A universe without a conscious observer seems kind of pointless to me.
It's not enough to talk about any meaningful statistics.
The fact that we have a somewhat complicated mind capable of abstract thinking doesn't mean we're anything more than bacteria on the grander scale.
The fact that our species has developed all over Earth and became its self-appointed "stewards" doesn't mean that a well-placed asteroid can't turn our "stewardship" into a futile battle for survival.
We are so much more than bacteria, and until proved otherwise, so far we are the smartest beings in the universe.
We will at some point, stop existing as a species.
This doesn't mean everything we do is meaningless.
Eternity and infinity intelligence are not the only measures we can choose to value ourselves, in fact, they smell too much like religion for my personal taste.
What we have is more struggle, more problems to overcome, more challenges and the possibility of succeeding, the possibility of leaving the solar system before the sun dies and kills the earth.
Step by step. Value the small victories. We have reached very far, so far.
It is one by our point of view, and most humans argue that (a) our point of view is the only one that matters since in the grand aspect we haven’t found any other intelligent point of view, though we theorize they may exist and (b) judging the pain of death as catastrophe is a personal choice, even on Earth we allow people to call the death of their loved ones catastrophic even if other humans continue to go on living blithely unaware of their pain.
The idea of a human-centric universe is quite humorous.
Even if this position seems obvious to you, I respectfully would suggest you consider that most people do not hold extremely nihilistic views like this, and that a lack of nihilism is not naive.
From that perspective, it is hard to argue that is not accurate. And if it is accurate, then positions contrary to it are not accurate and therefore naive.
It's one way I guess, but there's no reason to prefer it, and it's not popular for obvious reasons.
Now that the universe has manifested we conscious agents of its matter, how dare we squander this gift? Just because it didn't come with an instruction manual? We will find our own purpose.
I will admit that I chuckled at the cancer comparison. How does the universe consider, which cells are 'good'?
> Nihilists recognize that meaning is not inherent, but rather ascribed by the person experiencing the feeling.
That sounds reasonable, so here's an attempt at a synthesis. The universe is huge and mostly empty, but here we have a tiny patch full of life and self-ascribed meaning. Does the universe prefer life? The part that's alive certainly does! So don't let it fall to ashes just to appease the void. I think that's the best answer a mere mortal can give.
This is an interesting question, and the answer one gives is highly dependent upon their worldview and beliefs.
From a Christian perspective (on which most of the Western world was based), the earth was given to humans along with an explicit decree to have children and "subdue" it and everything on it ( https://www.biblegateway.com/passage/?search=genesis+1%3A28&... ). Therefore in the Christian worldview, Earth is pretty explicitly defined as human-centric, and human life is considered above all else on this Earth.
I appreciate the effort to keep an open mind, but you can have too much of everything :)
This objection is technically correct, but misses the point completely. It's irrelevant whether "the universe" cares – all that matters to humanity is whether humans care. And they do care about the survival of their species.
I would care. As a human (as a living organism, really), I have children because I hope they outlive me (that's not the only reason!). In a way, they are what's left of me when I'm dead. And my grandchildren when my children are dead. So, yes, I would be sad if my children choose to not have any children themselves, and I would consider it a catastrophe if the hypothesis that a whole generation stopped having kids materialized.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antinatalism [2] https://www.newyorker.com/culture/persons-of-interest/the-ca...
If the last human dies and there is no one there to witness it, who is there to claim this a catastrophe?
This article makes a big, implicit assumption about a very human-centric world, which I consider kind of naïve; the universe, including Earth, does not care or need to care about humanity in order to keep on existing. According to all current knowledge, it did just fine before us, and it will likely do just fine after us, even if we do our best to make it inhospitable e.g. via global nuclear warfare.