News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by akamaka on Monday January 02, 2023 @01:44AM (#34215084)
How will Apple recoup the cost of designing a powerful chip for a product like the Mac Pro, which is presumably their lowest-selling product?

Most of the M-series chips are shared across multiple products, but the Mac Pro seems to be a clear case where using a powerful off-the-shelf Intel chip makes more business sense right now.

I don’t see Apple doing it simply as a vanity project, so there will have to be some innovation or new product line coming if an Apple Silicon Mac Pro is to ever exist.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by teruakohatu on Monday January 02, 2023 @01:49AM (#34215109)
> clear case where using a powerful off-the-shelf Intel chip makes more business sense right now.

It will simplify MacOS when they end Intel support.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by vlovich123 on Monday January 02, 2023 @02:21AM (#34215270)
Yeah, that’s a common analysis people seem to miss even though Apple is very clearly vertically integrated. Software maintenance costs are so much significantly higher that unifying HW is significantly more value even if the margins aren’t as good. The high end macs serve as cachet status symbols amongst the creators and designers which tend to contain a lot of trend setters + mind share + creative software being optimized around the macs which then means that hardware is purchased at disproportionately higher levels (+ potential downstream effects where if you’re mostly a max shop already, shouldn’t you just get the MacBook Air and other Apple devices to simplify corporate device management?). Also a unified HW platform ALSO reduces software maintenance costs for partners and which is a nice virtuous cycle of encouraging that porting to happen. Apple has a uniquely holistic view of the market place that they’ve cultivated over decades and I’ve seen no sign that they’ve ever lost sight of that like many competitors due at much smaller market caps.
Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by lapcat on Monday January 02, 2023 @02:06AM (#34215202)
Exactly this. There's a cost to supporting Intel forever only for the Mac Pro and nothing else.

Not only a cost to Apple, but also a cost to 3rd party Mac developers, who would be even less likely to have the resources to support the Mac Pro for its own sake.

Apple dropped PowerPC support in Mac OS X (10.6) 3.5 years after the Intel transition started, and they dropped Rosetta support in Mac OS X (10.7) 2 years after that.

IIRC the last PPC Mac hardware was discontinued very soon after the Intel transition started.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by iamtedd on Monday January 02, 2023 @03:39AM (#34215745)
You don't think it's possible that the cost to maintain MacOS support for Intel is already built into the price of a Mac Pro?
Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by lapcat on Monday January 02, 2023 @06:57AM (#34216987)
Certainly not for 3rd party developers, who get $0 from Mac Pro sales. Hard to sell a machine if there's no software support.

Anyway, no, not for Apple either, because Mac Pro unit sales are already low, and trying to make that one Mac model cover the cost of all macOS Intel support will make the already expensive and low volume Mac Pro even more expensive, and thus even lower volume, making it harder to cover the cost.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by akamaka on Monday January 02, 2023 @02:48AM (#34215423)
That’s aside from the point. They could accomplish that by simply killing off the Mac Pro line.

The question is how they will pay for a high-end chip when they no longer can rely on Intel to spread out the development cost among many customers.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by pigsty on Monday January 02, 2023 @03:29AM (#34215673)
I feel like Mac Pro purchasers also have an accompanying MacBook Pro and iPhone and are more entwined in the ecosystem than the typical user.

Frustrating those people likely comes with a risk of losing high value customers.

I think it’s similar to the model a lot of game consoles have. They make little to negative profit on the console itself during the first couple years, but make it up on software and other benefits of hardware lock-in.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by dmitriid on Monday January 02, 2023 @05:51AM (#34216534)
> They could accomplish that by simply killing off the Mac Pro line.

In the time after the trashcan Mac Pro they lost a significant portion of the professional market. And while that market is relatively small, it's highly influencial.

By the time Final Cut Pro X was unveiled Apple could boast that 60% of Hollywood movies are edited on a Mac. Now? Not so much. And this probably extends into other areas, too.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by donbrae on Monday January 02, 2023 @06:44AM (#34216898)
Indeed. Releasing FCP X as an MVP (a concept no-one outside of software dev understands), without the features in FCP 9 that professionals expect, was a bad idea. I know a couple of filmmakers that switched to PC, partly due to the cost of Macs but also because of FCP X.
Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by jsjohnst on Monday January 02, 2023 @07:31AM (#34217238)
> without the features in FCP 9 that professionals expect

There was no version 9, nor version 8. ;)

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by donbrae on Monday January 02, 2023 @10:01AM (#34218569)
Of course, sorry, my mistake!
Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by cm2187 on Monday January 02, 2023 @03:35AM (#34215716)
Do we know how long it will take? Apple doesn't have a huge history of backward compatibility. This could be a not so subtle nudge to force everyone to re-buy their hardware at a time people are keeping their computer hardware for longer.
Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by rahoulb on Monday January 02, 2023 @06:34AM (#34216839)
I wouldn't be surprised if they keep internal Intel support anyway - as well as other architectures.

The difference would be supporting Intel publicly - with third-party developers. As the target for Mac Pros won't just be running a load of electron apps.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by ksec on Monday January 02, 2023 @02:19AM (#34215258)
>How will Apple recoup the cost of designing a powerful chip for a product like the Mac Pro, which is presumably their lowest-selling product?

Which is the question I have been asking since 2015. From a cost prospective it never made any sense. Presumably they will wait until Mac Studio becoming powerful enough to fill the gap.

>but the Mac Pro seems to be a clear case where using a powerful off-the-shelf Intel chip makes more business sense right now.

It surely does. Except it will be the only Mac in the lineup without Metal Support and Apple's increasingly important NPU for Machine Learning features. I dont see it as a good trade off.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by chongli on Monday January 02, 2023 @02:48AM (#34215418)
Which is the question I have been asking since 2015. From a cost prospective it never made any sense. Presumably they will wait until Mac Studio becoming powerful enough to fill the gap.

To me the only reason they still make products like the Mac Pro is for brand reputation and face-saving. It’s like when a big auto maker sponsors a formula 1 racing team. There’s no profit in formula 1 (for the auto makers). It’s just a giant money pit!

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by kalleboo on Monday January 02, 2023 @03:53AM (#34215838)
Right, as a brand reputation item, if you're building an ecosystem you need to have a clear upgrade path for all your users.

If I'm starting out today and looking to choose a PC or Mac ecosystem, if I see that the Mac has an upper bound that's lower than the PC, then in my starry-eyed optimism as a newbie I'll think I might as well start as the PC since one day when I'm super successful and I need more power I'm going to have to change platforms anyway.

Even if none of those users will ever end up using any more power than the Mac Studio, if they're convinced they will then they will not choose your ecosystem.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by thewebcount on Monday January 02, 2023 @02:55AM (#34215458)
What do you mean without Metal support? All Intel Macs shipped for the last 5 years at least have supported Metal.
Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by jsjohnst on Monday January 02, 2023 @07:43AM (#34217326)
I have a 2011 Mac Pro that supports Metal. ;) I think it was Mojave (10.14) that required Metal support for all graphics cards, which effectively killed off a bunch of older machines, but the Mac Pro was the one that had Metal support going back the furthest to I think 2010 (most others were 2012 or later).
Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by dagmx on Monday January 02, 2023 @03:35AM (#34215720)
Metal is a feature of the OS not the hardware. Every Mac supports metal today.

Some caveats:

* maybe not true if you go back to the introduction of metal but idk

* metal feature support varies by hardware

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by rosywoozlechan on Monday January 02, 2023 @03:39AM (#34215743)
what does the name "Metal" invoke in your mind?

> The Metal framework gives your app direct access to a device’s graphics processing unit (GPU).

https://developer.apple.com/documentation/metal/

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by dagmx on Monday January 02, 2023 @03:44AM (#34215776)
Edit: the user above changed the content of their post materially twice , with wildly different content each time.

I’m not sure how to respond as a result since it’s hard to discuss in good faith.

V1 of their comment simply asked what “metal” evokes in one’s mind.

V2 then posted a link to the Metal page saying it lets you directly use your GPU hardware.

V3 is now pointing out that metal feature support varies by hardware which I already called out, but they’re positing as a contradiction somehow.

As such I’ve removed my reply because it makes no sense based on their frequent changes and left this one instead.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by rosywoozlechan on Monday January 02, 2023 @04:04AM (#34215894)
I corrected my comment as I realized I was mistaken? I didn't see that I had a reply, and I wasn't able to delete my comment. You must have replied instantly because this all happened within a couple of minutes of me originally writing the comment. I frequently update comments like this.
Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by dagmx on Monday January 02, 2023 @04:12AM (#34215944)
Fair enough. It does show a 5 minute difference between the comments, so not instant but I recognize edits happen. It’s just that each of your edits were so wildly different.

As for your latest update, I had already mentioned that in my comment as a caveat, though I hadn’t shared the link which is always great to have.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by girvo on Monday January 02, 2023 @04:14AM (#34215955)
Silly idea: could they put a M-series processor connected to a Xeon as a coprocessor to get the “benefits” of both wrt. adding their NPU stuff? Would that even make any sense?
Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by yywwbbn on Monday January 02, 2023 @05:09AM (#34216259)
Would that be very useful if you can have a discrete GPU?
Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by mark_undoio on Monday January 02, 2023 @05:48AM (#34216516)
Hardware level stuff is a bit lower than my area but...

The two tricky things I'd anticipate are:

What does it look like to hardware? Different CPUs speak different protocols to maintain a cache coherent view of memory. So they couldn't easily share memory in a completely natural way - but GPUs manage to share memory between host and GPU, so it can be done (just not necessarily as conveniently to software).

What does it look like to software? Lots of weird options here. Most convenient for software compatibility is it the Intel is also somehow running MacOS (or appears to be). I guess you could do that - it'd be like having a two node cluster in one machine. But that's not as convenient as being able to distribute computation between compatible CPUs.

None of that is a complete technical blocker to a company that controls their stack, I'd just guess it would make it too inconvenient / expensive for them to do.

That said - as an intern, years ago, I once had access to a piece of prototype hardware that had an x86 chip in one motherboard CPU socket and a non-x86 chip in the other (with various adaptation hardware to allow them to play nice). I think that was more a proof of concept than anything else, not necessarily viable without other hardware changes. Interesting nonetheless.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by coredog64 on Monday January 02, 2023 @11:54AM (#34220151)
Sun used to sell PCI cards with a complete Intel computer on them. You'd use your Sun workstation for the hard stuff, and then you'd let the P3/Celeron running Win2k handle Outlook or whatever other Win32-only software you needed.

I saw a lot of new-in-box examples cheap on eBay prior to Sun's implosion, so I suspect they weren't particularly popular and were primarily targeted at a few important customers that had some box to tick.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by mijkal on Monday January 02, 2023 @06:35PM (#34225297)
Once upon a time, Apple shipped a few models with both Motorola PPC + Intel x86 CPUs.

Eg: https://everymac.com/systems/apple/mac_quadra/specs/mac_quad...

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by girvo on Friday January 13, 2023 @12:06AM (#34364168)
Funnily enough, that's what I had in mind when I asked! Other companies have done similar in the past, though with modern chips, chipsets and protocols/timing requirements on lines, I think it might be more difficult?
Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by tcmb on Monday January 02, 2023 @02:27AM (#34215306)
Low volume simply means higher unit prices, doesn't it? The Mac Pro as an explicitly professional high-end machine is OK to be expensive. Its USP compared to fast x86 machines is that it runs macOS.
Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by ksec on Monday January 02, 2023 @02:32AM (#34215336)
>is OK to be expensive.

That is until you run the calculation when the cost of doing it are in the tens of thousands per unit. Suddenly it doesn't make much sense.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by daemontus on Tuesday January 03, 2023 @12:48PM (#34234935)
A 32-core or 64-core Threadripper Pro workstation with a few hundred GB of RAM can easily run north of $10.000 and people buy them. The price is not an issue if the computer is fast enough. The question is how fast would a hypothetical 40-core or 48-core M2 Extreme be.

Sure, Threadripper makes economical sense for AMD only when "subsidised" by EPYC/Ryzen sales and the shared chiplet architecture. But Apple has deep enough pockets for halo products. They are allegedly repurposing some of the binned/sub-par silicon into internal server hardware anyway.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by bpye on Monday January 02, 2023 @02:07AM (#34215203)
> How will Apple recoup the cost of designing a powerful chip for a product like the Mac Pro, which is presumably their lowest-selling product?

In their own datacentres?

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by eptcyka on Monday January 02, 2023 @02:15AM (#34215244)
I am under the impression they do not run macOS in their own datacenters. And, unlike mortals, if they need to run macOS in datacenters, they're not bound by their own license to never virtualize macOS on non-macOS hosts, they can do as they please.
Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by sneak on Monday January 02, 2023 @02:48AM (#34215415)
macOS or Linux, it doesn't matter - all hyperscale datacenter operators are going to move as much as possible to the highest perf/watt platform (ie ARM). Apple is a hyperscale datacenter owner and operator, if only for iCloud.

AWS is already doing so with Graviton.

It has nothing to do with macOS.

Graviton CPUs are not for sale. If Apple wants a million ARM cores to run iCloud, they are going to have to get TSMC to fab them.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by bpye on Monday January 02, 2023 @03:53AM (#34215834)
In addition to the other reply - Apple definitely _do_ run macOS in a datacentre for Xcode Cloud [0].

0 - https://twitter.com/khaost/status/1410332951963869185

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by nickolas_t on Monday January 02, 2023 @01:46AM (#34215096)
I expect the chip to be used in the upcoming Apple XR/MR headset.
Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by frankchn on Monday January 02, 2023 @01:53AM (#34215122)
A high-end chip usable in the Mac Pro will draw more power than the M1 Ultra at 60W. I don’t think they are gonna fit a chip like that into any wearable unless the device comes with a backpack with the processing elements (and battery) in it.
Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by cwp on Monday January 02, 2023 @03:43AM (#34215772)
It may be that an Apple Silicon Mac Pro isn't profitable, but it's still good business sense to produce it. It gives them a way to push the cutting edge in a way that none of their other products do, and the things they invent for it may filter down the product line. At the same time, the sort of professionals that buy Mac Pros are good customers to have, even if there aren't many of them. Ignoring them has hurt Apple in the past. At the end of the day, Apple can afford to lose a bit of money on a small volume product for a few generations while they work out the kinks.
Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by IshKebab on Monday January 02, 2023 @03:58AM (#34215860)
Presumably it isn't that low volume. Just low volume compared to their other products.

They can probably heavily base a more powerful chip on their existing designs but with more cores & cache, so design should be relatively cheap. Manufacturing the masks etc. is probably around $10m which is probably fine given how expensive Mac Pros are (and it would simplify their software if they can ditch Intel entirely).

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by yywwbbn on Monday January 02, 2023 @05:13AM (#34216280)
I think IO would be a bigger issue than scaling performance.

Somebody buying a mac pro would probably expect support for discrete and expandable ram.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by IshKebab on Monday January 02, 2023 @05:55AM (#34216553)
That's just connectors though isn't it? It uses a standard RAM interface already.

Maybe it needs more PCIe lanes but again that probably doesn't need much design work.

Re:What’s Left in the Apple Silicon Transition by matwood on Monday January 02, 2023 @06:56AM (#34216980)
> How will Apple recoup the cost of designing a powerful chip for a product like the Mac Pro, which is presumably their lowest-selling product?

They are not starting from scratch. The Apple Silicon MX chips all share a common base, and are related to the AX chips. When every product Apple sells is using some version of the same family of chips, a lot of the design cost is spread across all Apple devices.

Then it's just the incremental design cost that must be recouped for things like (speculated) off die RAM.