News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by ttul on Monday January 09, 2023 @06:46PM (#34318204)
My son and his friends are already doing their homework using ChatGPT. Teachers will have to get used to this and hopefully embrace it.
Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by sunflowerfly on Monday January 09, 2023 @06:59PM (#34318337)
Teachers will adapt. Some are already giving students a question, allowing the students ample time to research, then writing papers with a pencil in class.
Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by krisoft on Monday January 09, 2023 @07:18PM (#34318498)
ChatGPT is still supremely usefull there. I can borrow whole phrases and structure from it if I want to.

I get my question, research it, provide chatgpt with an outline and ask it to fluf it out in a nice style and maybe copy it down once. Even if I only remember 80% of what I wrote then that is still a win.

Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by TSiege on Monday January 09, 2023 @06:50PM (#34318243)
No judgement here, but I'm curious how they're using it and what your feelings are. It seems like you've embraced it
Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by ttul on Tuesday January 10, 2023 @01:47AM (#34321363)
Literally everything. They’re using it to help with math homework. Putting together copy for a slide presentation about the history of Pepsico (why? I have no idea). Writing a silly story about an ape man who dominates the world through vicious conquests. “Now write a sequel” apparently works really well.
Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by jolmg on Monday January 09, 2023 @06:52PM (#34318258)
In the end, (ideally) it's the students that are losing out on education, though. That's unless there's a competition dynamic among students. Maybe embracing it is removing competition among students.

EDIT: On second thought, one can just put more emphasis on exams taken in-premises with supervision.

Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by Der_Einzige on Monday January 09, 2023 @06:54PM (#34318290)
School is not about getting an "education", this is pedegological propaganda.

It's about maximizing your college admissions chances, which then leads to better jobs.

Id rather be stupid and rich than "educated" and poor.

Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by epolanski on Monday January 09, 2023 @07:18PM (#34318505)
You have few really distorted, cynical perceptions and biased ideas about school.

First you're projecting your personal experience in your (I guess crap) school in a crap educational system to the norm. It's not.

Second, jobs having higher educational standards is a reflection of the booming of educated youngs, not the other way around.

Third, skilled uneducated professionals (e.g. plumbers, cooks, electricians, mechanics) make much more than graduates on average, it's a night and day difference, comes also debt free and you can start compounding much earlier. If money is your goal an education is actually not necessarily needed if not dangerous.

Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by Der_Einzige on Monday January 09, 2023 @07:29PM (#34318594)
No, I am not projecting. I went to good schools and had positive experiences in school. It's still an arbiter of competence. Its still failed to hold up even a vestigial "ideal".

And no, the stats say that tradespeople are massively underpaid on avg compared to BS holders. Ofc, no one believes this here since HNs demographics are highly clustered in the bay area where trades people basically just tell you how hard you're going to bend over for them...

Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by epolanski on Monday January 09, 2023 @08:02PM (#34318882)
The US does not have a good education system and you're projecting US system to the norm.

I'm European, know our school systems in various countries and it has no resemblance to the ideas you have about education and we don't really have such gatekeeping at college at all.

Third, about trades, I've never lived in SF, but I lived in italy/poland/switzerland and even 6 months at OSU in columbus and I've seen that all the time: skilled tradesmen in all these places make MUCH more than average graduate. There's no comparison. I'm 100% sure the average decent carpenter or electrician makes more than a stem graduate in Italy or Switzerland.

Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by skor on Monday January 09, 2023 @06:59PM (#34318328)
would you rather be stupid? think of all the things you would have wished to know before you die.

seems like a pipe dream to me.

Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by drbeast on Monday January 09, 2023 @07:09PM (#34318420)
Look at Paris Hilton. Do you think she cares about subjects she doesn't know whilenshe gets chauffered around on her rolls Royce, eating meals made by a personal chef, in her Beverly hills home?

The answer is no. A life of material richness vs being poor and highly educated. Ask a postdoc this question and I bet the majority would take lifetime wealth to having to slave away in a lab.

Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by dvngnt_ on Monday January 09, 2023 @10:05PM (#34320002)
I dunno she's been in crypto since 2016. she's probably smarter than what you're giving her credit for
Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by logicchains on Tuesday January 10, 2023 @02:38AM (#34321683)
> would you rather be stupid? think of all the things you would have wished to know before you die.

If someone takes the approach that school is required for learning, then they'll stop learning after finishing university (as most people do) and within a decade they'll be stupid compared to someone who believed learning is a personal thing and kept learning after their formal schooling had ended.

Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by jolmg on Monday January 09, 2023 @06:55PM (#34318295)
> (ideally)
Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by Der_Einzige on Monday January 09, 2023 @06:58PM (#34318319)
No, even ideally it's still wrong. Educators are the arbiters of competence. It's their subjective opinions of you (marked with grades) that literally decide if you eat lobster thermidor or if you eat raman through your life.

The greeks had an ideal. It's been so corrupted by the modern system that even the ideal is dead.

Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by krisoft on Monday January 09, 2023 @07:29PM (#34318602)
> It's their subjective opinions of you (marked with grades) that literally decide if you eat lobster thermidor or if you eat raman through your life.

I don’t think so? Maybe in some rare edge cases. If you were born to a rich family even with midling grades you will remain rich. If you were born to a poor family even with excelent grades you likely won’t raise above middle class, and that if you are lucky. If you were born into a middle class family and you are lucky enough to avoid catastrophies you will likely stay okay, but not lobster termidor every day rich.

Honestly it is much more likely that if they give you great grades and put the idea into your head that you should be a poet or a philosopher or similar that they send you down the ramen path.

I don’t know where you got this notion.

Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by pnf on Monday January 09, 2023 @08:31PM (#34319132)
This is just cynical and wrong. School is about ideological indoctrination and conditioning the political subject via propaganda during childhood development away from the prying eyes of disobedient parents. Read your Plato and Dewey.
Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by teeray on Monday January 09, 2023 @07:07PM (#34318411)
Good. Homework robs children of their childhood. If ChatGPT forces more school to happen in school, that may be its greatest contribution.
Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by optymizer on Monday January 09, 2023 @10:15PM (#34320060)
"Homework robs children of their childhood". Hell yeah!

I too think that's exactly what's wrong with the education system nowadays - too much homework and not enough time for drugs, Call of Duty, $120 apparel from LuluLemon, browsing TikTok all day in bed, and sending nudes over SnapChat.

Childhood. Solved.

Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by logicchains on Tuesday January 10, 2023 @02:32AM (#34321652)
If "wasting kids' time so they can't do worse things" is meant to be the point of the education system, it's a stupid idea, as it just means when they're adults with more free time they'll catch up on what they missed, and as a bonus they'll carry a lifelong hatred of learning from being trained to associate it with mind-numbing, pointless busywork at school.
Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by optymizer on Tuesday January 10, 2023 @10:02AM (#34325853)
If homework is "wasting kids time" and "busywork", you and I have very different definitions of homework.
Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by teeray on Tuesday January 10, 2023 @11:23AM (#34327229)
I took Spanish for 7 years and passed all the classes. Countless hours of homework involved every week.

As of my 30s, I can now mostly read warning labels and some of the Spanish manual if I happen to grab the wrong one out of the box. Conversations with a native speaker? No way.

If that wasn’t a complete waste of my time, I don’t know what is.

Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by optymizer on Tuesday January 10, 2023 @05:10PM (#34332270)
It seems like you wrote this in support of the argument that homework is a waste of time, but it doesn't seem like you're describing a problem with the concept of homework or how it applies to learning a subject. You're describing a situation when the subject itself was not useful to you in retrospect.

Presumably, from your point of view, all of the time invested into it was a waste of time, not just the homework part. That said, it doesn't follow from this that any homework is a waste of time. It doesn't even follow that Spanish homework is generally a waste of time.

One cannot generalize from your example at all because you might be an outlier. You'd have to show that learning Spanish provided no value to the majority of kids who studied it, or that class time is sufficient to learn Spanish so homework isn't really needed, which would be a very hard thing to argue for a human language.

For what it's worth, I took Bulgarian folk music - I'm not Bulgarian, nor do I live in Bulgaria, nor can I play any musical instruments. Was it a waste of time? Acquiring knowledge is never a waste of time for me. Typing comments on HN might be though.

Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by Pigalowda on Monday January 09, 2023 @06:53PM (#34318263)
Why should it be embraced? It can be avoided I suppose by using in class blue book written essays. I’m guessing universities are still doing that?
Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by skor on Monday January 09, 2023 @06:54PM (#34318286)
my partner (a professor in a European university) and I had a chat with gpt3 for 5 minutes tops, even though we were having some beers while we were doing that, we noticed instantly the “rhythm” of the output.

Don’t pretend, we will see you ;)

exams will show what you’re really capable of.

lol

Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by drbeast on Monday January 09, 2023 @07:14PM (#34318461)
Ok, so I'll have chatgpt write my 15 page research paper with citations. I'll then spend 1.5 hours rewriting and proofing it as opposed to the multiday researching, outlining, and writing I used to have to do.

And with all of that extra time, I'll study for your "exams".

Just replace chatgpt with Wikipedia, did this for 4 years of uni and another 2 at an ivy n school. No one was the wiser and now I have a cushy MBB job to show for it.

Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by krisoft on Monday January 09, 2023 @07:09PM (#34318427)
Oh that is just great. We will have all kind of teachers and professors running around with half baked ideas of what ChatGPT does or does not sound like, deducting points and being hardass based on a hunch. What do you think your false positive rate is? How did you quantified that based on a five minute interaction (which only contained true positive samples, and only in response to your prompting)
Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by asdff on Tuesday January 10, 2023 @12:17AM (#34320823)
I wonder if you can just ask chatgpt if it wrote the essay?
Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by greenie_beans on Monday January 09, 2023 @08:07PM (#34318920)
i would've been that student, and now i teach creative writing to kids in my free time. we use pen and paper to write poems.

but if i were an english teacher assigning research-like papers, i'd definitely incorporate chatgpt responses into my assignments. make them write a draft with chatgpt3 then revise it themselves in class with pen and paper. then write a version in their own words without plagiarizing the chatgpt version, but they can only use google docs or some format that can track changes, so the teacher can see the process. or something like that — it would need some iterating and real-world feedback.

Re:A college student created an app that can tell whether AI... by aliqot on Monday January 09, 2023 @08:30PM (#34319119)
>but if i were an english teacher assigning research-like papers, i'd definitely incorporate chatgpt responses into my assignments.

now THAT is a creative thing to do. I like that. I suppose the calculator version would be to do something like: "here is a simple graph plot, create an equation that produces a similar plot"

Wish there were more teachers like you embracing this stuff as a tool rather than doing your best to design a curriculum to 'defeat' it.