News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Social contagions can cause genuine illness, and TikTok m... by rowanG077 on Sunday January 08, 2023 @01:39PM (#34301760)
That they are self-modifying is the entire point. You can't just sweep that under the rug. This is what you said:

> 2. The outcomes of these procedures are in different stratospheres, and gender surgery doesn’t involve changing the makeup of one’s brain and the fundamental structures through which one experiences subjective reality.

And transitioning for sure changes the makeup of one's brain. You can backpedal all you want now but your own words are very clear.

Re:Social contagions can cause genuine illness, and TikTok m... by haswell on Sunday January 08, 2023 @01:57PM (#34301916)
> That they are self-modifying is the entire point.

From my perspective, physical destruction was the primary point, and I was very specifically calling attention to how that destruction is meaningfully different from other kinds of changes.

That the brain is self-modifying was assumed, and self modification becomes a moot point when the brain is no longer capable of the traditional processes of self modification due to physical destruction.

> And transitioning for sure changes the makeup of one's brain.

A point that I acknowledged explicitly above. That doesn't mean that attacking a region of the brain with a metal spike and hammer is somehow the same thing.

> You can backpedal all you want now but your own words are very clear.

Obviously my words were not very clear since you've taken some meaning from them that I never intended.

Hopefully this comment clarifies the original intent sufficiently (which, incidentally is not back pedaling, since nothing about my position has changed).