Re:Piracy is not a problem; SOPA is not a solution
by mnutt on Thursday January 05, 2012 @12:52AM
(#3427608)
You switched from "using something without someone's permission is morally wrong" to "using something without someone's permission is morally wrong, unless you add value to it". From the perspective of the person whose work was infringed via parody, they don't care that something was added, only that their work was used without their permission.
Which is why intellectual property isn't a moral right, but a tradeoff. And currently a lopsided one, at that.
Re:Piracy is not a problem; SOPA is not a solution
by nailer on Thursday January 05, 2012 @07:37AM
(#3428474)
I changed the language to illustrate that whether the originally copy still existed makes no difference.
> From the perspective of the person whose work was infringed via parody, they care only their work was used without their permission.
No, they care that that are being made fun of. People who attack parodies aren't concerned that someone would buy the parody instead of the original work - very few people would.
Re:Piracy is not a problem; SOPA is not a solution
by mnutt on Friday January 06, 2012 @01:35AM
(#3432287)
To Paul McCartney, it doesn't really matter whether I'm making a crappy metal cover of Hey Jude, or a parody of it. Why is one unethical, but not the other?
One could argue that I'm profiting from the original song either way--people are more likely to buy a parody of a song they've heard than one they haven't.
No, as the value being provided isn't the item being used, but the satire. Piracy doesn't add value like satire does.