News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Novell Netware lost the battle against Windows NT (2013) by jacquesm on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:03PM (#34186982)
That only really happened from the 68030 onward didn't it? Until the 030 processes needed to be pretty careful not to step on each others address space.
Re:How Novell Netware lost the battle against Windows NT (2013) by monocasa on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:31PM (#34187316)
It started with the 68020 which came out with 68851 support in an Apple product in 1987.

Despite that Mac continued with only partial process protection up until the release of OSX in the early 2000s.

My point is their problem wasn't hardware support, but software compatibility.

Re:How Novell Netware lost the battle against Windows NT (2013) by jacquesm on Friday December 30, 2022 @12:40PM (#34187444)
Hm, ok, I wasn't aware that the 020's already had a full MMU on board, thanks for the correction. Probably they made too many assumptions about being able to mess around in other processes address space to enable it by the time they got it.
Re:How Novell Netware lost the battle against Windows NT (2013) by icedchai on Saturday December 31, 2022 @12:10AM (#34193788)
I think they are incorrect. The original Mac II (68020 machine) didn't ship with a full MMU. It had a socket for the 68851 though, if one wanted to add one. I somehow doubt many people did.

The newer Mac II's (IIx onward) were 68030-based, so they would've had MMUs built in. (They also released the Mac LC later on, which was 68020 based and had no socket for an MMU.)

Re:How Novell Netware lost the battle against Windows NT (2013) by jacquesm on Saturday December 31, 2022 @05:16PM (#34201326)
Did the operating system the machine shipped with know what to do with that MMU or was it ignored if installed and only used by alternative os's?
Re:How Novell Netware lost the battle against Windows NT (2013) by icedchai on Sunday January 01, 2023 @08:28PM (#34213154)
As far as I know, it was ignored until System 7, which added virtual memory support. A/UX (Apple Unix) required it, but that wasn't released until a year or so after the Mac II was initially available.
Re:How Novell Netware lost the battle against Windows NT (2013) by spookthesunset on Friday December 30, 2022 @01:59PM (#34188553)
God I remember those days. The Mac was way late to the party.

Was Win95 preemptive or cooperative? I totally forget. Pretty sure only the NT versions of windows were preemptive.

I recall there was a period of time when you’d run Windows 2000 because it was so much more stable than 98/ME. It worked mostly okay but it didn’t have as good of support for gaming and was pretty late to the party with DirectX support.

Re:How Novell Netware lost the battle against Windows NT (2013) by twoodfin on Friday December 30, 2022 @02:30PM (#34188966)
Win95 was preemptive and with full memory protection.

They obviously had to make compromises for performance and compatibility’s sake that made the long term move to NT essential, but I feel like the Chicago kernel team’s efforts have never (to my knowledge) been well-documented or -appreciated.

Re:How Novell Netware lost the battle against Windows NT (2013) by monocasa on Friday December 30, 2022 @02:47PM (#34189145)
I wouldn't say full memory protection. The shared arena was kind of a "don't touch but the hardware isn't enforcing it" shared 1GB region that all processes had access to.
Re:How Novell Netware lost the battle against Windows NT (2013) by GeekyBear on Friday December 30, 2022 @09:23PM (#34192813)
Definitely not full memory protection. A Win32 program could take down the whole computer.
Re:How Novell Netware lost the battle against Windows NT (2013) by burnte on Friday December 30, 2022 @03:18PM (#34189544)
Win95 was both, it didn't preempt Win12 apps, they'd all run in the same VM space, but 32bit ones could be preempted, but still take down the system. Full protetion eeded the NT kernel.
Re:How Novell Netware lost the battle against Windows NT (2013) by kjs3 on Friday December 30, 2022 @04:33PM (#34190366)
Not that Apple used it, but the even earlier 68010+68451 gave you segmented (not paged) memory protection.
Re:How Novell Netware lost the battle against Windows NT (2013) by Maursault on Friday December 30, 2022 @05:02PM (#34190624)
> software compatibility

A/UX ran with memory protection on the 68020 Mac II in 1988, probably in 1987 in beta also.

Re:How Novell Netware lost the battle against Windows NT (2013) by icedchai on Saturday December 31, 2022 @12:01AM (#34193741)
The Mac II didn't ship with a 68851, however. It was an extra add-on.