A foreign investor would need to arrange for straw purchasers to avoid the law, but that in itself would be an act of consciousness of guilt for breaking this law.
Something that's not been brought up much in this discussion is that foreign real estate investment is a diversification tactic: they're buying to get money into a different market than the rest of their wealth. That's why it isn't Canadians driving most of this. Foreign real estate is primarily a safe offshore hedge.
Above, 'PragmaticPulp wrote that:
> I visited a friend who lived in a high rise and barely saw anyone else come and go from the building the entire week I was there. From the windows we could see into other nearby high rises, most of which were empty. Empty not because they were for sale, but because they had been purchased as investment vehicles by foreign investors who had no intention of ever living there.
And my question is how they knew that those apartments were empty because they were owned by some foreign investor (who presumably also wasn’t interested in making money on rent)?
I don’t understand how rules about conveyancing answer that question.
Then charge a vacancy tax.
If nobody is doing the following in a week, I am: set up Canadian entities, pay Canadians to manage it, buy houses and raise offshore capital with variable-rate notes tied to some index that's basically the value of the underlying homes.
My point: if it wasn’t rental only, I really wonder how many neighbours I’d have in a development like this, which seems like it would be a prime target for shoebox buyers around the upper-middle of the market
Foreigners are just a correlate.
Going after foreigners for this is like banning men from all bars in Canada because of the high correlation between date-rape drug usage and being a man.
https://www.toronto.ca/services-payments/property-taxes-util...
This is what drives me crazy about this story. The vast, vast majority of evidence suggests that the problem is with domestic investors. But because of a nice little story, suddenly it’s foreigners who are the problem.
Because its not about just buying for property buying sake. It's just an asset. People invest in assets to hopefully see a return. The fact they are buying in vancouver and not detroit is because these investors expect to see a substantial gain with the vancouver asset versus the detroit one. SPY is down 20% this year while vancouver properties actually saw a gain, its even better to invest in vancouver real estate than the stock market currently.
So how do you walk this back and not make housing in vancouver such a great speculative asset? Easy, you devalue housing, by allowing for apartments to be built in the ~80% of vancouver that is limited to single family or low density development.
Another good rule of thumb is to not dismiss issues just because they don't fit an over-generalized idea of how all situations must work.
The housing situation in Canada is weird. I visited a friend who lived in a high rise and barely saw anyone else come and go from the building the entire week I was there. From the windows we could see into other nearby high rises, most of which were empty. Empty not because they were for sale, but because they had been purchased as investment vehicles by foreign investors who had no intention of ever living there. An entire industry had popped up to cater to these foreign investors and help facilitate their purchase of these properties.
I can't say if this law will be able to curb that weirdness, but it should at least make a dent.