News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by hijinks on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @11:35PM (#34256013)
remember people, most employment lawyers work on contingency for this reason. They only get paid if you win. Most people don't know that and think it'll be too expensive to take on their old company
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by nipponese on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @11:57PM (#34256155)
Are you saying twitter is legally obligated to pay severance because musk said so on twitter?
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by greenhorn360 on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:06AM (#34256224)
They're legally obligated because of the WARN Act.
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by gedy on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:41AM (#34256482)
I'm not defending Twitter but it sounds like this person may still be getting paid (due to WARN), just hadn't got severance letter.
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by shagie on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:47AM (#34256516)
The WARN act does not mandate severance.

It does, instead, mandate that the employee is given a 30 day notice that they will be laid off. It would be completely within the law to say "you will be laid off on Feb 4" and require you to work until Feb 4, and not have any sort of additional severance pay.

Severance pay is not required under California law. https://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/finalpay.pdf

> There is no legal requirement under California law that employers provide severance pay to an employee upon termination of employment.

Confusing severance pay, WARN act, and the common practice of garden leave can make it harder for people to understand what they are entitled to.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by Supermancho on Thursday January 05, 2023 @01:12AM (#34256675)
This seems like a long-winded couching of the simple premise that would explain what happened. The tweet/author is misrepresenting the situation or was promised something he isn't legally entitled to, regardless.

> mandate that the employee is given a 30 day notice that they will be laid off

ie maybe he was terminated with notice and it wasn't explicitly labeled a severance letter.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by mc32 on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:07AM (#34256229)
Suing a company is typically not beneficial for the worker or ex worker. Unless the payout is greater than what remains of your lifetime earnings projections. A person with litigious history carries a kind of scarlet letter around their neck. No one wants to risk being the next target.

Think: would you want to bring on a cofounder who sued their previous cofounder? Maybe you would, but many would have second thoughts too.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by wpietri on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:32AM (#34256417)
I would absolutely hire somebody who sued Twitter for failing to pay what was owed. In a heartbeat. I like working with people with character; you can trust them to let you know when something isn't right.

Similarly, I'd look very carefully at anybody who stayed at Twitter well into the Musk era. As I did people who were at Uber during the Travis era. Sometimes decent people have good reasons for working for bad execs. (E.g., I hear a lot of the SpaceX people see putting up with Musk as a necessary evil for getting to work on something they care so much about.) But sometimes they are clue-deficient or lack a moral core, and those people require too much close supervision for my tastes.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by klabb3 on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:41AM (#34256481)
> Sometimes decent people have good reasons for working for bad execs.

Yep. Don’t forget immigration, that can be a big reason to stay. There was this famous pic of Elon with the some of the remaining Twitter staff and let’s just say they looked quite international. Obviously SV is multicultural and you shouldn’t assume individual traits from appearance, but, for a group it’s somewhat reasonable to assume a fair amount of H1B hostages with a huge incentive to stay, especially in the current economic climate.

Speaking as a former H1B holder.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by wpietri on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:50AM (#34256536)
Oh yeah, totally. I recall one absolutely terrible place that was well-stocked with H1B holders because they would grimly put up with all the executive nonsense. They were not a talkative bunch, but I got the impression a number of them were just saving every dollar possible for a planned return home. Which I totally respected, but I still felt terrible for them.
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by amachefe on Thursday January 05, 2023 @02:48AM (#34257136)
Saying people "looked quite international" is prejudicial

You don't get a pass because Elon and Twitter happens to be involved.

It is very unlikely if upto has of Twitter 2000+ employees are "H1B hostages", but I doubt that will serve your purpose

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by klabb3 on Thursday January 05, 2023 @06:03AM (#34258251)
Meh. I’ve worked in SF in another big tech corp. I know the demographics. I know many of those that are on H1Bs and as I said I’ve been myself. I also knew people at Twitter. It was less diverse than the big ones then, at least that was the image. The stereotype was more Equinox Soul Cycle white chic career women who live in the Marina, or something like that.

> I doubt that will serve your purpose

What purpose? I’m not coming from a culture war perspective in the slightest, but purely from his micro-/mismanagement of the company, and his treatment of employees, which I have learnt directly from his own words.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by wpietri on Thursday January 05, 2023 @01:42PM (#34264449)
> is prejudicial

It is not. He made no negative assumptions about the people in question and did no harm to them.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by david38 on Thursday January 05, 2023 @08:39PM (#34269821)
What crap. You are implying “international” == “bad”. Like poor workers, likely to commit crimes, poor communicators, etc.

The opposite is true. The “internationals” in that photo have a strong reputation for interest and hard work in engineering and the sciences.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by klodolph on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:42AM (#34256484)
> Similarly, I'd look very carefully at anybody who stayed at Twitter well into the Musk era.

Maybe the people without H1Bs. The H1Bs are in a tough spot.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by ars on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:47AM (#34256512)
Working for Musk means you don't have a moral core?
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by wpietri on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:52AM (#34256552)
I think that is one possible reason to work for Musk. An easy way for you to check here is looking at the number of people who have quit Twitter in recent months for ethical reasons. If the ethical people leave, what do you imagine remains behind?
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by vagrantJin on Thursday January 05, 2023 @01:38AM (#34256793)
Please do not judge people with such easy contempt.

Quite likely the people who have quit are upper middle class folks who have a huge safety net that allows them to throw tantrums with little repercussion. They also likely dont have to support a family and I don't mean 1or 2 kids.

TLDR; being ethical is great if you can afford it.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by wpietri on Thursday January 05, 2023 @01:50PM (#34264562)
I agree that ethics are a luxury good, but for developers they're a pretty easily affordable one. As I said, people can have good reasons for working for bad people. But many don't.

Back when email spam was relatively new, sometimes I would track down a spammer, call them up, and ask them what they were doing. Some were apologetic! They didn't know why it was bad, or had gotten talked into something by a sleazy sales guy. But I still remember one conversation with a guy who clearly felt bad about it but wasn't going to stop because he had a family to feed.

What I hope he eventually figured out is that everybody has a family to feed, but that doesn't justify harming other people and their families. I get that in the short term people end up stuck in things where the didn't realize what was going on. for example, that's how I ended up working in financial trading for a while. But I got out. It may take them a while, but others can too.

And for those that can't figure it out or don't care? I don't want to work with them until they do. They get to make their choices, but I get to make mine.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by vagrantJin on Friday January 06, 2023 @01:48AM (#34271745)
> As I said, people can have good reasons for working for bad people. But many don't.

Fair enough. But who is the bad person in this instance? What is the bad thing they did in contrast to really bad people like kingpins and human traffickers? Is it worth jeopardising finacial stability and a career over it.

It seems to me we need a universal scale of morality - since people have to justify why they are continuing to work for a paycheck.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by wpietri on Friday January 06, 2023 @02:42PM (#34279857)
There's always something worse, so that's not a reasonable way to decide whether something is sufficiently moral. Hit men can say, "Sure, I kill people for a living, but it's not like I eat them or have sex with their corpses after. Those are the real bad people; I'm just a professional doing a job like any other Joe."

You can try constructing a universal moral scale if you want. For me it's sufficient to see if the people I might hire are good matches for the work and the team.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by roguecoder on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @09:33PM (#34348414)
There are a million other careers out there. I absolutely judge people who prioritize their personal greed and luxury over ethics, as should we all.
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by UncleEntity on Thursday January 05, 2023 @04:17AM (#34257673)
> Similarly, I'd look very carefully at anybody…

Not everyone can afford to piss off a job because it doesn’t perfectly align with their moral compass.

All this talk about recession, unaffordable housing, tech layoffs and whatever else gets page views might make someone just a little hesitant to up and quit a job because the company is run by a raving lunatic.

Must be nice though to be in a position where you can create a class of undesirable peoples.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by wpietri on Thursday January 05, 2023 @01:40PM (#34264413)
Sure. And you can "not anybody can" for all sorts of factors that are relevant in hiring. Not everybody can work on interesting projects. Not everybody is given a chance to lead. Not everybody is working at places where they get to use modern tooling.

You seem to be acting as if I'm going to just throw out any resume with Twitter on it. What I said was I'd look very carefully at someone, which is what I'd do with literally dozens of causes of concern. And "perfectly align" is pretty hyperbolic. If you're exaggerating like this for hit-dogs-holler reasons, you might think about that.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by UncleEntity on Friday January 06, 2023 @09:27AM (#34274893)
> You seem to be acting as if I'm going to just throw out any resume with Twitter on it.

You did imply that is the case. The only people who stayed post-musk have compromised morals or they would have left with the rest of the right thinkers.

Maybe not what you meant but what I read.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by wpietri on Friday January 06, 2023 @02:39PM (#34279795)
You inferred that, but it is neither what I meant nor what I said.
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by roguecoder on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @09:32PM (#34348407)
I'm sorry actions have consequences. That must be disappointing.

I once saw a resume that had Enron, Wells Fargo, Uber and a crypto scam on it. That thing went straight in the bin. I'd have way more respect for someone who spent a couple of years bagging groceries than someone who embraced an abusive, toxic culture out of greed.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by htag on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:18AM (#34256312)
A high profile situation like this might be a different case. If this is happening to many former employees, and it reaches class action, then there will be a lot of press about the subject. You wouldn't have to explain why you brought the lawsuit, and everyone would have an understanding of the situation.

What's the point of being able to free to file a lawsuit if you practically can't?

What would you think of someone that wouldn't fight for themselves when they were lied to and cheated?

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by mc32 on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:21AM (#34256333)
Class actions is a possibility and it’s viable but most of the money would go to law firms and not end up in your pocket anyhow, so it’d be more of a stick it to the man action than an action to receive monetary compensation.
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by bhouston on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:39AM (#34256466)
Most of the money does go to employees who sue their employers forrongful termination and similar. Do you have evidence to the contrary or are you just knee jerk defending Elon?
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by crazysim on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:30AM (#34256403)
The man has a name.
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by danaris on Thursday January 05, 2023 @08:53AM (#34259518)
I would imagine there's a significant difference between a class action lawsuit on behalf of tens to hundreds of thousands of wronged customers, many of whom may not actually know they're part of the class, with a somewhat nebulous monetary damage value, and a class action lawsuit on behalf of hundreds to thousands of employees, all of whom know perfectly well they're part of the class, and where the monetary damage values per employee are both high and fairly clear.
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by bhouston on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:38AM (#34256458)
Successful people stand up for themselves, otherwise they will get taken of in life and business. You don’t want to be unstable, hysterical or sue over nothing but you want to stand up for your self in a consistent and thoughtful way.

Of course you don’t want people standing up to you if you are trying to screw them over, but it that is just your self interest.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by CGamesPlay on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:14AM (#34256278)
Why would the ex-worker disclose it? Are there many known cases of this happening? Also, I think founder- or exec-level employees probably have a different hiring experience than J Random Line Worker, regardless of past litigation history.
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by mc32 on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:18AM (#34256309)
A BG check would show that as they are public record. One option is to threaten a lawsuit and then hope to settle for a smaller amount.
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by BenFranklin100 on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:36AM (#34256446)
That’s interesting, I didn’t know that. Is that the case if it was settled out of court? Often employee labor disputes are settled out of court if the lawsuit is less than $30-50K.
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by bhouston on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:43AM (#34256493)
As someone who has been sued and settled this didn’t affect anything, I still raised money, gained business partners and grew the business. Business disputes happen.

In many ways suing or getting sued in business is like losing your virginity. It seems like a big deal before it happens the first time but then anfterward it isn’t a big deal and just stuff that happens.

I feel you are spreading FUD to protect one of the richest guys in the world and telling little people who have been abused here to just take it.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by BenFranklin100 on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:31AM (#34256411)
In many cases, potential future employers won’t be the wiser I would think. For example, some companies have a standard policy of not discussing past employee’s history. You have lost a reference however, which is often worth something.
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by jakelazaroff on Thursday January 05, 2023 @12:51AM (#34256539)
I would simply not lay off half my workers and then fail to pay the severance that I promised and legally owe them.
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by ClumsyPilot on Thursday January 05, 2023 @01:32AM (#34256772)
> A person with litigious history carries a kind of scarlet letter around their neck. No one wants to risk

You are advocating the mindset of a medieval serf, how dare little people stand up for themselves and defy the baron?

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by roguecoder on Wednesday January 11, 2023 @09:29PM (#34348385)
Did their previous cofounder fuck them over? Because I sure as fuck want a cofounder who will be willing to sue whoever fucks us over, whereas I don't intend to fuck anyone over so it would be zero risk to me.

Someone who is too worried about what Musk fanboys think of them to go after what they are owed would make a terrible founder.

Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by encryptluks2 on Thursday January 05, 2023 @01:00AM (#34256616)
Just a warning about contingency-based lawyers. First, read and re-read any agreements they send and know what you're getting yourself into. Hiring a contingency attorney may seem great cause it is easy, but if they are doing a terrible job and you want to fire them then be prepared for them to say they are still entitled to whatever percentage you agreed to with them no longer doing anything. A 30k settlement may seem great to a contingency attorney because they may get 10k for essentially sending a few letters that you could have sent yourself. They also may already have pre-arranged agreements and relationships with the big companies that represent the company you are suing to essentially pay you as little as possible. Don't settle for less than you deserve and definitely don't rely on a contingency attorney to tell you how much you should settle for. Make them work for you and not the other way around.
Re:I was laid off 2 months agoand I’ve never even seen a sev... by P_I_Staker on Thursday January 05, 2023 @04:49PM (#34267255)
> They also may already have pre-arranged agreements and relationships with the big companies that represent the company you are suing to essentially pay you as little as possible.

This is illegal, but I imagine I could see something like this happening naturally and cynically... you get similar effects with realtors and recruiters.

Still, there's plenty that are honestly and earnestly do their job for the most part. Often times these people can make deals happen. Taking a relatively basic deal instead of going to trial is often a good call.

If he knows he can get something pretty decent and you have to risk $30K+ for a long shot chance.