News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by sokoloff on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @09:34PM (#34348427)
If I brake check someone on the highway, causing an accident, and it’s discovered that that’s what happened, I’d be pretty shocked* if the trailing driver was found responsible.

That video looks like a combined lane change and brake check on the part of the Tesla.

* and disappointed

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by somethoughts on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @09:38PM (#34348458)
If you watch the first video from the Intercept article the Tesla FSD/driver was potentially undertaking an unsafe lane change - i.e. changing to the left lane and braking simultaneously. [1]

The driver will likely need to provide some legal defense against such claims.

[1] https://theintercept.com/2023/01/10/tesla-crash-footage-auto...

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by int_19h on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @10:02PM (#34348619)
Why would you be shocked and disappointed? It is the obligation of the driver trailing you to maintain enough distance to be able to stop safely if the car in front of them has to brake hard for whatever reason. The fact that your hard braking wasn't actually necessary may mean that you're also responsible, but it doesn't absolve the other driver.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by sokoloff on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @10:04PM (#34348642)
As a matter of pragmatism, the person intentionally putting other drivers at unnecessary risk by being an asshole should bear the responsibility for the outcomes of that intentional and unnecessary risk they elected to subject roadway users to.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by int_19h on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @10:35PM (#34348859)
They should, and I said as much.

It does not absolve the other person from responsibility for not following the required safety protocol. The car in front of them might have had to brake for a perfectly legitimate reason.

I mean, suppose that the other driver was driving while drunk. They might have arrived to their destination safely without the asshole in front, but that's not an excuse against a DUI ticket.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by paulryanrogers on Thursday January 12, 2023 @12:01AM (#34349420)
How do you maintain safe distance from those in adjacent lanes? Especially if they may come from behind you, suddenly change lanes in front, then break hard?
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by int_19h on Thursday January 12, 2023 @12:17AM (#34349510)
You do not, but that wasn't the hypothetical posited by OP.

In the actual case with Tesla, the driver of the car that was in front of the pile-up was not at fault IMO. But there were a bunch more cars behind, and at least some of those slammed into each other because they didn't maintain proper distance, according to the police.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by throw827474737 on Thursday January 12, 2023 @02:53AM (#34350464)
Are we looking at the same video? The turn signal is on long before, the lane change of the car starts long before.. you don't see any reaction of the following driver even when the Tesla's tires finally cross the line, which is the latest point where the following driver must adapt apeed and distance, but nothing happens?
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by quacksilver on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:24AM (#34351569)
I am not sure about the US, but in most countries I have driven in, putting a turn signal on is asking for permission to enter another lane, and there is no 'right' to go into the other lane or expect drivers currently there to slow down for you.

If there is an obstruction ahead, the safest scenario is to change to an empty lane ('empty' including safety distance) or brake in your lane to avoid hitting it. If you have some other problem you should probably brake slowly and change lanes to the outer edge of the road whenever there are safe gaps.

I would probably be off the gas or braking based on movement of the car in the other lane as part of driving defensively, though i don't think there is any 'obligation' for me to do so.

The behavior of the Tesla would also strike me as rather odd (assuming a right hand drive country unless there is a off-ramp coming up on the left) as it appears to be pulling over to the wrong side of the road.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by throw827474737 on Thursday January 12, 2023 @02:50AM (#34350435)
You don't, but as soon as you see the car in front of you change the lane (or just indicating via turn signal), you should? And to be honest, this looks more like slowing down and not a hard break, and at least the first following driver slept quite a bit... agreed the stopping had no reason, so (as someone quoted German laws) for that you would be too blame... but for crashing into the car with that video footage, I'm sure the following driver would get at least 80% if not 100% blame.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by smileysteve on Thursday January 12, 2023 @12:46AM (#34349675)
our auto laws are founded from a time when catastrophic failure happened much more often. If a suspension bushing randomly disconnects, or a wheel hub disintegrates, or a differential grenades, who is the asshole? That's right, it's the person following too closely
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by sokoloff on Thursday January 12, 2023 @12:57AM (#34349739)
No blame for the person driving unsafe equipment on a public highway?
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by cookingrobot on Thursday January 12, 2023 @01:49AM (#34350065)
Blame doesn’t have to be zero sum.

This seems to be 100% the fault of Tesla for selling unsafe equipment. Some amount of blame for the Tesla driver. 0% blame for the car that got cut off and hit the Tesla. And 100% blame for every car behind that crashed into the car in front of them.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by sokoloff on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:53AM (#34351768)
Only half of the subsequent impacts in the Tesla video are the fault of the car who hit the car in front of them. I agree with the police conclusion that vehicles 5, 7, and 8 share fault for unsafe following. Vehicles 2, 3, and 6 do not, despite crashing into the car in front of them (subsequent to being hit from behind). Vehicle 4 I couldn’t develop a clear sense of what happened, but it seems was hit only from behind.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by mensetmanusman on Thursday January 12, 2023 @08:46AM (#34353389)
Some failures are sudden and unexpected.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by lynx23 on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:16AM (#34350614)
I agree. But this should also apply to those drivers that experiment with FSD. After all, they were playing with tech on a public road, so deliberately putting others at risk.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by Shorel on Thursday January 12, 2023 @12:00AM (#34349417)
As much as I agree with you, it seems that concepts like 'brake check' and other road rage behaviours make this matter a lot more complicated than common sense dictates.

Simply, drivers don't use their common sense, and just their normal daily driving routine is already endangering to people around.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by int_19h on Thursday January 12, 2023 @02:09AM (#34350197)
It does. And then also actually maintaining a safe distance can be difficult simply because people will immediately merge in there (and then brake in front of you, because of course now they're too close to the other car).

Maintaining a safe configuration of cars on the road is the collective job of everyone who is driving on it; and conversely, it takes just one person to ruin it for everybody who is doing the right thing. So it really needs to be a part of the culture of driving for that to work. And we don't have that in US, unfortunately (though, to be fair, there are far worse places to drive in).

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by scotty79 on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @10:51PM (#34348959)
I think the intention matters. If you did it to spite the guy behind you then you are at fault. If you did it because you thought something might cross the road and just wanted to be safe then it's not your fault even if nothing crossed the road or nothing was really there.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by abduhl on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @11:09PM (#34349077)
Tesla’s FSD/autopilot does not act with intention as we understand it.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by scotty79 on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @11:10PM (#34349085)
No intention, no fault. But definitely unsafe lane change, I think.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by abduhl on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @11:11PM (#34349094)
How convenient for Tesla. I doubt we would think this way if your wheel flew off your civic because of a design flaw in the axle.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by noobermin on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @11:54PM (#34349370)
Why is this being downvoted? Intent isn't everything. While it is important, design flaws are worth getting the book thrown at you over.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by klyrs on Thursday January 12, 2023 @01:09AM (#34349814)
That's because we'd fully expect them to recall the effected models and fix the design flaw. Since Tesla knows about erratic lane-changes and phantom braking, and has for years, why haven't they recalled the vehicles and fixed the design flaw or at least disabled the feature?
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by Faark on Thursday January 12, 2023 @12:38AM (#34349624)
I agree with your original example ("good reason => OK", "bad reason => BAD"). But for the in-between we should default to "not OK" as well, since stopping on a highway is just dangerous.

But damn, I really have little sympathy for all the inattentive drivers not being able to stop in time for the pileup (and hope damages have to be payed accordingly). Maybe, Tesla FSD does not make the streets more dangerous than they already are, after all.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by masklinn on Thursday January 12, 2023 @01:28AM (#34349931)
> No intention, no fault.

Nonsense.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by scotty79 on Thursday January 12, 2023 @08:29AM (#34353174)
Imagine it is a human driver saying that shadows on the road made him believe there was a person there so he slowed down to make sure.

He wouldn't be at fault for slowing down (after checking his eyesight).

Lane change is what makes Tesla at fault here, not unreasonable slowing down.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by smileysteve on Thursday January 12, 2023 @12:43AM (#34349648)
or lack of intention. If an engine throws a rod, if a driveshaft pole vaults, if a wheel falls off, or a suspension component catastrophically fails.

These are all realistic sudden stop issues that our laws mostly accommodate.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by userbinator on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:05AM (#34350545)
No, those are not "sudden stop" situations either.

In fact the worst thing to do is to stop suddenly.

Even if a wheel falls off, you do not slam on the brakes unless you want to lose even more control.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by smileysteve on Thursday January 12, 2023 @09:13AM (#34353743)
If a wheel falls off, the driver doesn't have to apply the brakes... A quarter of the car is digging in and melding itself to the asphalt.

If the differential fails catastrophically, it applies more braking force than the brakes do, so you'll have brief period of being airborne and then at least 1 rear wheel will sheer off (seen it).

If the driveshaft or trailing arms fail the wrong way, they result in a steel shaft digging into the roadway at a downward angle in front of the wheels and the driveshaft will stop the differential as above, until it sheers off.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by jjav on Thursday January 12, 2023 @11:24AM (#34355946)
> If a wheel falls off, the driver doesn't have to apply the brakes... A quarter of the car is digging in and melding itself to the asphalt.

That's not necessarily true. I've been in a car where the rear wheel parted ways with the car and passed us. For a few seconds we wondered where that wheel came from until realizing it was from our car. The car was balanced just fine on three wheels, there was plenty time to lift off the gas and make way to the breakdown lane safely.

Even if it's a more heavily loaded wheel (e.g. front wheel on front engine front wheel drive car), it'll slide on the brake disc or the disk cover (whichever is lower, varies by car). A good amount of sparking but you'll have enough steerage to pull over.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by JKCalhoun on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @11:45PM (#34349330)
Lane change + braking is extremely scary.

I rear-ended a woman who did that to me. When she cut in front of me in my lane there was not nearly enough distance between us for me to fully stop when she then suddenly braked.

I'm not sure what I really was even supposed to even do in a situation like that — I suppose as soon as she cut over I should have just assumed the worst was coming and hit my brakes right away?

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by Jach on Thursday January 12, 2023 @12:08AM (#34349454)
Or at least have the foot off the gas. I try to have or create if I don't distance between myself and aggressive drivers. But even with defensive / paranoid driving sometimes there's just not much you can do, physics is physics.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by hef19898 on Thursday January 12, 2023 @02:01AM (#34350152)
Yeah, in cases like this it is just physics. Propably not much you could have done. She cuy into the space between you and the car in front, the normal reaction is to lift the foot to increase distance again. If the new car hits the brakes, no chance to not rear end it...
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by mhb on Thursday January 12, 2023 @12:22AM (#34349542)
In the video, the Tesla comes to a gradual stop and the car behind it didn't change speed at all. The third car was able to stop without hitting the second car and that was arguably more challenging. Second car wasn't paying attention. Maybe it was using cruise control?
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by tempestn on Thursday January 12, 2023 @01:20AM (#34349890)
Yes. Watching the second video, you can see the second car's brake lights come on quite quickly, given the Tesla's actions were completely strange and unexpected. Less than a second from when the Tesla cuts in front and starts braking to the vehicle behind hitting the brakes. They're definitely not at fault. Some of the cars that piled in behind were a different matter though. Some were able to stop while others didn't. Those ones must have been following too close and/or not paying enough attention.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by mtsr on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:18AM (#34350632)
They didn't actually stop their car, though. And it really looks like they could have, had they braked a little bit harder. But that may be due to the unexpected nature of the Tesla coming to a full stop.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by tempestn on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:42AM (#34350785)
Yeah, it's possible they didn't fully slam on the brakes immediately. But you don't expect the car in front of you to do so for no reason either, so I still wouldn't consider the second car at fault.
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by Loic on Thursday January 12, 2023 @01:49AM (#34350063)
In Germany you would be covered because line change and break, without a reason, is a deliberate dangerous action. This means that the one doing it is responsible of the following crash.

For the multiple cars crash, if not clear cut, without video recording, all the insurances pool themselves together and consider the drivers as not responsible. Nobody cannot tell if you stopped, got hit in the back and then the front or the opposite.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by raphman on Thursday January 12, 2023 @05:23AM (#34351566)
Huh? In my (German) experience, responsibility for the crash (and thus for the sentence/fine/payout to each driver) is rarely assigned to a single driver in such a case. Instead, it is distributed among participants with e.g. the Tesla driver being 80% at fault for the second driver's damages and the others ramming the second car for 20% (or something like this).

I admittedly find it a little bit confusing how many people here assign complete blame to exactly one participant.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by Loic on Thursday January 12, 2023 @07:11AM (#34352355)
I asked my lawyer, the fine element is the deliberate and dangerous part of the action without reason. Normally you effectively have shared fault.

The question is if in this case the action can be considered as deliberate. The "software" did it, is it deliberate? Is it considered as a failure of the car like the breaking of mechanical part?

This is new and the justice will have to figure it out and I am very happy not to have to figure it out.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by jjav on Thursday January 12, 2023 @11:17AM (#34355815)
> I admittedly find it a little bit confusing how many people here assign complete blame to exactly one participant.

I'd say there is only one car which did a clearly illegal action (sudden lane change followed by brake checking), so the guilt is 100% on them.

It's also true that the car behind probably could've been more assertive in braking harder to avoid reaching the Tesla (I wish there was a dashcam to see it from a better angle). But they didn't do anything illegal per se.

Also, that second car driver might've been worried of braking too hard to avoid getting themselves rear ended, which is a legitimate concern when having to break hard in traffic. Of course in the end they got rear ended anyway, but couldn't have known that prior to it happening.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by piceas on Thursday January 12, 2023 @07:34AM (#34352569)
My id4's gps went haywire and the limiter caused the car to break unexpectedly as it suddenly reported that it was in a village somewhere a few kilometers away. If that had lead to a crash, how do I show that VW was at fault?
Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by Gordonjcp on Thursday January 12, 2023 @03:28AM (#34350702)
Not a brake check, that kind of implies cutting in and then a hard enough dab on the brake to freak out the guy behind and force them to brake sharply but not enough to stop.

This was the Tesla braking as hard as possible to a complete stop. The following driver reacted quickly and had they not been paying attention the accident would have been much much worse.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by jejeyyy77 on Thursday January 12, 2023 @08:44AM (#34353363)
That would still be your fault for following too closely.

Basically if you hit a car from behind, it’s your fault, every time.

Re:New Video of Tesla Crash Demonstrates the Problem of Semi... by jjav on Thursday January 12, 2023 @11:26AM (#34355986)
> Basically if you hit a car from behind, it’s your fault, every time.

Incorrect. If you brake check someone (what the Tesla did), the front car is at fault.