, with these curated store platforms, a user can only use the App Store. They can get a different phone--at ridiculous expense, as there are numerous anticompetitive lock-in mechanisms with respect to licenses that prevent this: I would, for example, lose access to all of the music and books and apps I've ever bought--but then they aren't able to use the App Store anymore.

The problem is that virtually all sane people only carry around a single phone. This is not true of grocery stores or frankly any other form of store unless you map the analogy to geographic regions, where people have to move to a new house in a different community--at great difficulty and expense--to get to another grocery store. Even if you only have a monopoly over one "small" region, that's still a monopoly.

Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by throwaheyy on Saturday January 14, 2023 @07:20PM (#34385467)
This is not really the case for mass market consumer goods (like the cereal example in your post). Safeway and Kroger are a duopoly not far off of Apple’s app store monopoly and if you don’t like their terms, there aren’t exactly alternative viable channels for your cereal.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by smoldesu on Saturday January 14, 2023 @08:06PM (#34385726)
I get what you're saying, but I think the fact that convenience stores are anything but a monopoly just further illustrates how disparate Apple's authority is here. The power Apple wields is like if there was one cereal store, and if you didn't like the selection they had then you "just find another breakfast food". It doesn't, and shouldn't have to be a binary choice.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by grishka on Saturday January 14, 2023 @01:11PM (#34382414)
And the customer has the right to hack their car to activate their already installed heated seats on their own terms because they own the damn thing.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by pjmlp on Saturday January 14, 2023 @01:18PM (#34382483)
Depends on the laws of the country.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by goosedragons on Saturday January 14, 2023 @12:52PM (#34382207)
Who says the HS student is buying the hardware themselves? It could have been a gift, a hand-me-down, a school computer, etc. As a HS student I was poor as shit, no allowance and lived in a rural area where getting a part-time job would require a car and all the expense with that.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by pjmlp on Saturday January 14, 2023 @12:57PM (#34382260)
Yeah and selling apps on Apple hardware will surely be top priority in such cases.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by smoldesu on Saturday January 14, 2023 @01:03PM (#34382328)
They didn't say they wanted to sell the app, just sign and distribute it. Maybe they want to put their FOSS project on the App Store, but can't until they get a "real job" first.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by pjmlp on Saturday January 14, 2023 @01:17PM (#34382477)
No need for the app store for that.

Plus I have known many offshore colleagues from African and Asian countries that managed to be successful in selling software, despite the conditions they were raised in.

So painting the Apple story as gate keeping is playing it short, there are many ways to skin a rabbit.

Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by smoldesu on Saturday January 14, 2023 @01:21PM (#34382530)
You'll need the App Store if you want it on iPhone, which means you need to pay the subscription.

I'm not going to sit around all day and play pity-party with you about impoverished developers. I've known my fair share too, and I might even be one depending on your definition of poor living conditions. The point is simple: Apple stops people from doing arbitrary stuff for no reason. Perhaps you don't care; I'm not arguing that. Maybe it doesn't stop people from getting rich; obviously, money is still made. Regardless, everyone knows their deal stinks like shit - the cat's out of the bag. Apple bought themselves a couple months with the 15% punch-line, but the laughing stops next year.

This isn't controversial or high-concept stuff. You should be able to freely install stuff on your iPhone even if you don't personally intend to. It seems like by-and-large, the democratic world agrees.

Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by pjmlp on Saturday January 14, 2023 @02:51PM (#34383507)
And me thinking this whole thread was about Mac apps for macOS.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by smoldesu on Saturday January 14, 2023 @03:28PM (#34383849)
If only the App Store were that simple.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by pjmlp on Saturday January 14, 2023 @07:24PM (#34385497)
The whole point of the post was exactly not using it, so it doesn't matter how simple or complex it happens to be.
Re:Distributing Mac apps outside the App Store, a quick star... by smoldesu on Saturday January 14, 2023 @08:08PM (#34385736)
Alright.