I'm having a hard time understanding where your attitude here originated from. Copyright in the US has always just been a matter of practicality from the founding of the US through hundreds of years of jurisprudence, and you can see that in how readily aspects of it are traded off against other public interests. Copyright as basic morality would result in a system radically different from the one we have now.
No, as the value being provided isn't the item being used, but the satire. Piracy doesn't add value like satire does.
Which is why intellectual property isn't a moral right, but a tradeoff. And currently a lopsided one, at that.
> From the perspective of the person whose work was infringed via parody, they care only their work was used without their permission.
No, they care that that are being made fun of. People who attack parodies aren't concerned that someone would buy the parody instead of the original work - very few people would.
One could argue that I'm profiting from the original song either way--people are more likely to buy a parody of a song they've heard than one they haven't.
You're right.
Using something somebody has made without their permission is unethical.
Fixed.