News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Waze tests new alerts warning drivers about roads with a ... by dietr1ch on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @06:48PM (#34167620)
Google maps has not been getting the hint at forbidden left turns :/

I'd guess that if you consistently avoid a left turn it could be because it's forbidden instead of because you miss it every single time. It's safe to assume that by now they take this kind of implicit feedback, but it either takes a long time to be processed or it's not happening on time-restricted left turns..

Re:Waze tests new alerts warning drivers about roads with a ... by gregoryl on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @07:04PM (#34167748)
It's bizarre that TikTok can genuinely determine roughly what I am in the mood for within a few videos, but Google Maps can't learn my preferences based on how I travel. The former seems far, far harder - and Google has almost my entire location history recorded from the last 10ish years!
Re:Waze tests new alerts warning drivers about roads with a ... by kccqzy on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @07:38PM (#34168021)
Because TikTok is built to be a personalized social media, but Google Maps is not built to be a personalized route finding service. I can imagine adding such personalization will make most of the caches in route finding unusable. I would instead argue Google has a much harder job than TikTok.
Re:Waze tests new alerts warning drivers about roads with a ... by gre on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @08:52PM (#34168531)
Google maps has gotten my route wrong many times.
Re:Waze tests new alerts warning drivers about roads with a ... by kccqzy on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @10:02PM (#34168967)
And you noticed it! If TikTok gave you a wrong suggestion you wouldn't even notice. That's what I mean by consequences.
Re:Waze tests new alerts warning drivers about roads with a ... by danuker on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @07:20PM (#34167858)
What benefit does Google get from improving Maps? Does it make them more money? They get location data even if you don't use Maps.
Re:Waze tests new alerts warning drivers about roads with a ... by photonbeam on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @09:39PM (#34168809)
They show ads in the maps app, so that effects revenues
Re:Waze tests new alerts warning drivers about roads with a ... by photonbeam on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @09:41PM (#34168822)
For iOS, google maps is very often the only way google can geographically target you with accuracy for better ads, as users will deny location requests to the other google apps
Re:Waze tests new alerts warning drivers about roads with a ... by bbarnett on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @07:20PM (#34167862)
Google doesn't care. Maps is there to sell ad space to companies, you're the product, not the customer.

To highlight this, it is literally impossible to choose your own route. Google will randomly redirect you, will keep nagging, while you constantly have to click 'no'.

For example, let's say you are driving from New York to California. There are two main paths, dictated by the mountains.

Google knows this, and lets you pick the southern, or northern route.

The southern route is 5 hours longer, but gee, no snow! Google doesn't have "avoid snow", and 5 hours longer becomes much faster, if the northern route has a storm.

So you pick the southern route.

Congrats! For the next 50 hours of driving, google will happily exclaim "I found a faster route!" and switch you over, unless you click cancel.

This means that you are constantly, sometimes as often as every 5 minutes, forced to interact with maps while driving, or be forced to redirect as google wishes.

This 5 year old bug is well known, people complain about it everywhere, but google could care less.

Re:Waze tests new alerts warning drivers about roads with a ... by xyzelement on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @08:48PM (#34168514)
If I was the product manager on maps, I'd keep it exactly as it is.

The worst thing is for maps to be "silent" when there's a route available that can save you half a day of driving. You don't want that but an average driver does.

You are basically a power user who knows better than the map which is fine, but then just add a waypoint that forces the Southern route and go on with your life.

For the average user, nagging them to get the 5 hour faster route is the right strategy.

Re:Waze tests new alerts warning drivers about roads with a ... by bbarnett on Thursday December 29, 2022 @12:42AM (#34169907)
For the average user, nagging them to get the 5 hour faster route is the right strategy.

Extremes much?

You act as if there are two options only. Relentlessly nag the user, and not tell them at all.

There is another. Ask the user, and be done with it.

When I click on decline, I mean it. Everyone does. And it isn't just nagging, it literally forces you to click no every time, or your route changes.

When in traffic. In seconds. Immediately. Over and over.

It is a terrible design choice.

Re:Waze tests new alerts warning drivers about roads with a ... by WWLink on Thursday December 29, 2022 @04:46AM (#34171066)
Last time I encountered that, I just ignored it and it kept me on the same route.
Re:Waze tests new alerts warning drivers about roads with a ... by shkkmo on Thursday December 29, 2022 @08:16AM (#34172294)
You can just add an intermediate waypoint on the southern route.
Re:Waze tests new alerts warning drivers about roads with a ... by mjcohen on Thursday December 29, 2022 @11:38PM (#34181839)
In the browser desktop maps, you can select your exact route by dragging points on the path. I wish this could be done on the mobile app.
Re:Waze tests new alerts warning drivers about roads with a ... by dahdum on Wednesday December 28, 2022 @10:06PM (#34168985)
> It's safe to assume that by now they take this kind of implicit feedback, but it either takes a long time to be processed or it's not happening on time-restricted left turns..

I wouldn't count on that. I've been exiting a Costco for years now where Google Maps tells you to take an impossible left turn due to a divided road. Google should have a mountain of data showing those directions are never, ever, taken. Street view shows it to be impossible too.

If they are actually looking at that type of data they aren't doing much with it.