News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:E-mail is the Universal Platform by bane on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @08:52PM (#3426938)
I'm almost convinced at this point if somebody simply built a facebook like interface, and used email as the messaging protocol, but didn't display it like an email, more like a FB conversation (as opposed to a threaded or gmail-like conversation view), that it would be used. There's not really much that's offered by alternate messaging solutions that email can't do if it existing in the right sort of framework:

1) Person-to-person? Check

2) Person-to-group? Check

3) Group-to-group? Check

4) Group-to-person? Check

5) Multimedia? Check

6) Fancy formatting? Check

7) Attached files? Check

8) Near real-time? Check (most of the time)

9) Deliver Fault tolerant? Check

10) Federated/distributed? Check

Why everybody seems to want to reinvent email is beyond me. About the only thing that FB or G+ offer is the storage of a server-side contact list so I don't have to remember their email address and the use of a white-list for sender/receivers so I don't get spam. Offer the same with email and a decent web interface and you've basically recreated any "modern" social network, except it'll be built on a time-tested, robust protocol that's already ubiquitous across the internet and already has billions of users.

edit I guess what I'm saying is that it's the application layer (server and client side) in the email equation that needs most of the rework, not the protocol layers.

Re:E-mail is the Universal Platform by est on Thursday January 05, 2012 @02:35AM (#3427845)
> Why everybody seems to want to reinvent email is beyond me.

11) Program parsable structured info? UNCHECK

How cool if emails have a semantic layer standard, like when someone invites you to an event using email, another app could automatically recognize datetime, convert time zones and add to a task reminder? (think of embedded iCal or vCard, but more generic and powerful).

Re:E-mail is the Universal Platform by nemoniac on Thursday January 05, 2012 @07:02AM (#3428389)
Emails have a semantic layer standard. it handles iCal and vCard. And not only that, it's extensible. See mailcap and MIME.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mailcap http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MIME

Re:E-mail is the Universal Platform by chetan51 on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @11:33PM (#3427415)
I agree with most of what you said, except that the real-time aspect is not real-time enough. If email were actually real-time, then it could completely replace instant messaging as well. Right now it's lacking.
Re:E-mail is the Universal Platform by bane on Thursday January 05, 2012 @12:00AM (#3427479)
True, which is probably why google put im right next to the message viewer in gmail. I know of many ocassions where a flurry of emails turned into an im session.

I think gmail's "conversations" are really the first try at what I'm talking about, a new front end on email, but I don't think they work well enough personally. And they haven't really expanded well on the concept recently.

Re:E-mail is the Universal Platform by chetan51 on Thursday January 05, 2012 @12:16AM (#3427504)
Google Wave was really what I thought the ideal marriage between email and IM. Why did it fail again?
Re:E-mail is the Universal Platform by noahth on Thursday January 05, 2012 @12:37AM (#3427561)
1) incredibly poor rollout strategy (imo) 2) what problem did it actually solve again?

forgive any appearance of snark; i just wanted to be concise, and i don't think that "the ideal marriage between email and IM" is something that people were - or are - desperately crying out to have.

Re:E-mail is the Universal Platform by cstejerean on Thursday January 05, 2012 @06:23AM (#3428301)
I believe it failed in part because of the slow rollout (nobody you cared about had access yet) and lack of interop with email for notifications about changes, etc. I tried using it, and gave up. By the time it became widely available most of the early adopters gave up as well.
Re:E-mail is the Universal Platform by Scaevolus on Thursday January 05, 2012 @06:13AM (#3428283)
The things that turned me off were:

1) Busy, complex interface.

2) Sluggishness.

I find Convore to be a much better way to approach the same problem of how to enhance email.

Re:E-mail is the Universal Platform by mnutt on Thursday January 05, 2012 @12:21PM (#3429516)
Shameless self-promotion: my startup (http://movableink.com) lets you add real-time elements to email. In fact, we have a group messaging company using it to show real-time conversations in status emails.

It doesn't allow interactivity (which is what you're probably thinking of) but it does provide real-time content.

Re:E-mail is the Universal Platform by akrymski on Thursday January 05, 2012 @08:41PM (#3431533)
It is real-time, it's just that current email clients aren't designed to be efficient, it's purely UI's fault. Again this is something we've fixed at post.fm, cant wait to show you guys.
Re:E-mail is the Universal Platform by chetan51 on Thursday January 05, 2012 @11:32PM (#3431979)
Is the protocol actually as real-time as XMPP is?
Re:E-mail is the Universal Platform by akrymski on Friday January 06, 2012 @07:49AM (#3433070)
Obviously email doesn't support seeing someone type, but SMTP is almost as fast as XMPP - sub 1 second doesn't really make a difference, it's usually IMAP that's the slow bit. Of course it's just as fast as XMPP if both sender and recipient are using post.fm, but the real latency comes from the recipient using eg gmail which has really slow IMAP polling in the web client (plus having to go back to the inbox or clicking show new message in gmail). Post.fm doesn't use IMAP under the hood so its instantaneous (and querying your mail in SQL lets us do amazing stuff).
Re:E-mail is the Universal Platform by chetan51 on Friday January 06, 2012 @09:07AM (#3433295)
What is post.fm? Do you have a demo yet? I'd love to see it.
Re:E-mail is the Universal Platform by akrymski on Sunday January 08, 2012 @09:42AM (#3439599)
its a new email platform to rival gmail, but we're stealth still so i cant disclose much. we'll be starting a beta pretty soon and issue an official press release at that stage - make sure you request an invite in the meantime.
Re:E-mail is the Universal Platform by neilrahilly on Thursday January 05, 2012 @01:26AM (#3427695)
I made a REST/HTTP/JSON API for accessing IMAP mailboxes: http://imappr.com. The idea is to make email, as a messaging platform, as easy to work with as the Twitter or Facebook APIs.
Re:E-mail is the Universal Platform by Joakal on Wednesday January 04, 2012 @10:36PM (#3427239)
Re:E-mail is the Universal Platform by akrymski on Thursday January 05, 2012 @08:38PM (#3431526)
That is exactly what post.fm is all about. Check it out - we'd love for you to become a beta tester and perhaps pick your brain a bit ;)