Re:People with disagreeable personalities do not have an adv...
by HWR_14 on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @02:33PM
(#34236751)
The study defines "disagreeable" as "selfish, combative and manipulative". I don't think the point is as fine as you think.
It's not about "passive" vs "assertive" like you claim. Both of those can be agreeable!
Re:People with disagreeable personalities do not have an adv...
by kyleyeats on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @02:34PM
(#34236774)
Great point, thanks for making it. It's maybe this very conflation that I have the real problem with.
Re:People with disagreeable personalities do not have an adv...
by citrate05 on Wednesday January 04, 2023 @02:11AM
(#34242930)
But the Big Five Inventory [1] does explicitly ask if subjects consider themselves to sometimes be cold, distant, rude, unkind, selfish, or inconsiderate of others, and these answers are all used to compute their (dis)agreeableness scores. Similar questions also show up in other inventories. So, without even getting into any other behaviors these traits might correlate with, the Big 5 definition of "disagreeable" extends well beyond literally just tending to disagree with others.
[1] https://arc.psych.wisc.edu/self-report/big-five-inventory-bf...
You do, actually, have to be disagreeable to disagree. Agreeable people don't like to cause a fuss and just go along with stuff even if they disagree internally. Disagreeable people are the people who tend to disagree. That's all it means. Some of them are snarky assholes (you right now?), and others are just people who disagree.
"Disagreeable" in common parlance means difficult, overly-critical, and aggressive, but that's not what 's being said here.